Re: ? of ethics
Fred Bearman
>Quite honestly - I didn't think that people like you inhabited this board. I would have thought that you would be out selling snake oil, or your mother, or running one of the Nigerian scams.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: ? of ethics
Fred Bearman
>Quite honestly - I didn't think that people like you inhabited this board. I would have thought that you would be out selling snake oil, or your mother, or running one of the Nigerian scams.
You've heard the answers........
Scott in Eastern Iowa
>...... what's the verdict?
I'm wondering....Will you be continuing this activity ?
My personal opinion are in check, but I think alot of folks are now wondering this very answer.
Scott
Re: ? of ethics
Ted Wong
>Seems kind of like a lame scam to me. I come from a restaurant family that has been in business for almost fifty years. I think your profiting at the company expense is rude and inconsiderate. Restaurants take reservations as a service to their clientele. If you make a bunch of reservations under one name or even a bunch of aliases you're taking up appointments from other people that call in asking for reservations. And at busy restaurants many loyal clients will turn away if they can't get a reservation knowing they may have to wait if they show up without one. Also when I worked in the family business our policy was to hold a table for fifteen minutes. If you don't sell your reservation that means the table sits empty for fifteen minutes. In a high volume restaurant that can mean a lot to a servers bottom line. In a lot of restaurants a servers wages depends a lot on how many times a table is turned over in an evening. I'm sure if my brother caught you in his restaurant he'd kindly ask you to leave.
And quite frankly I can't remember the last time I had to stand out in the cold waiting for a table. Every notable dining establishment I've been too has either a waiting area for customers or a cocktail lounge to wait in before being seated.
Remember the bunny?
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>It was about two years ago that two guys threatened to kill a bunny on the internet if they didn't get enough Paypal donations in 30 days. From what I remember reading they made off with $20,000 before PayPal shut them down due to pressure from animal rights groups. The could have made alot more money. It's not illegal to kill a rabbit (hunters do it all the time) and there were enough people willing to donate a bunch of money to prevent it.
Happy Woodworking!
Re: ? of ethics
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>That pretty much sums up my thinking on the subject as well. Though I've been trying for several hours to figure out how to word it without using any of George's seven words.
Rob
Here's how I see it.
Kelby
>Hypothetical No. 1: You aren't in the picture. I come to the restaurant with my family no reservation at 6:45. Bob Jones comes to the restaurant with his family at 6:50. We're both in line, and I'm ahead of him. I get the next seat available, which comes open at 7:15. Bob gets the next seat open after that, which comes open at 7:30.
Hypothetical No. 2: Same story, except this time you are in the picture. You got a reservation in before I got there, but solely for the purpose of selling it. So you go to Bob and sell him your reservation for $10, and he gets seated ahead of me. He gets the first open seat (the 7:15 seat), and now I get the 7:30 seat.
So how have you changed the world? Well, let's start with how you haven't changed the world --- you have not created any new seats, made the waiters work faster, sped up the cooking process, or in any way reduced the total amount of time that all people at the restaurant collectively have to wait for a seat. What you have done is switched the order in line --- even though I got there first, you effectively put him ahead of me in line. So you reduce his wait time from 40 minutes to 25 minutes, but extended my wait time from 30 minutes to 45 minutes. And pocketed $10 for your effort.
You have taken money from Bob to shift his wait burden to me.
Probably not illegal, and ethical is a pretty subjective term. But personally, I wouldn't feel good about taking money to shift one person's wait to someone else.
Now, you sound like you justify it by saying some little old lady doesn't have to wait in the rain. Hmmmmm. I'm skeptical. First, I doubt your clients are just the little old ladies in line. I presume they consist of anyone willing to pay $10. Second, the person who would have been next in line for that table now has to wait longer --- I don't know whether that person is a little old lady or whether it's raining, but it smells to me.
Remember when you were a kid in line for ice cream, and the kid in front of you looked at his buddies behind you and said "come cut in front of me!" I think that's what it's like.
Good of You to Ask, Ernie
Robert Hutchins
>Ernie,
Since I was the first to respond, and the first to get your response, I'm going to take advantage and counter your response - kinda like the old high school debates. But, first, let me say that I think you must be an honest - and undoubtedly brave - man to pose this question openly. Please don't take offense at what I've written because I truly do not mean to offend you nor do I think you would offend anyone knowingly.
Now: "Fasten your seatbelt. We've been advised that there's some turbulence in our flight path and it might get a little bumpy. We'll get through it quickly, but until we turn the seat belt light back off and you are again free to move about the cabin, please remain seated with your seat belts securely fastened."
"Nothing they move on to the next person in line."
I didn't read your original post to mean selling a place in line but that you were calling in reservations that would possibly not be honored if you didn't sell them and thus might deprive the restaurant of income.
"The seating is first come first served not really reservations but when they are full you have to wait for a table. I am just waiting in line for them."
No you're not, not really. Your answer tells the tale: "The seating is first come first served . . . " If you are allowed to do this, it won't be long before the restaurants themselves will be auctioning off tables to the highest bidder waiting. Would you want to do business with a restauarant that ran their business that way? No, it's not illegal; and, yes, there are other examples (futures trading) in capitalist societies that parallel the practice (although futures traders are at much greater risk), but capitalism is not a perfect system, just a better one at doing some things than other systems. Would you want organ transplant availability traded like this if your son/daughter/mother/wife needed one? It is the same question, ethically speaking.
"Is the restaurant owner? Don�t know the question?"
I was trying to ask if you were putting the restaurant owner at risk of losing - or not making - money. He would lose my business in perpetuity if I found him condoning the practice and I'd do my best to pass the information to as many people as I could to encourage them not to patronize the business.
"I am not profiting from the restaurant I am providing an additional service for people who don�t want to wait for seating."
If the restaurant didn't exist - and didn't have the reputation and didn't do the advertising - you couldn't do this, could you? Why not trade in organ transplants? What you are doing is really catering to people who want to circumvent the rules of common courtesy. Marie Antoinette is reported to have said, "Let them eat cake." and look what happened to her. Now there's a study in ethics.
"Time is money. I spend my time waiting in line for people who don�t want to. It come out to $2.50 per person for a table of four to not have to wait for 45 minutes. Is you time worth more than $%.00 an hour?"
Time is not money or rich people wouldn't die. This is a fallacy promulgated by those who want to make a quick buck. It assumes that anything that has value is acceptable for market trading. Extending that logic, is it ethical to sell sex? How about selling children into sex slavery? Selling heroin to school kids? Yes, there is a great deal of difference in the consequences, but ethically speaking, making a buck because someone is willing to spend it for what you are selling is the same.
"They can but they will have to wait for a table to open up 30-45 minutes in the cold."
No one HAS to wait in this country, thank God! They choose to, though why anyone would choose to stand in the cold to give their money to someone else for any service is beyond my ken. Your clients choose the restaurant because someone - not you - put up the capital and took the risk to build the business. You are simply insinuating your service into the business model and taking advantage of their effort.
"I have never had a problem with any managers several even let me get more than one reservation at a time."
Do they have a 'stake' in the business or just make money there? Do they understand that they might PO a lot of customers and that could lead to their losing their job? What if times were like the Depression and they couldn't get another one? Would they still participate? If the day ever comes that restaurants turn this into their business model everywhere, can we post your picture and address on the web so people can come thank your for encouraging the practice?
You know, you gotta love this place! Where else on the internet can you find important questions asked by intelligent people - people who care what others think - and read a real, honest exchange in good faith and good humour?
Thanks for asking, Ernie.
Re: ? of ethics -- ethically WRONG WRONG WRONG!!!!
wilbur
>"What people get is the ability to go straight into the restaurant with little or no wait thus keeping there loved one warm instead of waiting for there table 30-45 minutes."
No, what people get is the inability to make a reservation because you have already made a reservation that you don't necessarily intend to keep. And now the alternatives are to [1] go to the restaurant and wait 30-45 minutes, which is what you claim to be saving people the trouble of doing, or [2] pay you $10 to get that reservation that they could have gotten for free, had you not been reserving tables at restaurants all over town.
I'm glad that you titled this thread "? of ethics". Legally, you may not be doing anything wrong. But ethically, what you are doing is wrong, period. It is wrong because those reservations are not yours to sell in the first place.
Re: ? of ethics
DB
>When I first read your post the first thing that popped in my mind was "SCALPING". But the more I thought about it the less I thought it was scalping. Scalpers actually pay for the tickets, before they try to sell the tickets.
What you are doing is taking money from someone so that they can take "cuts" in line. You are making everyone in line else wait longer since you took the space that you were not intending to use in the first place.
The only way to make this ethical is to make the same deal with everyone in line that is between where the party should be and where you are. So give all those other people $10.00 also.
Re: ? of ethics
Charles Self
>"If I understand it correctly, you're basically putting your name in for 10 tables, the restaurant calls your name 10 times in a row, and you give those 10 spots to those willing to pay you?
snip
On gut instinct, it seems like you're catering to the lazy or unwilling to make their own arrangements so that their significant others won't be put out."
Isn't that what half the businesses, or more, in the world are based on, creating a convenience for another, in a niche that others have overlooked? What the buyers' motivations are is of no real import here, beyond the fact that they exist.
Personally, I don't get it. What does the buyer do with that 45 minutes? Walk around the building or the mall or whatever area the restaurant is located in? I would as soon wait myself, but, then, I don't see the benefit in a lot of things other people do or want (fortunately for the latter, as I have no desire for a $102,000 BMW such as the one a CA preacher recently bought with the proceeds of his--illegal--sale of his church. Now there's an ethical question).
Re: ? of ethics
James Dillon in MD
>Ernie,
My take on your original (rather confusing IMO) post is this:
1. If you have made a reservation for ONE table, even under false pretenses, stood in line prior to the reservation time, and then accepted $10 IN EXCHANGE for your place in line, then no big deal. I might be disgruntled to see, say four people (actually three additional people) pop in line ahead of me - but this happens all the time when the rest of a party shows up and only one person from the party was in line "holding-the-spot".
2. HOWEVER, if you made reservations for MORE than one table, and continued to stand in line, accepting money, until all the tables were sold (or you reach the head of the line), then I would find this practice unethical, and unfair to the restaurant owner (who has held tables vacant waiting for your "party") - which may or may not show, not to mention getting VERY PO'ed at seeing 16 additional people (four tables) get ahead of me. And as someone else noted, this "scam" also exacerbates the inequality of those who can afford to pay for a spot in line, versus those who cannot (or will not).
Just some thoughts.
Jim
Thanks for your replys
Ernie Miller
>I knew they was a reason I hang around this place. You all have a way of keeping a person grounded. So I will take my wife out and enjoy dinner and give up selling tables I must say it has been fun in it's own way. I have not seen any thing wrong with selling my little blinking box to some one who did not wat to wait for there to viberate. But I tell you this when it is 12� and that thing is flashing if you hold it up and ask does and one want my spot for $10 and 4 or 5 people come up to you with money in hand you got a quick free meal and can turn around and sell theres in ten minutse when it goes off. I ask here becaust I trust you all. and will fallow your advice. I am a die hard capitalis and if some one wants to spend a doller I am willing to take it. I work hard play hard and enjoy my life to the max. Thanks for being gentle. As I am sure that there are alot of people who thought better to keep there mouth shut instead of telling me what they realy thought. Have a Rockin Good Day with your Loved Ones.
Re: Good of You to Ask, Ernie
Ernie Miller
>Thanks for your reply This is why I ask it. I know the people will keep me grounded where I want to be. I actualy see nothing wrong with the concept. But I see things differantly. than alot of people. I am the youngest of twelve. I have worked sinse I was 13 on a farm and then at lots of differant jobs. I have lived on my own sinse I was 16. I have learned if you work hard you can make money. I have also learned to think outside of the box. The first Time I did this I was wateing in line like every one else and it was nasty out and some one said I would give twenty dollars to get inside out of this rain. at about that time my blinking box went off. It didn't take me long to know what to do. he had my box I had his and a new buisness was born. Laughed about it with some friends and we eavh went to four resturents and each got one buzzer about 5 minutse apart one person stayed at each untill they sold and we all ate for free in about 45 minutes and walked off with some cash. I still don't see any thing wrong with it but Like I said you people help keep me grounded and I will fallow your advice. as it looks like about 2 say it is a great idea and 40 think I am slime for even contemplating such a scam. Thanks again Ernie
Its called scalping
s.mackay@worldnet.att.net
>
I don't understand?
Ernie Miller
>why is selling one thing scalping and another selling comidities? There are X # of concert seats and they sell for Y on opening day if you sell them for more it's scalping? or there are X# of stocks available at IPO and you sell them for more it is trading on comoditys or stocks? What is wrong with free markets in some aspects of life and not others?
And thanks Ernie...
James Dillon in MD
>... for asking a rather thought provoking question. And for providing a bit more background on where you are coming from. As a poster said, just because you can do something, doesn't mean you should. If you continue to want to do this, instead of a good meal, you might want to invest in a good bullet-proof vest as some people don't take kindly to people getting ahead of them in a line. 8-). You've heard of road-rage; well maybe there is restaurant-line rage 8-) 8-). Anyway, I've always enjoyed reading your posts and this one in particular.
Jim
My question exactly.
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I don't really understand how scalping is illegal, but I had a friend with a criminal record to prove that it is. Is it illegal simply because it's stated in writing on the back of the ticket?
I guess the ultimate decision on if something is okay or not is this criteria: does it break any laws (Biblical or state laws), does it hurt anyone, does it negatively affect anyone (do unto others as you would have them... you know)
Not that I'm any authority in this, of course, but I'd liek to know the real reason that scalping is illegal. Anyone know?
Happy Woodworking!
Interesting
Raymond Overman in SC
>Ernie,
I feel that if you're selling a service such as you or your wife standing in line at a restaurant as a placeholder for Mr. and Mrs. Smith then you have an ethical business. If a first come, first serve restaurant has a list that takes an hour or more to get through, then it might be worth my $10 to have a surrogate line waiter while my wife and I have a drink down the street or don't have to leave the house quite as early and pay that babysitter an extra hour. However, the logistics of this would mean that each party would need a physical person to stand in line at $10 a pop and there would have to be some sort of communication between you and the attending party so they knew when to arrive. It doesn't seem very economical to me but my time as a professional is worth much more than $10/hr.
The idea of making a reservation early in the hopes of selling it seems at the least opportunistic. The restaurant will lose some time in waiting for the party to announce their arrival if they are not there. This might not seem very long in the span of an evening but over time would equate to real money being lost not only by the restaurant but by wait staff that may depend on tips. Also, as a patron, I may question whether I should wait on line if I get the perception that a party in front of me has decided to leave, when actually there was no party at all.
While the worlds capitalists and entrepreneurs may applaud such action as innovative, I still think that $10 a pop isn't enough for somebody to question my ethics. A reputation, which you are obviously gaining from your co-workers, of questionable ethics, perceived or otherwise, is not acceptable.
The money may be ok, but remember there are a lot of lawyer, stock broker, and salesmen jokes out there that deal with just this idea. Are you selling your reputation for a few hundred dollars?
Note: Don't take this as my judgment of your actions. Personally I think we weigh the costs and benefits of our actions every day. I'm not one to weigh someone else's actions. I just wanted to publish some thoughts about your question. Good luck with your business.
Laws, Regulations and Personal Ethics
Stuart Johnson
>why is selling one thing scalping and another selling commidities?
Laws and regulations make the difference. Some places scalping is legal in others it's illegal or controlled. Commodity trading is regulated by any number of rules and laws with penalties for violations. That does not mean all trading is done with full compliance or those caught in violations are all treated the same.
Ethics are very personal. If you went to a garage sale being held by a widow and saw a large OneWay lathe marked at $400. Would you say something like "well it looks to be in good shape, I'll take it". Then come here and post a gloat or, would you tell her it was worth closer to ten times what she is asking and offer to help her?.
Either option would be legal and can be debated. Although I think anyone with the exception of many of our politicians can see the difference.
Ernie, No One Thinks You're
Robert Hutchins
>slime. We just don't want your business model to be adopted by restaurants. If they see you doing it, it won't be long before they find a way to incorporate it into their business model.
I'm the 9th of 9, myself and have worked (or did work) from the time I was 10 until I retired, unwillingly (health issues), a few years ago. There was never a day in my life that I didn't have at least one job and many times two; so I understand hustling for a buck.
Again - no one thinks the less of YOU. In fact, the very act of asking the question shows me that you are a caring individual and a valuable member of the community. It is the business model that we find unappealing. We all like Ernie.
Good response
Ron in Drums PA
>
Re: ? of ethics
greg robbins
>I'm still trying to figure out how 3 of you can be at 10-12 different resturants at the same time. You must be fast!!
Was'nt choosing sides . . .
s.mackay@worldnet.att.net
>most aspects and events in my life are planned, paid for or rserved well in advance. Just seems that a large percentage of folks frown on the practice.
what about the
Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's
>guy who stood 2 hours in the col and rain to get tickets just to find out someone bought more table then they deserve so they could make 10 bucks.
I would bet he would either be pissed or offer you 20 bucks.
it's an inventive way of making money but it just plain wrong. there is no reason to take more than you need of some free to low value thing and make others pay for it. it may be the American way but it's wrong and has no integrity.
Just My opinion.
Re: I don't understand?
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>"why is selling one thing scalping and another selling commodities? There are X # of concert seats and they sell for Y on opening day if you sell them for more it's scalping? or there are X# of stocks available at IPO and you sell them for more it is trading on commodities or stocks? What is wrong with free markets in some aspects of life and not others? "
Ernie - tickets to a game ARE the commodity and regardless who's purchasing them or re-purchasing them, the venue makes the money it expected to make. The value to a venue is in selling the seat.
Restaurant seats themselves have no value placed on them by the restaurants. By that I mean you do not expect to walk into a restaurant, pay the hostess $$ to seat you and then pay more $$ if you eat or drink. When you walk into a restaurant, you expect that your seating is included with the price of a meal.
What you're doing is two things - you're associating a value to the actual seating and you're gaining revenue from a "service" (the seating) that the restaurant has chosen to package with their food. In effect, you're charging for something you don't own - something the restaurant has chosen to "give away". You're selling something that wasn't designed to be sold.
The other thing that occurs is that food establishments make staffing and material purchase choices based on a lot of factors, one of which is reservations. If they have a reservation for a table for four, it's a reasonable expectation for them to have that they'll be feeding a group of four and as such, will staff and supply accordingly. If for some reason the reservation you made is not sold, that restaurant is now out physical money - you've cost them that money. Further, restaurants expect and work to achieve an expected and forcastable table turnover rate. By virtue of "doing what's right", when they call for "SMITH" or whatever name you've used for the reservation but not managed to sell, they'll hold that table regardless of the line-up of people that do not have reservations but who would love to sit and eat. In the meantime, more people may drive up, see the line-up and choose to move on meantime that table sits empty. And an empty table doesn't make the restaurant a nickel - in fact, it's cost them more $$ because they made decisions on your commitment that you'd be there spending money.
Now, you may argue that you manage to "sell" your reservations 100% of the time and that you may do so in advance of your name being called such that the restaurant never sees a gap in being able to turn over the tables, and of so - you're not costing them anything. But that's luck - nothing else, and it's a matter of time before the money that's going into your jeans comes straight out of the restaurant operators pockets.
I like capitalism - perhaps more than most. But I have a problem with someone selling something granted to them in good faith - something that carries a cost to the person granting it when there was never intended to be a direct value associated to it.
However - IF - when you make these reservations you have an agreement with the establishments such that any reservation made by you but not filled carries a cost (to you, paid to them) equivalent of the anticipated bill had the table actually been revenue generating - I have no trouble with this at all.
Rob