WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

First Humpday of Summer Questions

Posts

First Humpday of Summer Questions

#1

First Humpday of Summer Questions

Gary Smyth's 2 question the other day prompted some questions for this humpday. You Google-a-holics cool your heels for a bit!

What is the difference between a casket and a coffin?

What religion requires a coffin be made of plain wood, joined with wooden pegs with no metal parts or adornments?

Many caskets are made of nice hardwoods. However, many are made of pine for a reason. Why?

Some coffins today are even made of cardboard. Aside from cost savings, why would cardboard be a desired material?

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#2

sharon in topanga

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

Try Judaism for the religion.

My dictionary gives coffin as a synonym for casket???

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#3

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

Cardboard coffins might be used for cremations. Don't know about the other stuff. Hopin' not to need one for a while!

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#4

Right & Wrong

Your first answer is correct.

The second statement is not. :-)

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#5

Not really...

Carboard coffins might be used that way but not what I'm after.

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#6

Cardboard will compost eventually

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#7

OK my WAG's

1. A casket is lined a coffin isin't.

2. No clue

3. Pine is cheaper and used for buring low life scums (I'm thinking the old west here)

4. Cardboard is biodegradble for the big "green" sleep.

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#8

sharon in topanga

Re: Right & Wrong

A casket is a fancy box used to hold jewelery or other valuables, but I didn't think that was what you were after. Other than that, they are the same, although the funeral industry would have you think differently.

How about cardboard for environmental reasons?

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#9

Correct on that one

You and Scott got that one. Cardboard is often used when someone is buried in a nature area or somewhere that eco-friendly bio-degradable means are desired. In other words...you become worm food much faster! ;-)

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#10

1) No, 2)No, 3) No, 4) Yes

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#11

This time Wrong and Right ;-)

Wrong on the first part but correct about the environmentally friendly part.

I'm glad nobody made any tasteless homeless person-cardboard box remarks! ;-)

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#12

Re: Correct on that one

Also burns faster in the crematory.

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#13

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

1). A casket is rectilinear in shape. A coffin is "body" shaped.

3). Ex-parrots are buried in Pine and buried in the Fjords.

Dan.

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#14

First one correct, Second, not really.

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#15

Answers

A coffin is generally a burial box that is wider at the shoulders and narrower at the feet. A casket tends to be more of an American innovation and is a rectangular box. There are other shapes but I'm just covering the basics.

Orthodox Judaism is the religion that requires coffins to be of plain wood with no metal parts.

Pine coffins are often used instead of nicer woods for cremation....mostly for the economics. I do not have information about the use of cardboard for cremation but it makes sense for the same reason.

Cardboard coffins are used when the burial takes place in a nature area or wehere eco-friendly means are required. They bio-degrade more efficiently. Next time I buy a fridge I'll be sure to save the box. ;-)

Thanks for playing!

Tommy

Re: First Humpday of Summer Questions

#16

Re: Elaboration

Caskets for Orthodox Jewish burial may contain no metal, and even any glues used in their manufacture must be of "natural" sources - merely "bio-degradable" isn't sufficient. Any linings, which usually aren't fancy, must also be of cotton or linen, that is, plant fibres that decompose completely. Occasionally, they are called "Kosher Caskets." Finally, the body itself is wrapped in little more than a shroud, although there are some interesting specifications regarding this as well. Upon burial, the casket must be placed directly in contact with the soil to hasten decomposition. Even in cemetaries where some kind of vault is required, it is little more than a "four-poster" of cinder blocks with a cement slab atop it, to prevent the grave sinking in when the casket collapses. The source of this information is "The Jewish Mourner's Book of Why" by Alfred J. Kolatch, and personal observation.

An additional material for casket manufacture is particle board for use in cremations. It burns nicely and completely, and the resulting ash can be separated from the remains very easily.

Finally, there is a company in the southern US that is making caskets out of ground almond hulls in some kind of binder. The resulting material moulds like plastic and machines where necessary like wood. It's weight is about the same as wood. It is probably not very biodegradable, and I'm sure the EPA would have something to say about burning it.

How did we get on this topic, anyway? Oh yeah, coffins are body shaped, while caskets are boxes, and a coffin can be shipped inside a casket.

Lovely topic for a Humpday.

FNelson

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.