Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Is hide glue appropriate?

Posts

Is hide glue appropriate?

#1

Is hide glue appropriate?

Bill Sands

>I�d like your input. What are your thoughts on using hide glue for kitchen cutting boards? The glue is strong and nontoxic and the boards are not designed to be immersed, but rather to be cleaned with a damp cloth. Do you think that level of moisture would affect the bond? Thanks

Bill Sands

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

#2

Lee Grindinger

I don't say this very often

Lee Grindinger

>PVA is a better choice for cutting boards. PVA is more shock resistant, more water resistant, and cutting boards are not intended to last for a very long time. PVA is stronger in it's early life and nontoxic.

Lee

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

#3

JL

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

JL

>Don't get me wrong. I like hide glue a lot. I use it in chairs and furniture. I don't think it is appropriate to use for a cutting board for several reasons.

Yes - you say the cutting board will only be wiped off with a damp cloth. That might be true - most of the time. You might not be the only one using that cutting board. Someone else would give a quick rinse...

Kitchens are moist enviroments - splashes, etc.

Many foodstuffs contain a lot of moisture (especially tomatoes :)).

Hide glue consists of modified "proteins" - it might be nontoxic to bacteria, mold, etc. - things that occasionally visit cutting boards. They (bacteria, etc.) might find the glue "tasty".

I've used Gorilla Glue, yellow glue (Titebond moisture resistant) and one or two others. I didn't like the Gorilla Glue - too much of a line. I liked the Titebond.

My $0.02.

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

#4

Save the cows

Bill Sands

>Thanks guys. I�m convinced. I�ll �stick� with PVA. I�ve been using Titebond II with good results and it seems that there�s no need to fix something that ain�t broke. I just like the idea of using non-synthetic materials on these old time boards.

Bill Sands

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

#5

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I just wanted to throw out a few thoughts regarding hide glue and its use on a cutting board.

First thing we all tend to forget is that up untill about 70 or 80 years ago all wood items were made with hide glue. his would include all those beautiful old butcher blocks along with exterior windows and doors. while many old butcher blocks may be the worse for wear they certianly stood up to a lifetime of servise and survived may a cleaning with out comming appart or making people ill.

I think the reversibility of hide glue is over stated and simplified. While it is true that it is the only 100% reversable adhesive, just wiping with a wet rag or splashing will not make a hide glue joint fail. If only it were so easy! I have only wanted to unglue one joint and it was very dificult and took a fair bit of time along with some heat and moisture and in the end I didn't use enough of any of these and ended up with the wood breaking before the glue joint gave way.

the last point I wanted to make is that hide glue can be make to be water proof by treating the wood with a formalin/borax solution just prior to glue up.

All that being said I don't want to imply that hide glue would be the best choice for a cutting board. I just wanted to throw out the idea that it certianly has been used in the past and if you wished to try it out it likely will not make anyone ill or fall apart during normal use.

Robin Corell

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

#6

Re: Is hide glue appropriate?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Hide Glue wasn't the only one. There was also casein glue made from milk protien. It was a lot more water resistant than hide glue. Casein was a powder and mixed with water shortly before use.