Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Review: NYW on DIY

Posts

Review: NYW on DIY

#1

Review: NYW on DIY

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Well, I DVRed the inaugural offering of The New Yankee Workshop on DIY this morning (Jigs, Part One) and just finished watching it. I think I'm going to be sick.

Most of you know that I've put a fair amount of time into chronicling the tools Norm has used in 19 years of TNYW. That has entailed watching (and timing) a lot of TNYW episodes (243, so far). I didn't start video taping episodes until around 1999—ten years into the show—so I had to rely on HGTV rebroadcasts for all of the early years.

As I viewed all of the episodes I learned that while the original PBS content totalled 24 minutes and 18 seconds (I'm not sure why the odd number, but it's been consistent over roughly eight years of actual PBS content that I have), HGTV edited their airings down to 21 minutes and 45 seconds—also consistent over twelve years worth of programming, or 156 episodes (all that HGTV ever aired). I had an overlap of a few episodes in the late '90s for which I had both PBS and HGTV versions and it was interesting to see what they cut out—it wasn't a lot, mostly setups and an occasional orientation shot—but generally not a lot of meat. Of course I can't really say how much had been cut from the earlier years because I had no comparison recordings.

This morning marked the return of supplemental (to PBS) airings of TNYW since HGTV ended their contract several years ago. I eagerly anticipated it, since I've been transferring all of my VHS recordings over to DVD. Although the VCR tapes were done from fresh, SP recordings of either original PBS broadcasts or HGTV broadcasts of the earlier years, I had to re-record them in EP in order to get all 13 episodes of a season onto a single two hour tape. Consequently, there's a lot of noise (and jitter, due to different VCR machines involved) on my archive tapes. I was hoping to be able to get pristine transfers from my DVR to the DVDs with the new DIY offering. Here's what happened:

The DIY version (at least for this first program) totalled 19 minutes and 43 seconds of content. That's 4½ minutes out of the original 24+ minutes. I don't think it possible to find enough non-critical material to take out of a 24½ program to get to where DIY apprently feels they need to be, but I thought I'd at least check against the PBS version I have. So I pulled out my archive and watched. Quelle horror! Sure, there were a couple of minor cuts that I noticed at first, but after building the panel cutter, panel raising jig, and circle cutting jig, they stopped. They cut out one of the items entirely—the finger boards. I was shocked enough when I looked at my stopwatch on the first viewing and saw 19:43, but as I viewed the original and found one fourth of the projects missing I was simply stunned.

I think I'm going to be sick. I know I said that already. I don't think I can say it too much. If that's the standard to which DIY is going to air TNYW episodes, I'll recommend you not bother to watch. In order to make that number, there will simply have to be significant content excised which will render the program virtually useless. And I'm stuck with putting my noisy, jittery, EP recordings onto DVD. Or, I can buy 200+ episodes from TNYW at $15 a pop…probably not.

What a disappointment.

Rod


P.S. The missing content and its impact on new viewers is my real concern, not the quality of my recordings going to DVD.


Woodbutcher.net for those who may not know.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#2

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Wow. Considering the "standard" for a 1/2-hour program is generally about 22 minutes of content to 8 minutes of commercials, dropping to below 20 minutes of programming is craziness. Boooo.

Jason

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#3

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>DIY is a premium channel from my cable provider. I'd considered subscribing, but after your revelations, I'll not be paying extra for chopped-for-ads programming.

Rant Warning: Ads are taking over all forms of TV. We have one local station that has actual programing of 6 hours in a 24-hour day; the other 18 hours are infomercials. How can these folks get a broadcast license? What a waste of airwaves!

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#4

Further rant to your rant…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>rant

I didn't mention the splash ads or crawls that popped on screen at various points. It's gotten so you can't even watch a first run network program without being inundated with ads or promos during the program.

I'm considering waiting for the DVD sets to come out for my favorites in order to see the original programming without all the distractions.

/rant

Rod

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#5

Misery Loves Company

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Rod,

Thank you for the time and effort expended in your review/comparisons. I am not a fan of DIY channel to begin with. When I read your review, it reinforced objectively my own feelings. Almost all TV now exists to advertise and sell product rather than air well crafted shows which are sponsered. My own beef is that I am paying for some TV premium cable channels which take my cable money and then force me to watch commercials on top of that. Its like paying twice.

George

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#6

Re: Misery Loves Company

Ted Wong

>Thats why we should support PBS and its local affiliates or at least let your congressmen know you want them to support legislation that will continue its support.

Although many programs have sponsors or corporate underwriting its not the same as being blasted every 7 minutes with a 2 or 3 minutes of commercials.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#7

Re: Misery Loves Company

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I DID support PBS - but "my shows" all seem to be broadcast Saturday AM and they're the first to get bumped by the ever-increasing fund raisers that they do. So I called/wrote and was told "donate more and we won't do that". So I did, but they kept on doing it. I called/wrote again and was told "it's for the greater good that we do this, but thanks for the $$". In other words, thanks - SUCKER!

Never again - not another nickle. I love the concept of public boradcasting, but hate the execution.

The thing they don't get, is in the more people they tick off by doing this the less $$ they get, which means the more people are going to get PO'd and stop donating...

Rob

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#8

Re: Misery Loves Company

Ted Wong

>Yeah I guess it isn't fair that each time fundraiser time comes around the same shows seem to get bumped. I really don't care anymore since I rarely watch NYW, Hometime, TOH, etc. It annoyed me when I did watch those shows. But as you said they need their fundraisers to keep the boat afloat. I think its a small inconvenience to put up with for four weeks out of the year. As far as I know most of the programming that is preempted is shown at another time during the year would have been reruns. Classic example of a station going under is our local NPR station. They are walking a tightrope, clinging for survival because the fundraisers aren't generating the revenue they need. I think there are a lot of listeners out there that aren't ponying up their share and will miss it when it's gone.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#9

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

Ed in NY

>Sorry to hear that Rod, I have almost all of the episodes on tape, except one, "Old Pine Bar" (for some reason I missed that one!) or on DVD. I began recording them to my hard drive on my computer about 2 years ago from the PBS shows and then putting them on DVD. I'm also in the process of transferring my VHS versions to DVD right now. I plan on putting one show on one DVD.

I'm so sick and tired of the HGTV/DIY shows. When they first started out they showed some quality stuff, like NYWS. Now every show is a guy and a girl who know nothing, putting a room together on a extemely tight schedule using cardboard and tissue paper to make furniture. It's no surprise that DIY is messing up NYWS, they've messed up almost everything else.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#10

YES!

Ed in NY

>I love to watch old episodes of Bonanza and Gunsmoke on TV Land, but it drives me INSANE when they squash the credits at the end of the show to the side to play another promo. I actually wrote an e-mail to them about it....never heard back from them.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#11

Re: Misery Loves Company

Ed in NY

>That's my biggest complaint too. NYWS hasn't been on for weeks here in NY. Fund raising time. They seem to switch their programming around all the time. It's annoying!

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#12

Re: Misery Loves Company

Larry in NW Ohio

>Ted I see that you don`t watch commercial TV to much. 2-3 min. of commercial, hech thats been 3 years ago, 4 min. is about the norm now. Larry in Ohio

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#13

Response to both of your posts.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> Although many programs have sponsors or corporate underwriting its not the same as being blasted every 7 minutes with a 2 or 3 minutes of commercials.

I have at least one PBS recording of a TNYW episode that is loaded with scrolls for some event they were going to be running. I agree that their broadcasting model is an improvement, but as someone pointed out (I think on the wreck) 24 minutes per hour of content is pretty much the same standard, whether it's PBS or commercial network. The difference is in how (if) it's broken up.

> I think its a small inconvenience to put up with for four weeks out of the year.

If only. At one time it might have been as little as four weeks out of the year (I used to refer to them as the quarterly whine), but the number has steadily been getting greater and the time longer. The local Orlando outlet is now in its third consecutive weekend of begging and it is their second session this year so far. Fortunately, one of my other PBSes that I get on the satellite doesn't do it as often or extensively, and the third one doesn't do it at all.

I sort of wonder what kind of thinking goes on at those places. I get the impression that the market they're targeting in their pledge drives isn't exactly your blue collar, everyman demographic. Yet the programs they preempt don't seem to be in that same demographic. How, then, do they expect a quid pro quo from the viewers?

Rod

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#14

Re: Further rant to your rant�

J D Thomas

>This is EXACTLY why I pretty much don't watch anything on TV anymore. I'd rather read a book. I've had a Tivo for about 5 years and I can't even watch those programs due to the spectacularly annoying crawl ads. Some of them even have sound that overrides the program I'm trying to watch!!!

Television is such a wasted medium. Too bad, since it could be such an informative medium.

J D Thomas

ThomaStudios

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#15

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

Ted Wong

>Well I guess it just highlights my point. If you want the real thing someones got to pay for it. The cost of production always goes north. So if a PBS station comes on for more than twice a year looking for $$ someone better pony up so they don't have to do it so often. Rod would know better than I would since I'm not a big NYW fan, even with the pledge drives does a PBS station end up showing all the episodes, or do some episodes get preempted and never shown? If it is the former (which I suspect) then what is the big deal if it's not on one particular Saturday but another Saturday a week or two down the line?

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#16

Former, I believe, but it upsets the cosmos...____

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#17

The moral of this story.

Virgil Johnson

>Kill your TV.In the 100 hours it takes to watch 200 episodes a of a DIY show a nice piece of furniture could be built,actual skills developed,dust created,calories burned,confidence increased and the list could go on. We had our cable TV disconnected nearly ten years ago. I was actually nervous about getting rid of it for some reason but we have not missed it.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#18

... and they wonder why fewer

Mike Farinella

>and fewer people watch TV. I don't - I'd rather watch my computer.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#19

Bill Blasic

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

Bill Blasic

>Well to set you staight here in Erie they get preempted and when they come back after 3 or 4 weeks they are not shown. They allow 13 weeks for the series and then they run their begging stuff for 3 or 4 weeks right in the middle.

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#20

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

David Hay @ Denver

>While I'm sure there are some decent shows on the likes of HGTV, DIY, etc. Whenever I happen to tune in (usually at the gym) it seems that most of the shows follow a format where they spend the first half of the segment between commercials recapping what the place looked like and what they've done, then show someone drive a nail or glue some cardboard together, and then go to a commercial break....repeat.

Guess that is one of the many reasons we don't have cable/satellite TV ;)

David

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#21

Amen, brother

Bill Hylton

>

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#22

Re: The moral of this story.

Dan Donaldson

>I killed mine about a year or so ago. The kids were always arguing about what to watch, and it was all junk anyway, so I disconnected it. after a month, we didn't really miss it, so I canceled the service. Best thing that I ever did. I did keep the high speed internet connection though ;-)

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#23

So, NYWS, how 'bout a "boxed set"?

John E. in SC

>I for one would love to see a "boxed set", or "Season 1, etc" set of DVD's for the NYWS. If sold at a reasonable price (not $15 per episode), I think these would sell like gangbusters. Most other series have done this, including my other favorite, MASH. They would still sell their measured drawings to woodworkers who are actually trying to build the particular project, and as a matter of fact, they would probably sell more, as more WW'ers would be "exposed" to more projects by watching more shows.

I know for me, NYWS is not even available. I can't find it on PBS or HGTV anymore, and I don't (won't) subscribe to DIY for the small amount of TV I watch.

So, who wants to start the petition? :)

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#24

Re: The moral of this story.

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>I lived without television for a few of my bachelor years,, purposely to wean myself away from it and be more active in everything else in life. I loved not having one and preached tv-less life as often as I could.. Mostly just to get a stir out of folks :)

Today, my wife and I have a television, together watch maybe 1 to 1.5 hrs. per night , 6-8 channels are off-air, no cable or satellite out here.

I would get rid of the thing if it were my choice, but it isn't.

I think most of us can easily life without it, cable, remotes, the whole thing.. It's amazing how creative one becomes when the box isn't there to turn on.

Norman

Re: Review: NYW on DIY

#25

Ironic

Tony - Memphis

>We just decided to kill our DirectTv service. We went without for years and kept hearing about all these great channels like HGTV and DIY. But, after having it for a couple of years, we've decided its mostly junk and we don't watch it that much anyway. I do enjoy the National Geographic channel and a few shows on the History channel, but not enough to keep paying I guess. Part of our realization was equating the yearly sum we pay to how much a couple of yard projects we wanted to do or a trip to the beach! Plus, I don't need anything to give me an excuse to sit on my rump anyway.

Tony