>My wife and I are restoring old plank flooring in a rental unit. I need to know what the best material would be to fill the gaps between the planks. The floors have been stripped and sanded and we want to stain them. Also, would we apply the stain first then fill in the gaps? Any advice would be appreciated.
>Hi BK, you don't want to fill the gaps, wood floors move. If you have anything else to fill such as nail holes I suggest you fill them before your last coat of finish.
>Thank you, The gaps are quite wide in some places. I don't have the resources to spend alot of time and money and since it's a rental, I still need to fill in some of the wider gaps. I've considered silicone caulk, wood putty and even grout. I've seen pictures of old pine planks that have wide gaps in "This Old House" but they never mention how the floors were actually restored beyond sanding and staining.
Those "gaps" are very typical of old plank flooring and are quite coveted in old homes in the Northeast. Think of them as "character" and proof of authenticity 8-). The downside, other than appearance, is that they are dirt collectors. I am not aware of much you can do that would be easy and, especially since this is a rental unit, I would do nothing except enjoy your beautifully restored antique flooring; and ask the landlord to knock off a bit from your next months rent for a job well-done 8-).
>I have seen floors caulked with rope caulking similiar to what you would use on a wooden boat. You need to drive it in with a caulking iron with the same amount of force you would use on a boat hull. Holds up surprisingly well with a good appearance.
>Echoing Andre, I've seen them filled with rope (just plain sisal), either stained to match or not. I live in a 185 year old farmhouse with wide board ash floors. The gaps vary, from 1/16" to 1/4" or more in some spots and they do collect dirt (that's what the crevice tool on the vacuum is for :) ).
I refinished the floors this summer and they look good (if I do say so myself), gaps and all. In some earlier attempt to remedy this, the previous homeowner filled the gaps with putty. It has stayed in some areas, not in others, but never actually filled the gaps. The putty actually caused the floor to buckle in some spots because it prevented expansion.
Personally, I, don't like the way the rope looks (tends to emphasize the gaps and makes the floor look striped).
>bk; I recently did my 100 year floor and filled the large, 1/2" gaps with similar wooden 1/4" shims. I'm pleased with the results, hardly notice them. I would notice any filler, especially if it appeared obvious after poly. joey