WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

Posts

Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

#1

Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

Alex Y

This time, you are presented with two gameboards. Both boards have 12 pieces white side up. One board has 11 pieces black side up while the other has 13 pieces black side up. After you are blindfolded, the pieces on each board are thoroughly mixed (but the board positions do not change, so you know which has 23 vs 25 pieces).

In as few moves as possible, move individual pieces from one board to the other until they both have the same number of black pieces.

Note: This is a twist on a puzzle that I think I saw here for the first time, and one solution is to turn this puzzle into that one. But that is not the minimal solution.

Re: Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

#2

Re: Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

Larry Barrett

Question - in addition to moving tiles from one board to the other, can tiles be turned over?

If the answer is yes, then I think the solution is straightforward - move one tile from Board 2 to Board 1, then turn over all the tiles on Board 1.

Start:

Board 1 has 11B, 12W. Board 2 has 13B, 12W.

Case 1 - a W tile is selected at random and moved from Board 2 to Board 1.

Result: Board 1 has 11B, 13W. Board 2 has 13B, 11W.

Turn all the tiles on Board 1; Result: Board 1 has 11W, 13B - same as Board 2.

Case 2 - a B tile is selected at random and moved from Board 2 to Board 1.

Result: Board 1 has 12B, 12W. Board 2 has 12B, 12W.

Turn all the tiles on Board 1; Result: Board 1 has 12W, 12B - same as Board 2.

If the answer to the question is no, then I do not have a solution.

Re: Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

#3

On the right track

Alex Y

Very good! That is a solution, but not the minimal one. (And yes, you can flip the pieces, which is the key.)

Re: Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

#4

You can do it with just x discs moved

Alex Y

Close this if you want to keep working on it without knowing x.

If

not

,

then

scroll

down

and

try

your

hand

at

figuring

out

how

to

get

the

same

number

of

black-up

pieces

on

each

board

with

only

2

discs being moved!

Re: Friday Puzzler -- More Othello

#5

More Othello solution

Alex Y

This one has been out there three weeks, so maybe it is time for the answer

Move 2 discs from the board with 13 black discs to the board with 11, flipping the discs as you do.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.