Watched it 3 Times
Robert Hutchins
>Maybe I'm just a crusty old b@st@rd, but I think it is far too trite. Realizing that what we saw was a highly edited clip, I believe there was sufficient to indicate extremely poor scripting.
1) The opening seconds of camera roll will, presumably, be redundant from show to show. If so, it will get old faster than a live skunk at a church picnic.
2) The scene setting shot of the Mayflower replica could easily have been left out with the dialogue covering where the original was being viewed. Also, the model is formulaic NYW - I'd worry about legal hassles for copying it too closely.
3) Some of the camera shots were gratuitous sexism, IMO. You don't have to use sex to interest woodworkers in making sawdust. Sex has been used far too much to sell far too many worthless products on today's TV shows. Mind you, I have nothing against an attractive lady as the demonstrating expert, but shots calculated to show her rear end ascending steps or her breasts heaving boards are prurient and offensive to good taste. It's only a short step from those choices to having cleavage shots like the stupid home improvement shows. Please don't waste my time. It is far too precious. I'm surprised the distaff side of our community hasn't chimed in here - but these ladies are probably too discreet and tasteful to point out what this crusty curmudgeon will.
4) There was virtually no content that would attract any but the rawest tyro to the craft. No discussion of material selection, nothing about style or even utility of the finished piece. Given the popularity of trunks/chests as subjects for endeavors by those of all skill levels, all opportunity to educate or inform was ignored. Shame on whoever wrote the script and/or edited the footage.
5) Why were dimensions not referenced? why was joinery technique not addressed? Why was there no consideration of choice of finish? If the content of this video is indicative of what's to come, I predict it will not last long - certainly never have the staying power of a TNYW or TOH.
6) The proffered show appeals to an intellectual capacity that reaches double digits only when multiplied by a factor greater than 3 or raised to another power. There are far too many of these around. If you want to produce a show, shoot for something that stimulates, not some 'me-too' rip off of another's idea. The subject matter is sufficiently deep to have kept the interest of individuals here on the Island sustained for decades. Why not exploit the richness of the subject and make something worthwhile?
If the young lady isa as talented and smart as AJ says she is - which I don't doubt, she will either leave the show or insist on much, much better scripting and production.
You asked!
BobH