Reply to Mr. Hamler
Robert Hutchins
>Hello AJ,
Looks like I hit buttons I didn't know were there. Sorry if I was the cause of elevating your blood pressure, but my opening should have told you that the response was going to be critical. So, here's my rebuttal to your characterizations of me.
First:
"You don't know Gail. You don't know the producer. You don't know the writer. You haven't even seen a whole show, but a five-minute clip. And yet, you KNOW somehow that it's all "calculated to show her rear end ... breasts heaving."
You are absolutely correct. I don't know any of the people. I have no interest in the show or the individuals - financial or otherwise. I am a disinterested party with no emotional or other axe to grind than to evaluate and reflect what I saw based on my experience and on what I'd like to see in a new woodworking show. I watched the clip 3 times to ensure that I was making observations and expresssing opinions only about what I saw. I only know what I saw in the clip.
I made only one of six points about sexism, but you took it as my major text. I don't recall ever seeing a shot on TNYW or TOH of any of the guys going up steps shot from the lower floor - always from above. The stairway shot is taught in film production classes to increase the sense of opening of the subject - as if entering upon a new space and discovering something new. They also teach that humans find facial expressions more interesting than body movements (ergo closeups as opposed to wide shots) and that body movements are used to evoke more subtle, primal responses. Look it up. Read the psychololgy behind visual arts. Don't blame the critic's observation. Remember who told the world that the emperor was naked - a guileless child.
Second:
"But if Gail does the exact same thing, why, it's all "calculated" to be prurient."
My paragraph said "some of the shots". There were only two shots that I found particularly objectionable. I've never seen Vila, Abrams or even the young redhead (the 'meat' proffered to distaff viewers on TOH) positioned in the lens in quite the same way that the producer chose to show the young lady. Those shots would be considered 'meat' shots in any film class. They are not classed that way only in my imagination. And, in no way did I ascribe those shots to Gail or her intentions. They are ascribed to the writer/director/editor/producer of the clip, for only that person (or persons) is (are) responsible
Third:
"If it's copied so closely, then how is it so clearly a calculated attempt at appealing to a prurient interest, when the show you say it's copied from does not?"
I separated the comments about prurience from the comments about plagiarism for a reason. It is the blocking of the shots - intro, scene setting, subject exposure, project adoption, project execution, project finishing, next episode's project - that copies the TNYW formula.
Fourth:
"But hey, let's not stop there. I suppose, since there were no black people in the video let's call it racist too. Why, not? They must have purposely wanted to appeal to whites only, huh. Why those filthy, blatant racists."
You're putting words in my mouth. Is this because you can't attack my statements with anything but hypotheticals? This isn't allowed in the discipline of debate but is used only theatrically.
Fifth:
"But don't make up criticisms based on your imaginary view of how you think the world runs."
My view is my view and could thus be called 'imaginary' because it arises in my head, but I wonder if you would have used the term so pejoratively if I had praised the show? Another attempt to impugn the critic and not the criticism? And, what did I say about how the world is, or should be, run? More theatrics instead of debate?
Sixth:
"Really? You've just put down everyone one on this forum -- and others -- who posted anything positive about it.?"
This is the closest you've come to striking a reasonable riposte, but it fails because it assumes that my point was to insult those who viewed the video positively rather than to accept the fact that it was aimed narrowly at those who created it. The criticism was hyperbole designed to make blatantly clear the opinion of the writer that the show has aimed far too low intellectually to appeal to the vast majority of the people who visit the Island - or people interested in woodworking generally, for that matter.
Seventh:
"Your baseless accusations are, frankly, offensive. Far more offensive than any perceived "calculated" anything on Gail's part, certainly sexism. I think you owe her an apology.
As far as accusations, I made none. I made criticisms based on the content of the video and known precepts about film production - far from baseless (unless the video is baseless). I also expressed opinions designed to enlighten and encourage a higher quality product. That I did so with a sharp pen calculated to drive home the points is an offense to which I plead "knowingly guilty." For giving offense to you, A.J., and for any offense I might have given to Gail - or to any Islander - I most humbly apologize.
I carefully crafted my post - after carefully studying the video, more than once or twice - specifically avoiding any criticism of the young lady. She acquitted herself very well in the video. My missive was aimed at the guy who posted the original topic. My motivations were entirely to encourage a higher quality product instead of another me-too series. It was honest criticism based on some knowledge of photo journalism and photography in general. No, I'm not a professional in that field, but I've done extensive reading, taken a few workshops, and even taken a couple of college level credit courses in the subject.
This response is not meant to be inflammatory, designed to create heat without merit. (Nor was the original.) But the response to my post impugned my integrity and knowledge which I cannot - by my nature - let go unchallenged. I only hope that my defensive response will be taken as civil and will be perceived as being honest and fair, for that was the spirit in which it was written - without animosity or the desire to 'flame'.
BobH