WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

One more just for grins

Posts

One more just for grins

#1

One more just for grins

This one is actually an easy one, but perceptions can be deceiving. Before you do any setup for this problem, make a guess as to the answer then post both the guess and the answer. Be honest ;-)

Here is the problem:

I am going to make a couple of assumptions; first that the Earth is a smooth, perfect sphere; second, that the diameter is exactly 25000 miles. Here is the scenario:

There is a company that has a contract to build a fence all the way around the Earth at the equator. They get all of the stuff, then at the last minute, it is decided that the fence needs to be a foot off the ground in order that the twin headed purple tree snark can migrate back and forth across the equator. The question is how much more fencing material will the company have to purchase to raise the fence a foot off the ground?

Remember, guess first, then work it out.

Re: One more just for grins

#2

My instinct says zip.

If the fence is say scheduled to be four feet high from the ground, raising it a foot means that the fence, as originally planned was enough to cover that height as is. If the fence is one foot high from the ground, the top wire is already at the one foot height so flipping it is no big deal?

Re: One more just for grins

#3

Re: One more just for grins

6 feet 3 and 1/2 inch

Re: One more just for grins

#4

Steven Antonucci

2*Pi miles

If I understand the scenario correctly- 1' off the ground all the way around the equator, and not just at one point?

S

Re: One more just for grins

#5

no, wrong logic

Re: One more just for grins

#6

scenario correct answer wrong

Re: One more just for grins

#7

what was your guess before working it out?

Re: One more just for grins

#8

... just for grins

a tad less than a meter

Re: One more just for grins

#9

Re: ... oops

out by a factor of 2

Re: One more just for grins

#10

Re: ...I hesitate

to guess, with my consternation about the previous quiz. But, since there is no stipulation in the question as to the height of the fence, I'll guess the answer is 0 feet additional. I'd just cut a foot off the bottom of the rolls of alleady purchased fencing and start installing.

Re: One more just for grins

#11

Re: But in a

senior moment, I'd probably cut off the top instead of the bottom of the rolls, and have to start all over :-). I've been sitting home all day with a chest cold, now you have my head hurting wore than my lungs.

Re: One more just for grins

#12

Steven Antonucci

I've seen this one...

An I know that the answer is much greater than you'd expect (or much less, can't really recall...)

Assuming that the circumference of the earth is 25000Xpi, a fence of 1' above the earth would create a circle 25002? (one foot all the way around on either end of a diameter). 25002xpi would be the new circumference.

the difference is 2pi...but I know that's wrong because it was too easy.

I've also seen it where the string around the earth needed to be lengthened so that a 6' tall man could walk under it at a single point... can't remember that one either...

Steve

Re: One more just for grins

#13

Steven Antonucci

Duh. Conversion errors...

get my units right...

S

Re: One more just for grins

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: One more just for grins

>>diameter is exactly 25000 miles<<

My guess was 10~15% more. Started to work the problem and think I noticed a typo. The earth has, I know it, a circumference of about 25,000 miles. So... thought Dan was playing word games and I gave up the ship at that point(??). Thanks for the puzzle anyway, Dan.

Re: One more just for grins

#15

Re: I've seen this one...

It would be 25000 miles +2feet, not 25002 ;-) The answer is 2 π feet. The interesting thing is that it does not depend at all on the diameter of the sphere you are going around. The earth, the sun, or a basketball, to make it stand 1 foot above the sphere, it needs to be 2 π feet longer. Most people would tend to guess much higher.

Re: One more just for grins

#16

Re: One more just for grins

Actually, just a slip, but it really doesn't matter. See my answer above. It is independent of the diameter of the sphere. to get it one foot higher, it needs to be 2 π feet longer.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.