WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Photos for the AWR competition

Posts

Photos for the AWR competition

#1

Each year the Australian Wood Review Magazine holds a National and International furniture competition, "Maker of the Year". I entered once, a few years ago, and I think they lost my entry as I did not get in the top 100. I think that they were genuinely racked with guilt over this, as they did not reply to my demands for a recount!

Faced with the opportunity to embarrass them once again, I decided to enter my pair of nightstands. No one in this world is going to take them as serious furniture - that's my story for another failure to place, and I'm sticking to it!! We'll see. 

In seriousness, it is just fun to be a part of something like this. (And, no, I do not fancy my chances).

Here are the photos I entered ... only these are much lower definition to fit on the website (these average 130 Kb and the entries were around the 3 Mb range). And don't hassle me about the background or lighting - my handheld iPhone 11 rules!

1006x692

877x692

922x692

880x692

849x692

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Photos for the AWR competition

#2

Good Luck
Tell'em the whole world is watching!
;)

Re: Photos for the AWR competition

#3

Ellis Walentine

I'd like to know how the judges reach their conclusions. There are so many ways it can be done. "Maker of the Year" indicates to me that it is not a design competition, rather that craftsmanship itself should be the main criterion, regardless of the entry's complexity or overall aesthetic.

I've been involved with so many competitions over the years that I know how random and subjective the judging process can be, depending largely on how the contest is specified. How, for example, can you judge between a reproduction Chippendale highboy and a jewelry box, or a kayak, or a modern chest of drawers; yet that is how impossible many of these contests can be to judge. If everyone had to make the same nightstands, and the finest craftsmanship won the prize, I don't doubt that you'd get the honors.

Your nightstands are unique and stand up to the highest scrutiny of craftsmanship, Derek. Here's wishing you all the best.

Ellis

Re: Photos for the AWR competition

#5

Ellis Walentine

Ha, so it is a design competition! You'll be relying on the judges' subjective judgment. My friend Kirby would have some thoughts on this.

Good luck!

Ellis

Re: Photos for the AWR competition

#6

This is clearly a winner! If they don't find it so, then F*%()%ck them!

Re: Photos for the AWR competition

#7

Seriously, Derek, the body of work you have done over the years and the education to all of us who follow your entries, deserved a big Blue Ribbon!!  BZ my friend~~~!!!  Philip

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.