Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Grain Orientation

Posts

Grain Orientation

#1

Grain Orientation

Mark McC

>I have been asked to make a table similiar to the one below.

My question is about grain orientation whether it should be straight up and down running parallel with the leg,askew to the leg. other?

Which is the strongest method?

Thanks

M


img

Re: Grain Orientation

#2

Re: Grain Orientation

Keith Newton

>I think you should probably go with plumb, to keep the bottom portion from becoming too short-grained. This would be the most vulnerable part. When choosing your lumber, You might look for some grown crook to improve the strength, unless you want to try bending.

Tables like this have a long history of broken legs. Since the customer has chosen this design, you might caution them not to drag this table or drop it from even a low height.

Re: Grain Orientation

#3

Re: Grain Orientation

Roger Myers

>Mark,

I'd give very serious thought to doing a bent lamination...will be much stronger than you could do from solid piece.

Re: Grain Orientation

#4

Lamination

MaxM

>

Re: Grain Orientation

#5

Re: Grain Orientation

Mark McC

>Thanks guys.

I was considering that but I am having a bit of trouble envisioning how with bent lamination I can get the almost 90 degree angle needed for the top , where the 4 skirts will have to mortise into the leg.

The curve has to bend around at the top to become plum.

Seems like a pretty tight bend for continuous pieces of laminate.

Am I mising something?

Thanks again for your responses?

Re: Grain Orientation

#6

Re: Grain Orientation

David Hay @ Denver

>We have a dining room table that does something similar...what they did was build up the leg with multiple different boards with alternating grain patterns. Imagine that the leg was split down the middle, lengthwise. On one half, there were two boards joined at the middle of the arc to make a "v". On the other half, there are three boards joined (e.g. half of a hexagon). These two halves were then glued together and the arc cut out of that.

The idea was that at least half of the leg at any point has the grain running in the right direction.

Now, this might not work for your case, in that the joints may not be acceptable. However you could do something like what I describe and then put a veneer over the whole leg assembly to hide the joints and make it appear to be one solid piece.

Hope that helps!

David

Re: Grain Orientation

#7

Re: Grain Orientation

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Good idea from Dave.

If you laminate conventionally you could create the vertical faces at the upper end by just cutting with a saw. IOW no sharp bend. Then apply a veneer to cover up the laminae end grain.

The legs in the photo look quite thick. They might be strong enough to avoid breakage. It would be easy enough to make a full size leg and test its strength.

Ed

Re: Grain Orientation

#8

Re: Grain Orientation

Barry Irby

>This is what the crooked parts of the tree are for. Or the buttress at the bottom of the stump. Of course, you might not have any laying around.

I would think that if you made these with the quarter sawn face on the sides (between the legs) they would be weakest. If you select the wood so that the grain is flat sawn on the sides, they would be stronger, but still not very strong.

You might try making a leg and then veneer the inner and outer faces with wood of the same species. You might reinforce them almost like fiberglass on the surface. If you were real careful with color match, it could be nearly invisible. Cut your veneer out of the very same board if possible.

I have no experience with this, but it seems it would work like lumber core plywood.

Re: Grain Orientation

#9

lamination

Roger Myers

>This is where you want some full size joinery drawings..but I'd laminate the leg with the top of the leg lamination ending at the bottom of the apron...then loose tennons or dowels to attach this laminated leg to blocks in the apron... not sure if my description is clear enough. you have a visual transition taking place there anyway, and the tennoned leg should be strong...certainly stronger than having short grain problems in a solid leg.