A riot helmet may very well offer a higher level of protection to the head & face, however you still have to transfer / dissipate the impact energy to somewhere. It doesn't simply disappear.
More chance of secondary injuries to neck or from the turner being knocked to the ground and injured in the resuting fall or striking say the corner of a bandsaw / tablesaw table on the way down.
Best not to get hit in the first place by turning at safe speeds and using higher levels protections such as sound turning practices, robust mounting techniques, inspecting blanks etc.
I have had a piece fly off the lathe and catch me dead center of the forehead. I was reaching for the switch with my left hand and the face shield with the right. Got ahead of myself. I was much luckier than Lynn. 27 stitches and I was back home. An inch lower and I could have lost an eye.
I believe Lynn has sort of over calculated this. Figured "impact" against a rigid stationary target. I think the impact would have been less than the calculations indicated. And I believe any face shield is better than none. That said, that's no excuse not wear a good one.
I have wondered about using a catchers mask or something similar under a plastic shield or a chainsaw mask. Or, how about doubling the plastic on a cheap shield?