Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Posts

Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#1

Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Pete LaBelle

>Guys -

Spent Saturday looking at bandsaws and, although a 16 or 18" saw would answer more needs, a 1hp 14" will probably follow me home in the near future. A comment was made on another web site that I had not thougth of, in that if I go with a riser block, longer blades will be needed. Getting a riser block well after the saw is purchased risks the current stock of blades not being usefull once the riser block is installed.

95% of my sawing will be able to be done on a 6" capacity saw.

Question to you folks with riser blocks on your saws: Are there any drawbacks to having riser blocks on a saw? Most of my work will be less than 2" thick, but once in a while........

Thanx......

Pete

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#2

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Pete,

As far as the longer blades go, I would bet that if you bought the riser block kit when you bought the saw, your dealer would probably swap you a longer blade for the one that comes on the saw.

The only drawback that I can see on adding a riser block to your saw is that the 1 HP motor that was plenty powerful for the 2" stuff suddenly becomes marginal for the bigger stuff. I have a 1.5 HP on my old Rockwell and wish I had a 3 sometimes.

Gary

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#3

I have a Ouija Brand 14" saw with riser.

Barry Irby

>Actually, its one of the major brands, but I think it may have been manufactured by the same people that make Ouija boards. It seems to have some other worldly forces that direct the cut no matter what I do with my hands.

Kidding aside, I suppose the riser block does add a little flexibility to the frame, but it seems to have almost no effect on day to day use. If you think about it, making light cuts in stock under two inches would putt he least stress on the frame. OTOH, making the occasional ten or twelve inch cut would put the most stress on the frame, so its a sort of double whammy.

I added the riser block later and gave away the older blades. I did not have many on hand so it was not much of a sacrifice, but if I were doing it again I would either go with a bigger saw or get the riser block initially.

I have a love/hate relationship with the saw. I find it annoying that it take thirty minutes to an hour to change from a "circle" cutting to a resaw blade and then tune the saw to cut straight. Its takes about the same time to change it back. So the answer is to have two saws. One with a 6" cut that stays set up to cut circles and one with about a 12 or 14" throat that stays set up to resaw and rip. So I went from having no bandsaw to wishing I had two. Or three. I find the blade changing to be much more tedious than a TS.

Back to your question, Assuming I am going to own one saw I have no objection to the riser block. If I had known how much I was going to spend on accessories like Guides, tension release, dust collection, etc, I would have looked harder at a bigger saw. You can do everything a smaller saw will do on a larger one, but there are things a larger one will do better or that a smaller won�t do at all.

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#4

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Pete.

I have a Jet with the riser. I don't see any draw backs. But I'm not too anal about its cuts either. I have a WoodSlicer on it 98% of the time. I get pretty darn clean resaw cuts with it. The resawing I've done has been with walnut, cherry, and maple. No problems. I just go slow and easy and let the saw do the work.

I have no regrets with it. I suppose there are drawbacks but for me (a weekend woodworker) it works.

Joe

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#5

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

> The only drawback that I can see on adding a riser block to your saw is that the 1 HP motor that was plenty powerful for the 2" stuff suddenly becomes marginal for the bigger stuff. I have a 1.5 HP on my old Rockwell and wish I had a 3 sometimes.

I do have a 3 HP on my Delta, and let me tell you that I don't regret having done the swap (from a 3/4 HP) one bit...

However, Louis Iturra mentions that while the saw can take a 5 HP motor, the selection of blades available makes it a waste to install more than 2 HP on the saw. Since I sped up the blade speed (4000 vs. 3000 FPM) I can take advantage of the extra power.

DC

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#6

Ellis Walentine

It's all relative

Ellis Walentine

>You've heard some good input here, Pete, but to put it all in perspective, the power issue is the biggest drawback of increasing your resaw capacity, unless you also increase the horsepower of the saw to provide the added cutting force necessary for wider resawing.

The blade length issue shouldn't be too serious, as band saw blades don't really last very long and they aren't terribly expensive.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#7

Main drawback: change the height, not the wheel

wilbur

>The main drawback to adding a riser to a 14" bandsaw to get more vertical capacity as opposed to going for a bigger bandsaw altogether is that the blade still has to make that turn around a 14" wheel. I assume you want to do this for resawing purposes. Resawing benefits from a stiffer blade, which usually means a thicker blade, which will be stressed more if it is bent around a 14" wheel, as opposed to a 16" or 18" wheel. The added stress means a shorter lifespan for your bandsaw blade. A larger bandsaw will also typically be outfitted with a heftier motor, which will also make resawing easier. You can also run the blade on a bigger bandsaw at a higher speed, which (guess what?) also makes resawing easier.

For comparison, the price difference between a Grizzly 14" bandsaw plus riser and their 17" bandsaw, which gives you the same resaw capacity, is $363 with shipping. Comparing 14" and larger bandsaws from other companies gives you about the same price difference. I would say it is worth it. (But even better would be to find a bigger bandsaw used.)

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#8

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

Pete LaBelle

>Guys -

Good feedback thus far. Initial question of the saw losing any abilities going with the riser apparently prove false.

Currently, I haven't had the need for much, if any, resawing. Though if the saw has the abiltiy, the door may be opened for this avenue to persue.

The bigger reason for a taller saw opening would be to cut thicker bowl blanks into rounds. My current chinese saw of 18 years limits me to 6" thick.

Other question: The 14" JET with 1hp motor is both 110 & 220 volt operation. One man I talked to said he got more ooomf out of his saw converting it to 220. Are there others out there who have experienced the same?

Also, if I have the patience, can I assume the large HP motors are only a function of speed of cut ?

Thanx.....

Pete

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#9

There is one...

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>At least with the current crop of 14" bandsaws, there actually is a drawback with the addition of a riser block.

It's not a big deal. In fact, most people don't even notice it. But it's a drawback nonetheless.

Your 14" bandsaw is now a 13.5" (or is it 13"? I don't remember exactly) bandsaw.

-- Hoa

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#10

Just one: installing the darn thing by yourself.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#11

It's the same issue

Curly Smith

>The power requirements discussed relate to the thickness of the wood, not whether you're resawing or cutting bowl blanks. The max that you'll be able to cut with the riser is about 10.5". If you'll routinely be using the saw to its max capacity then you might be well advised to move to a bigger saw.

Other factors that will influence power requirements are:

- cut slower as you suggested (allow the blade to cut and clear)

- keep the blade sharp (resharpen frequently)

- use the proper blade

There's no power advantage to running a 1 hp motor on 220v versus 110v - it's still a 1 hp motor. Wiring for 220v just draws fewer amps.

Ultimately, there's probably not that much downside to the Jet with the riser. If you later determine that it's unsuitable for your needs then you can sell it and get a bigger saw. Sure, you'll lose 20% of what you paid but you're not paying all that much anyway. And, as was mentioned above, the step up to the next saw is pretty large.

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#12

Tru dat!

Dave Morris

>Whereas the riser block is the same width as the base of the saw's upper section, that base "was" below the level of the table's surface. Cutting width was limited to the space between the blade on one side and the blade guard on the other. Adding the riser means the saw's cutting width is reduced to the space between the blade on the right and the "riser" on the left.

So unless I'm cutting upside down "L" shaped brackets, cutting width is limited to 12-7/8 inches.

But I didn't install the riser for extra width. I installed it for extra height. Now there is 12-3/8 inches max under the upper guide. Doesn't really matter, cuz most of the time I'll only need the taller capacity for about 8-9" in height, with only a couple-four inches width at max on the same stick of wood, so the riser was still needed.

Good call, Hoa.

Dave--- who figures if he starts working with 14" X 14" sticks or bigger, he's gunna need a LOT bigger saw anyway

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#13

Re: Just one: installing the darn thing by yoursel

Lee Brubaker

>I have the 14" Delta & ran it several years before installing a riser block. I'm a little old guy 76 years old. Installed it myself with no trouble at all. Actually, the hardest touble I encountered with this saw was the initial set-up. Found installing the 1 hp motor in the enclosed cabinet a bit of a "grunt".

Sawed some 12" cherry with it & it was slow going with just 1 hp but it did get the job done.Most of my need for the riser kit is in the 6" to 8" range so still using 1 hp.

Lee

Re: Bandsaw riser block - - drawbacks ?

#14

Thanx again for your valued words of wisdom....

Pete LaBelle

>