WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Turning Punky Wood

Posts

Turning Punky Wood

#1

Doug in Seattle

A nice lady donated a lot of really pretty spalted big leaf maple to my turning club, South Puget Sound Woodturners in Puyallup, WA.  I am trying to turn her a few thank you gifts but, some of the wood is a little on the punky side and the rest of the same piece is rock solid.  Getting a lot of tear out.

I am aware of the saying about life being too short to work with bad wood but, I am trying to thank her with her own wood.

What food safe treatment can I use to make the wood better for simple bowls?  I have some Minwax Wood Hardner.  I have stabilized wood with Cactus Juice but these bowls are too big to fit in the tanks I have.  I've seen some videos where they used epoxy thinned 50% with acetone.

What treatment have you had success with?

Thank you in advance for your assistance, Doug

Re: Turning Punky Wood

Edited #2

Doug,
You'll find a very comprehensive article at http://www.woodrestoration.com/  although it concerns a particular product brand  with which that I have no experience.  I have used Total Boat penetrating epoxy that can be additionally thinned.  Check with Jamestown Distributors.com for specifics.

Have I turned rotted wood? You bet.  Hows this

Punk.jpg

for punk.

What did I use?  NC lacquer thinned and applied on the lathe with final (many-many-many) coats in black spray lacquer. I got this:

2Black.jpg

Jar was turned on a waste block to about 1/4" with honed tools [gouge and skew].  The lacquer actually penetrated through the walls so the piece wound up as a lacquer/wood composite.  Aside from the wood and lacquer, the primary ingredient was . .  Much Time.

Good Luck

Re: Turning Punky Wood

#3

Joe Fleming

I've used PolyAll 2000 (from Canada, I think), I've used Minwax Wood Harderner, and I've used Cactus Juice (which is quite a process).  The PolyAll was more like a filler that hardened the wood.   When turning, it smelled bad and behaved more like plastic. The Minwax stiffened the fibers, but did not really fill the micro-voids in the punky wood.  Not much of a filler.  Cactus Juice definitely filled in the chunk to stabilize the whole thing.  I liked it best, but you need a vacuum pump, a vacuum chamber and an oven to cook the wood.  Plus, Cactus Juice is not cheap.

Re: Turning Punky Wood

#4

You can get wood stabilized if you don't want to mess around with all the hardware to do it yourself.  K & G Finishing in AZ is where I had some done a few years ago.

Re: Turning Punky Wood

#5
Joe Fleming wrote:

I've used PolyAll 2000 (from Canada, I think), I've used Minwax Wood Harderner, and I've used Cactus Juice (which is quite a process).  The PolyAll was more like a filler that hardened the wood.   When turning, it smelled bad and behaved more like plastic. The Minwax stiffened the fibers, but did not really fill the micro-voids in the punky wood.  Not much of a filler.  Cactus Juice definitely filled in the chunk to stabilize the whole thing.  I liked it best, but you need a vacuum pump, a vacuum chamber and an oven to cook the wood.  Plus, Cactus Juice is not cheap.


Hey Joe,

PolyAll  was a great product, I used it with a lot of success.  It was designed to restore damaged and rotted wood in classic cars.  However, it is no longer manufactured.

Ric

Re: Turning Punky Wood

#6

I tried PolyAll (the Canadian stuff) but found it unworkable as it set up way too fast for my use.

Re: Turning Punky Wood

#7

Joe Fleming

Ric,

Good to know on PolyAll.  When I was in Colorado for the symposium, Cindy Drozda gave me an unused kit.  I used up a kit years ago, so now I'm ready for more stuff.

Joe

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.