WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Another one.

Posts

Another one.

#1

Another one.

Dan Donaldson

How about this one? We all know that the ultimate answer is 42, so how about this question?

How many different right triangle with integer side lengths exist with a leg equal to 42? How do you know?

Re: Another one.

#2

corrected semi-answer

Alex Y

The sides of the triangles with such legs total to 1528. Answer and rationale deferred...

Re: Another one.

#3

Answer

Alex Y

There are four such triangles, with sides of 40,42,58; 42,56,70; 42,144,150; and 42,440,442.

If a right tringle has legs of 42 and x, and hypotenuse of y, Pythagoras tells us that 42^2 + x^2 = y^2. A little algebraic manipulation converts this:

42^2 = y^2-x^2

42^2 = (y-x)*(y+x)

Since x ad y are both integers, y-x and y+x are either both odd or both even.

42^2 = 2^2 * 3^2 * 7^2

We are looking for pairs of numbers that multiply to 42^2, and are both odd or both even. The only way that can happen is for them both to be even. The five choices are:

2 * (2*3^2*7^2)

(2*3) * (2*3*7^2)

(2*7) * (2*3^2*7)

(2*3^2) * (2*7^2)

(2*3*7) * (2*3*7)

The last one reduces to a non-triangle, since x = 0

But for the others, you can determine x and y. For instance,

(2*7) * (2*3^2*7)

= 14 * 126

70 is half-way between 14 and 126, and they can be expressed as

(70-56) * (70+56)

so 56 and 70 form the other sides of one of the four triangles.

Re: Another one.

#4

perfect 


👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.