WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Tuesday Puzzle

Posts

Tuesday Puzzle

#1

Tuesday Puzzle

Dan Donaldson

This one may take a bit of time. It is a version of the classic "put numbers in the boxes such that all rows, and diagonals add up to the same number.

Here is an interesting version:

The attached image has nineteen circles that have to be filled with the numbers 1 up to (and including) 19. These numbers have to be placed in such a way that all numbers on any horizontal row and any diagonal line add up to the same sum.

Be careful: there are many horizontal and diagonal lines, and different number of circles (3, 4, or 5), nevertheless all these sums have to be equal!

The Question: How should the nineteen numbers be placed in the net?

There are at least 12 solutions, but as far as I know, all of them are simply mirror images or rotations. Perhaps the best way to answer this one is to tell us what the sum for this puzzle is.


Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#3

Sorry


Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#4

38

Alex Y

But I haven't solved it.

1+2+...+19 = 190 [ n*(n+1)/2 ]

190 total / 5 rows = 38 per row

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#5

Steven Antonucci

That's what I did, only without the error :-)

Steven Antonucci

I added wrong on a calculator, which has some stick key issues. I think I dropped a 10, which was how I got to 180 instead of 190...

S

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#6

Total is correct, now for the (a) solution 


Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#7

But I already answered "the best way"

Alex Y

I've seen this before, but still don't have a clue how to approach it.

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#8

What I've concluded so far

Alex Y

Am I right in my conclusions that:

1) Most of the centers of the edges of the hexagon come from 14-19 range

2) Most of the vertices of the hexagon come from the 8-13 range

3) Most of the interior points come from the 1-7 range.

4) At least one of the vertices comes from the 14-19 range.

5) The center point is less than or equal to 11 (and probably 4 or smaller)

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#9

Here is one answer

Dan Donaldson

You can get others with rotations etc.

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#10

Solution method?

Alex Y

Any idea for a solution method, short of brute force? Some of the conclusions I drew based on my analysis were accurate, while others were only close, so my approach was clearly not the best. I'm glad you posted the answer before I tired all 19! possibilities :)

Re: Tuesday Puzzle

#11

Re: Solution method?

Dan Donaldson

Sorry, but in this case, it is a problem I found and did not actually do the solution myself. I usually try them myself, but I was running short of time, so I took one that I had already with the answer.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.