WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

Posts

Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

Edited #1

admin

wood-2601_990.jpg

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#3

I have no idea, but I'd guess you borrowed this from another forum. Anyway, I use ChatGPT for a lot for things I don't have a clue about, so I tried it using the photo asking it to ID the pith of the embedded stem. Here are the results, but are they meaningful?   
https://chatgpt.com/share/6970158c-56d0-800d-a95c-8e2b51fc58ec

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#4

Huh....
I would guess pecan, but as Jim noted, the pic is limited.  Could be lots of woods.

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

Edited #5

admin

@Dale Stansbery,
I obtained this image from Woodfinder and assumed it was appropriate. However, AI did not identify it as what it was intended to represent. Rather than speculate further, I will post a few additional images that I know are accurate and more representative.

wood-2601b_991.jpgwood-2601a_992.jpgwood-2601c_993.jpgwood-2601d_994.jpg

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#6

Sticking with pecan.... or hickory, pretty much the same thing I've heard, at least in commercial lumber.  Only pecan I ever cut up looked like hickory but was not as hard and dense.

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#7

I aske ChatGPT about hickory/pecan.
"Short answer: very unlikely.
Here’s why.


Hickory & pecan (Carya spp.) pith characteristics

Hickory and pecan have very small, often barely visible pith that is:

  • Tight and pin-point sized

  • Frequently off-center

  • Sometimes crushed or discontinuous

  • Much smaller relative to twig diameter than what’s in your photo

On finished lumber, hickory/pecan pith usually looks like:

  • a hairline dot, or

  • a tiny dark speck that’s easy to miss

They do not normally show a clearly defined, round pith like the one in your image.


What your photo shows instead

Your embedded twig has:

  • A clearly visible, round pith

  • Uniform shape

  • Proportionally large compared to the twig diameter

  • No chambering or collapse

That combination strongly points to diffuse-porous species, not ring-porous woods like hickory or pecan.


Ring-porous vs diffuse-porous (key distinction)

  • Hickory / Pecan → ring-porous, tiny pith

  • Maple / Poplar / Birch / Willow → diffuse-porous, visible round pith

Your example matches the second group.


Bottom line

While anything is possible in theory, hickory or pecan would be a very poor match for the pith shown.
From an identification standpoint, they’re essentially ruled out.
If you want to be 100% certain, a clean end-grain photo of the board would settle it immediately—ring-porous hickory/pecan is unmistakable under even a hand lens.

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#8

Yeah, maybe.
I don't much care what AI thinks though.

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#9

admin

Maybe my idea for a recurring "Identify this wood" topic using images from Woodfinder wasn't one of my shining moments. :)

Kinda tough to identify a wood species based on a small image.

The answer BTW for this one is...

Hickory

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#10

how did you identify it?

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

Edited #11

admin

@Dale Stansbery,

I didn't identify it; I copied it from Woodfinder. It has a Wood Library of wood photos, descriptions and sources. My "brilliant idea" was to periodically pick a photo and post it in this puzzler forum.

But maybe that's more frustrating and annoying than fun and educational. A little thumb-sized photo isn't enough to go on in identifying the many types of wood.

What say y'all?

Re: Identify This Wood! [Jan 2026]

#12

I thought it was ok, fun wise - but then I would think that in retrospect.  

Had the wood been something else it would be entirely predictable for me to be bitter and negative about the whole exercise - so I wouldn't blame anyone for taking this opinion with a grain of salt.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.