WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

Posts

Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#1

Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

Alex Y

As illustrated below, you have a cannon tilted at 45 degrees, which fires a cannon ball at a trampoline. What angle does the trampoline need to be set at to return the cannonball to the mouth of the cannon?


Some assumptions:

The mouth of the cannon and the trampoline are at the same level.

Vacuum.

Trampoline is perfect reflector.

Any other nasty complications like friction I might have missed do not exist. :-)

There are actually two answers, one of which is illustrated in the image.

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#2

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

Don Orr

In the perfect world you have described does not angle of incidence equal angle of reflection?

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#3

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

Alex Y

Yes:


Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#4

Clarification

Alex Y

My answer to Don was just confirming his statement with a gratuitous (and possibly misleading if you read too much into it) illustration of what "angle of incidence = angle of reflection" means. The illustration does NOT represent the relative trajectories of the cannonball coming into and off of the trampoline in either of the two solutions..

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#5

Hint

Alex Y

I hope all had a Happy Thanksgiving.

A projectile in a vacuum follows a parabolic path. Consider the symmetry in the cannonball's path.

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#6

Solution

Alex Y

This has generated no answers, so thought I would put up the answer in case someone looks and wonders later.

Don was on the right track.

In a vacuum, a projectile follows a parabolic path. On the moon, a golf ball hit with a driver will follow a path described by the very top, nearly flat, portion of a very large parabola, while one hit with a loft wedge will follow a much larger portion of a much smaller parabola. The key for this puzzle is that the shape of the downward path is an exact mirror image of the upward path. Thus since the projectile at the mouth of the cannon is moving at 45 degrees from horizontal, it will be at 45 degrees when it gets to the same level at the trampoline.

If the trampoline is tilted at 45 degrees, the cannonball will hit it squarely and follow back along exactly the same path.

The second solution is trickier: If the trampoline is set at 22.5 degrees from horizontal, the cannonball will hit the trampoline at 22.5 degrees from perpendicular, and reflect at 22.5 degrees on the other side or perpendicular, which is vertical. The ball will shoot straight up, then come back down, tracing the path in reverse, eventually back to the mouth of the cannon.

Re: Friday Puzzler -- Cannon and trampoline

#7

Re: Solution

Larry Barrett

I didn't respond because I could not think of any possible second solution.

But I always enjoy your puzzles and hope for more in 2017.

Thanks and Happy Holidays,

Larry

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.