Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

? of ethics

Posts

? of ethics

#1

? of ethics

Ernie Miller

>I am being harassed here at work me my wife and a two other couples broker tables at restaurants on special occasions like tomorrow night. Valentines Day. We each go in and make a reservation for four at 10-12 local restaurants and then sell our tables to people who do not want to make there loved one wait in the cold or rain. This could be a record night for tables as we will have 3-4 inches of snow on the ground and themps in the low teens. We sell out reservations for $10 and usually have no problem getting rid of them. I even have several repeat customers. We always work the same restaurants so people know us. Have a lot of fun and make some good money in about 2 hours. Have a great meal and leave a big tip. What people get is the ability to go straight into the restaurant with little or no wait thus keeping there loved one warm instead of waiting for there table 30-45 minutes. Some people her at work think it is just plain wrong for me to sell my table that I have been standing in the cold for 30 minutes or more for $10 and the people who buy them walk in with out a wait. I value your opinion is it wrong to sell you table. So some one mom Grandma, wife or girl friend doesn�t have to wait in the cold? Three of us sold 40 tables on New Years Eve. It�s looking like tomorrow will be better as I have had two people call me in advance for there table.

Re: ? of ethics

#2

Re: ? of ethics

Robert Hutchins

>I don't pretend to know the ethics of this, but I have some questions for you.

What happens if you don't sell the reservations? Are you out any money? Is the restaurant owner?

Why should you profit from the capital investment and goodwill that the restauranteur made and worked so hard to create?

What value do you add? Why can't your customers make their own reservations?

If I owned the restaurant and caught you brokering, I'd ban you from the place. It would seem to me - in that position - that you are putting me and my reputation at risk without risking anything yourself. It's not the same as stealing, but it's a close cousin, IMO.

My ole granddaddy used to have a saying, "Just because you can doesn't mean you should!"

Remember, you asked.

Re: ? of ethics

#3

Re: ? of ethics

Ernie Miller

>I don't pretend to know the ethics of this, but I have some questions for you.

What happens if you don't sell the reservations? Nothing they move on to the next person in line.

The seating is first come first served not really reservations but when they are full you have to wait for a table. I am just waiting in line for them.

Are you out any money? No not really I book of post-it�s and a couple pencils

Is the restaurant owner? Don�t know the question?

Why should you profit from the capital investment and goodwill that the restauranteur made and worked so hard to create? I am not profiting from the restaurant I am providing an additional service for people who don�t want to wait for seating.

What value do you add? Time is money. I spend my time waiting in line for people who don�t want to. It come out to $2.50 per person for a table of four to not have to wait for 45 minutes. Is you time worth more than $%.00 an hour?

Why can't your customers make their own reservations? They can but they will have to wait for a table to open up 30-45 minutes in the cold.

If I owned the restaurant and caught you brokering, I'd ban you from the place. It would seem to me - in that position - that you are putting me and my reputation at risk without risking anything yourself. It's not the same as stealing, but it's a close cousin, IMO.

I have never had a problem with any managers several even let me get more than one reservation at a time.

My ole granddaddy used to have a saying, "Just because you can doesn't mean you should!"

Remember, you asked.

This is why I ask I value your opinion.

Re: ? of ethics

#4

Re: ? of ethics

Jerry Nicholson

>I see nothing wrong with this. But then I don't understand the laws against "ticket scalping" either. You are buying and selling table futures, just like buying and selling wheat, corn, oil, or microchip futures. On the other hand, if you reserve a table at the restaurant, then I think you are ethically obligated to fulfill that reservation.

Jerry

Re: ? of ethics

#5

NOT Reservation

Dustmaker Mike

>if you are standing in line for the next table then that is not a reservation. When they call your name and you give your spot to someone else for 10 bucks and they are willing to pay more power to you.

Re: ? of ethics

#6

Re: ? of ethics

J. Robison

>If I understand it correctly, you're basically putting your name in for 10 tables, the restaurant calls your name 10 times in a row, and you give those 10 spots to those willing to pay you??

On the first read of it, I'm not a fan. To me, it seems no different than letting those people cut in line. I don't think I'd appreciate it if I were waiting and knew it was going on.

On gut instinct, it seems like you're catering to the lazy or unwilling to make their own arrangements so that their significant others won't be put out.

I'm trying not to read into it too much and just relay my first impressions.

Re: ? of ethics

#7

Nothing unique, Ernie.

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>AAA has been doing the same thing. You pay them for membership. One of the members' benefits is that when you sell or buy a car, you don't have to wait in line at the DMV. You can just go to any AAA office and do the paperwork there.

Besides AAA, there are others providing the same service.

My travel agent handles passport/visa paperwork for free if I buys plane tickets from her. She charges about $50 per passport/visa if I don't buy tickets from her. I have a choice whether to pay her or to stand 3 hr. in line at the consulate.

When I was going to UC Irvine, I had a choice of buying a "regular" parking permit with no space guarantee, or paying 3 times as much for "premium" parking permit with a guaranteed space.

-- Hoa

Re: ? of ethics

#8

Re: ? of ethics

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Interesting question. I can tell you this.....if I was waiting in line behind you and you sold your spot to someone, and then kept your place in line in front of me waiting for the next "sale".....well, believe that I would walk over or through you before I'd let you bump me back again. In other words, if you want to give up your "one" spot for $10 bucks fine, but don't expect to make a living at the expense of my time.

Re: ? of ethics

#9

seems wrong to me...

Bryan in Broad Ripple, IN

>I'm not sure I can properly verbalize my thoughts on this, but this seems kind of sleazy to me. I don't intend to be personal with my comments, so please, don't take offense. No offense is intended. This is meant as constructive criticism, even though it may come off sounding high-and-mighty or holier-than-thou. I'm not the moral police, here, so bear with me.

A few thoughts:

The owner has established "first-come first-served" rather than reservations for a reason. What their rational is, I cannot guess. But, you are establishing your own reservation system outside their system, and this is clearly (at least to me) not in the spirit of the house rules. You speak of the "managers" letting you make several reservations at once. How do the OWNERS of the establishment feel...not just the wait-staff or "managers"?

If you have 10 reservations lined up, the guy in line right behind you will be told that his wait will be MUCH longer than it would have been otherwise. A 20 minute wait may become a 2 hour wait if the place is small. What if that person were you? How would you feel about someone making you wait another 1 or so hours for a table so they can pocket a few bucks? Since you are the one doing this, I know how you will probably answer....but try to be objective, and tell me how would you really feel. I would feel angry about it. Personally I would turn-around and leave. The restaurant would, therefore, loose my business. Bottom line, even though they will fill that table one way or another, they lost MY business that night, so the establishement ended up losing money....my money.

You keep mentioning "the cold", and wanting to keep people from waiting in "the cold". Well, by your actions you are now making other people who are NOT profitting from your actions wait in the cold. Your motives here are NOT altruistic, as you might want to believe. In fact, you might just be making people who cannot afford your $10 fee to wait in the cold, while those that can afford to pay get to stay warm. Remember, lots of people of modest income don't get to dine out frequently, and often wait for special occasions to do so. You may just have ruined their special night for your can profit.

Again, I'm not trying to come off high-and-mighty. I'm just giving my impressions.

-Bryan

Re: ? of ethics

#10

Re: ? of ethics

Brad Chenoweth

>Hi Ernie,

Most of the restaurants in this area would not permit this sort of activity. In fact, many of them will not reserve a table unless your entire party is present. Personally, if I were waiting in line and this happened, I would raise the roof, and let the manager, and everyone else present, know that I would no longer patronize that establishment. I always enjoy your posts, but I guess you can figure out that I think you're just wrong on this one:>)

Brad Chenoweth, watching the blizzard conditions outside in N.E. Ohio

Re: ? of ethics

#11

Simply wrong

John Pappas

>Ernie, those tables belong to the restaurant, and you have no right to claim ownership by making fraudulent reservations. I will refrain from really saying what I think of your scam.

Re: ? of ethics

#12

Re: ? of ethics

Jim Smith

>Yes it is wrong unless you sell it to the person standing directly behind you, if you sell it to anyone else and I'm the person directly behind you, me and you both are probably not going to eat that night because I'm going to spit in your face, and then we are going to fight and end up downtown in police station. Sorry but you asked for opinions!!!

Re: ? of ethics

#13

Re: ? of ethics

Dave Bonde - Iowa

>I don't think it is right. I probably wouldn't be standing in line to eat anyway, but since you asked - the way I read your post is you are waiting for one table sell that and then move on. If I was next in line I guess I would live with that even though I would not be happy. My own feeling is you really don't have the right to "sell" the table. But if you stay in line ahead of me and wait for another table there would be a real problem. Just my opinion Dave

Re: ? of ethics

#14

Why?

Doug in Denver

>First of all, it's apparent that you did not do a good job of explaining exactly what it is that you do. First you said reservations, but it appears you are only standing in line, but then you say you do it at 10-12 restaurants on the same night. How do you stand in that many lines? And I still don't get the multiple reservations thing. Why would any owner who has a line of people allow you to walk up and say "I'd like 4 tables please" and then let you sell them for $40. Again, I dont think you have explained it well.

My intial reaction is the same as many others, that it's at least a little weird, but the question nobody has aked is why on earth you do such a thing? Just to make some extra money? I'm thinking how I would respond if somebody asked me "how much would I need to pay you to go downtown tonight in the cold and spend your evening standing in restaurant lines? You don't eat, you just stand in line." I think I'd say "I dunno, but more than $500."

Re: ? of ethics

#15

What do the restaurant owners say?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>If you are taking advantage of their reservation policy and making false reservations for profit, then your answer is right there.

If however, the restaurent owners are in full agreement with what you are doing, then I guess it's okay.

But I'll tell you, I'd never eat at a restaurent that allowed that sort of thing to happen. It would seem too much like Uncle Luigi allowing Cousin Vini to make a little extra spending money. If I saw that happen in front of me, I'd leave and go elsewhere.

Just my opinion, for what it's worth.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: ? of ethics

#16

And

Doug in Denver

>Do you really have 10-12 restaurants in your town where people have to wait outside in the cold? I can't remember the last time I stood outside waiting for a table.

Re: ? of ethics

#17

Lee Gordon

Re: ? of ethics

Lee Gordon

>Sounds to me that what you are doing is not much different from what people do when an overbooked airline offers to give them free tickets or other consideration in exchange for agreeing to be "bumped" from a flight and give up their seats to people who otherwise would be left behind.

If I understand correctly, you get in line and wait your turn, just like everyone else in the line. So, theoretically, when you get to the front of the line it would be your turn to be seated. Someone then comes along and pays you to be "bumped," they replace you in the line, and you go away. Instead of free airfare on a future flight to anyplace Southwest flies, you get ten bucks and move along.

I don't see anything wrong with this as long as you step aside when you make the transaction. The people waiting in line behind you should not be upset (which is not to say that some won't be upset) because your little deal is not causing them to have to wait any longer that they would have waited if you had just proceded to the table you stood in line for.

And for any of those people who would get upset, I would ask how they would feel if, instead of collecting a ten-spot, you had graciously offered your place in line to an elderly or disabled couple who arrived at the restaurant and were surprised to discover they would have to deal with a long line (again, presuming that upon relinquishing your place in line, you left the premises or moved to the back to the end of the line to wait some more).

Re: ? of ethics

#18

Alan Young

Re: ? of ethics

Alan Young

>Ernie,

You said:

"It�s looking like tomorrow will be better as I have had two people call me in advance for there table."

Wow. I guess I gotta hand it to you. You seem to have found two people dumb enough to give you ten bucks when they know in advance they could make their own reservations for free.

Alan

Re: ? of ethics

#19

Not sure, but its not for me!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I guess I see nothing illeagal or even unethical about it. I'm sure I wouldn't do it for $10 for a 45 minute wait. There is a mall near that has a half dozen restraunts in very close proximity and they all give you those electronic buzzer light things when you ask for a table. I've seen people split up outside and each one goes to a different place to eat, each gets a buzzer and which ever one goes off first is where they eat. They return the others and go enjoy their meal.

If you were the person in line in front of me, I guess it wouldn't bother me a great deal. If the transaction took place out of sight then who is to know. I would still get seated in the same amount of time.

If this is a fun thing for your to do and a way to earn a free meal then have fun. However based on some of the more terse comment received to your question, don't be too surprised if someone takes a swing or says something impolite at you one night.

Lee

Re: ? of ethics

#20

To me..

Ron in Drums PA

>To me this sounds like scalping.

Re: ? of ethics

#21

If you have to ask it usually isn't ethical.

Stuart Johnson

>

Re: ? of ethics

#22

I knew a guy......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>When I was in highschool we went to a baseball game. A couple of guys scalped some extra tickets. They got themselves arrested somehow. One guy was under 18 but the other was 19 a got a criminal record.

We were shocked and frankly could never really understand why scalping was punished so severely. We joked that if he was selling a tiny amount of dope they would probably have let it go.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: ? of ethics

#23

I used to do this.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Here the high end resturants get booked about a month ahead. I used to make reservations for 2 at three to four of the top resturants in town in early Jan. Come one or two weeks before Valentines day I would get calls from my buddies at work and I would sell the reservation. As these resturants would ask for a deposit via credit card, I made sure to get enough to cover the deposit. The guys didn't give me any grief as I was bailing them out of a jam. One of my co-workers took this over, but after he left IBM I don't know who took over. Next year lower your reservation seat count and see if you get any complaints.

Re: ? of ethics

#24

Re: ? of ethics

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Ernie, it doesn't sound right to me, but I am considered old fashioned by some. If I saw someone ahead of me doing what you describe I would say something about it to the management and not frequent that place again. Probable would leave without eating there also.

Howard

Re: ? of ethics

#25

Steven Antonucci

How much money would it take to shoot a puppy?

steve antonucci

>There's a video circulating Youtube where some kids ask this question and then listen for answers.

While I don't claim to know everything, I think that I know the difference betwen right and wrong. Someone once told me if you have to ask, it's probably wrong.

Just like the puppy question, the amount of money doesn't change the act. If you charged $1, $10, or $100 for your service with no intent of taking that table at a restaurant, it seems that you are deceiving the owner and the folks in line (Why did that guy stand here for an hour and suddenly leave?)

Disneyworld combats this problem as best as it can since it manages a couple of hundred dining facilities and 100,000 people per day. Since all of their reservations are centrally managed, you can't make more than one without cancelling prior reservations. There are people who cheat the system and put themselves first- please don't be another one.

Steve