Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

shop-made drum sander drum material?

Posts

shop-made drum sander drum material?

#1

shop-made drum sander drum material?

Carol from AZ

>Thought about plastic pipe. Really thick-walled pipe, like 1/4" or better in a 3+ inch diameter. So the heat of sanding doesn't warp the drum? Or the stress of passing wood over it, so it flexes?

Anybody make this stuff?

Thoughts?

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#2

Bob Moffett

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Bob Moffett

>A friend of mine made a drum sander to fit on his Shopsmith. He made the drum out of plywood disks, got them close to round and put a board with course sandpaper on it and raised the board against the disk and sanded them round. He then mounts it between centers in the Shopsmaith lathe mode to use it. It works very well.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#3

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Falberg saw Co

>Find your local pipe and steel supply to get Schedule 80 pipe, probably steel. buy some 4", 6", or 8" v-pulleys (to fit inside pipe). Have your local machinist fit your 5/8" drive shaft with keys and keyways to link your motor , also v-pulleys, and bada-bing. You'll want a good flat table so go whole-hog on a SS plate. Stylin'.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#4

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material? *LINK*

Falberg saw Co

>I forgopt the most important part. Go to www.beltcorp.com and tell them what you're trying to do. You may need to split the pipe to allow for contraction. Don't know about that, but you could probably soap the sanding belts on if you get them sized right. There's probably enough stretch in the rubber tire to slip it on.


http://www.beltcorp.com

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#5

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Carol from AZ

>Metal pipe! Hadn't thought about that. And a SS table! Wow! But the idea was to make something effective without breaking the bank.

And I had thought to wrap the paper on over Velcro.

Ah, I see the problem. My inadequate English again. Think in terms of the Performax or the Sandflea. A drum in the 18-24" length.

Anybody know anything about the different 'schedules' of plastic pipe?

I have a CAD drawing in the works. This is now a reality check against available materials. :)

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#6

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>how about a rubber drum from a spindle sander? Grizzly sells a 3"x9" drum for just under $70. I know it isn't exactly cheap but they are very concentric and made for the exact thing you are thinking about.

Robin Corell

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#7

Plastic is probably too flexible...

John in New Mexico

>You'd want sched 40 or 80 pipe, definitely not the cellular core stuff sold at HD these days. You'll probably have to buy 20' at an industrial supplier. Come to think of it though, you could probably get a scrap from a septic contractor or plumber.

I would go with the plywood or maybe maple disk idea mentioned above.

John

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#8

Re: I started one a couple of years ago.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>Then a friend upgraded his sander and I bought his Delta. End of sander project.

I made a lot of 6" discs from 1/2" Baltic birch plywood and was going to string them on a 1" solid cold rolled steel bar. I drilled the 1" holes first and used a jig on my disc sander to make all of them exactly the same diameter. Some holes through the side of the 1" bar with roll pins installed would have driven the discs by virtue of slots routered radially in some of the discs. The holes in the plywood were a really tight fit on the steel bar. I have no doubt that there would have been no flex in this assembly. I remember that I had a design to spring load the final 2" of the roller to keep tension on the paper as it stretched.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#9

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Rob Sandow

>I would think the biggest problem with a shop made drum sander would be end-to-end rigidity. Drums made of PVC will certainly flex, and if you have an open ended design you would need a huge truss to keep things even end-to-end. You would need high stress bearings somehow incorporated as well, and a method of adjusting the feed rate to compensate for hardness and density of the stock. Then there would be the question of holding the paper in place through this whole exercise. There are reasons why Performax put thousands of dollars on the price tag of these things. I think my 22-44 Pro was well worth the $1700 I paid.

This is all assuming you are talking about a thickness type sander. If you are just looking for a contour edge sander, then maybe you could succeed with something shop made.

Rob

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#10

I'd use plastic pipe but the problem is not

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>the sanding drum it will be the pressure/feed rollers. I would use 5 or 6 inch plastic pipe with a 3/4 ground drill rod shaft with plywood discs about every 4 inches to match the inside of the pipe. Light cuts would have to be the norm but I think it would work. I'll have to think about the feed and pressure rollers a bit though.

Ray

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#11

Re: I started one a couple of years ago.

Carol from AZ

>Ah, the jigmeister replies!

I found a chart on wall thickness of plastic pipe on-line. A 2-1/2" nominal PVC schedule 80 pipe has a wall thickness of 0.293, more than 1/4". Ovality (a new word learned tonight!) is .008, necessitating a rounding operation somewhere in the process.

? Do you think 5 each 3/4" thick MDF disks spread along the inside of an 18" length of this stuff will give the PVC the necessary rigidity?

Sort of like this: |---|---|---|---|

The shaft would be 5/8" cold rolled steel. The paper Velcro-ed on to facilitate grit changes.

I am not thinking thickness sander so much as I am thinking a Sandflea type sander. I used to own a 22-44 Performax. I know what I used it most for and what I want this sander to be able to perform with the least expense and hassle.

Some will think, why not just buy the Sandflea? Fair question. First of all, I love building these kinds of things. I love the mechanical challenge of figuring all the specifics. Second, I am sitting in snowy, cold Iowa, with a little spare time (emphasis on 'little') and all my tools are in Arizona. I will be back in Arizona the middle of May. Meanwhile I can doodle on AutoCAD, write up specifications and procedures, locate material sources, etc. In other words, I find this fun.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#12

Re: I tend to overbuild when in doubt.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>I think the five bulkheads are ok, but I'd call a 5/8" rod barely adequate. I have seen plans for a gravity fed sander on which the owner made veneer. He had a tilting table and used no power feed for the stock. I thnk Popular Mechanics had plans decades ago for a sander which had a tilting bed attachment for the lathe, and used the lathe headstock to drive the sanding drum. The other end of the drum was supported by the live center in the tailstock. Lots of ways for an enterprising person to get themselves in trouble, aren't there?

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#13

Re: drum sander - now you have me thinking....

Carol from AZ

>feed mechanisms!

Dang.

The SandFlea is a simple drum and one passes the wood across the top. The human is the feed mechanism.

A powered feed mechanism is another can of worms presenting all sorts of tensions, pressures, stresses, etc.

How I most used the Performax was running flat stock thru it to remove planer marks before milling. Rarely for anything else. Thicknessing was never really part of the equation. Just getting rid of the planer marks in the most expedient fashion. It took a lot of floor space, was noisy, dusty (The dust collection hood of the older models left lots to be desired). Guy offered me more money than I thought anyone would pay for it when I was moving, so.....

I have this geared motor, about 12 rpm if I remember correctly. It has a big capacitor on the top. Is that one you could use a HF router speed controller with? I have one of those somewhere, too. I have a couple of 1/2" polished steel rods, but not big enough, huh?

Hmmm.....getting to sleep might be a challenge tonight, but alas, I must make the attempt. Seven hours of classes tomorrow..errr...today! BUT, woodturners club meeting tonight! YEAHHH!

The seminary calls this 'self-care.' Isn't that a great term for goofing off? :)

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#14

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material? *LINK*

Bri in Mtl

>Wonder what's used in this plan...


Drum sander plan

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#15

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Paul Waddle

>Hello,I made a stroke sander several years ago using wood disks(8"x7"). Ten years later no problems have surfaced-used 3/4" axial. I would either use 6" pipe and weld in ends or just use wood. The more ridgid you make the drum,the better it will be. I hate the lost shop space,but my sander really is handy,using the rear drum,(driven),really gives me a good free hand contour tool. JUST DO IT.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#16

Re: drum sander - now you have me thinking....

Dan Donaldson

>Cannot talk to any of the other questions, but the motor with the capacitor on top would not be suitable for use with a router speed controller. Those are for brush type motors.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#17

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Barry Irby

>You mentioned Plastic pipe being .008 out of round. I suspect that is nothing compared to the problems Velcro will add. If you are planning to cover the whole drum with Velcro and use Velcro backed strips on it, I think you will find the drum to be very soft and it will tend to round over ends and edges badly. Not sure, I don't have a Velcro covered drum to try out, but I betcha.

I had a hard rubber roller mounted on a shaft in a frame I picked up at an industrial junk yard. (Don't know why, but I rescued it. You probably understand) It was on a shaft. Heavy. I may have thrown it out, in one of my rare cleaning binges, but if you are interested, I will go look. It was four or five inches in diameter and about twelve inches long. If I still have it, its yours for the shipping.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#18

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Joe Burke

>I agree with Barry completely. I'd been thinking as I read every post that plastic pipe wouldn't be true enough. Add the velcro and it gets worse.

Thinking outside the box ..... maybe not

You could surf around for a machine that was broken, or out of service ..... something ..... and if you could get it for a song, salvage the drum. I realize this takes the fun of fabrication out of the equation. Just a thought. Not saying a scrap machine will just appear either.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#19

Rick L

Re: A much better option...

Rick L

>is to consider a stroke sander. If the plan is to just be able to sand your panels a stroke sander is far superior to a drum sander. With a drum sander you need to random orbit sand your panels. A stroke sander will allow you to go right to finishing so it's a bog timesaver over a drum sander by far.

FWW had plans in an early issue on how to make one. Used ones are really inexpensive and can be gotten for less than making a machine. Stroke sanders are one of the best kept secrets out there. Anyone who naysays stroke sanders doesn't know anything about them. I've even put one in a custom metal shop. Belts are cheaper and quick to change. HP requirements are much lower and you can handle veneers easily. One of the top Marquetry guys, Silas Kopf, has a stroke sander in his shop.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#20

Re: A much better option...

Carol from AZ

>Years ago, I had one. Didn't like much. Couldn't give it away, and it wasn't a shop-built. Bought it new, in fact. While it may be true I didn't appreciate it, the bottom line is, I don't have the floor space for one and I don't want to repeat the experience. But thanks for your viewpoint.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#21

Re: drum sander - now you have me thinking....

Carol from AZ

>Thanks, Dan. Another itch scratched.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#22

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Carol from AZ

>Thanks, Bri, I've bookmarked the plan. I will study it later. I like the clear dust cover. Can keep an eye on the belt that way. As for the drum, most of the plans I looked at after more than a few Google searches, were plywood or MDF disks epoxied on a shaft. I haven't ruled it out. Just exploring other, maybe easier ideas.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#23

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

Carol from AZ

>The SandFlea uses Velcro, so there is something there that works. But I'll think about some more. Thanks, Joe.

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#24

Velcro works fine.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I've got a commercial 38" model covered with velco and the edges of sanded pieces are nice and crisp. Any irregularities are canceled out by the spinning drum. If the pipe is only out .008 I wouldn't worry about it at all. All you have to do is stiffen it so it doesn't flex while spinning.

Ray

Re: shop-made drum sander drum material?

#25

That is what I had in mind. But I agree with

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Al on the size of the shaft(Jeez I hate to agree with Al). I would also go with the ground drill rod material (not hardened), not much more money and much more accurate than cold rolled. If you can find a place that sells supplies to semi rebuilding places they have the material for the rear doors that are made of thick plywood covered by steel on both sides. I have always thought it would make a great table material, nice and flat, stable and finished. As I recall the sheets were oversized, maybe 5x10 or 5x9 or something like that and about $100 a sheet (4-5 years ago).

I would build the drum, and the table, then take a spare piece of the table and mount paper to it to true the drum then put on the velcro and paper on the drum and sand away.

Ray