Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

Posts

Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#1

Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

Darrin hill

Going to start playing with segmented rings... Just want to add a ring around the top of a hollow form or something like that...

So I have kiln dried walnut and maple... And there is a lumber mill I think I can get mesquite planks from... But theirs would be air dried on racks with stickers between... And my hollow forms are usually rough turned and set aside for a while... So would combining the different ways of drying into one turning work out badly? Ie can I used air dried segs with kiln dried segs on the same ring, or stick to one type of dried wood ? Ie dry on dry?

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#2

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

Brian Roberts

I would be more concerned that the pieces have all reached the same moisture content.

If yours is stored indoors give any wood brought in that has reached an "outdoors" moisture equilibrium at least several weeks to adjust to the humidity level in your indoor storage area.

Beyond that....you can only hope the sawing was done correctly (as is possible) and no stresses remain that will surface when cut into different sizes....and thicknesses.....but you can almost count on some issues.....depending on how small your segments are.

At times it may be best to rough cut your parts....allow some time ...then cut to final size.....but YMMV!

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#3

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

john lucas

There isn't much difference in Kiln dried vs Air Dried for your purpose. Either one could be cut from trees that have stress and possible wood movement. However in pieces as small as your talking about the wood movement will be extremely small.

the biggest problem will be the wood movement differences between the solid wood vessel and the segmented rim. If you put a tenon on the segmented rim piece that is a hair smaller than the hole your putting it in and use a glue that allows some wood movement you shouldn't have a problem.

Many years ago I did the opposite. I put a solid wood rim of about 4 1/2" on a segmented vessel of that size. The rim cracked. It does close up in the winter when the humidity is down but opens in the summer. That was 1995 when I built it. I've been researching wood movement problems as they relate to my work ever since. I probably go over board now but I'd rather do that than have a piece self destruct.

Depending on the size of your segmented rim you really won't have much movement and it shouldn't be much of a problem. However if you add a 3 or 4 inch diameter piece I would look more closely at glue up solutions.

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#4

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

robo hippy

When they come out of the kilns, they have a pretty low moisture content, and it is probably similar after 'adjusting' to life in the real world. The biggest differences between kiln dried, air dried, solar kiln dried, or vacuum kiln dried, is that the standard kiln dried wood seems to have stress in the pieces. When ripping 8/4 boards on my bandsaw, there can be huge 'spring' in the boards both cupping and warping with the standard kiln boards. The others move very little if at all.

robo hippy

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#5

That depends on the tree & kiln operator

Dick Coers

not the overall process of kiln drying. Nice trees and a skilled kiln operator will produce wood of high quality and with a total lack of internal stresses.

As for the original post. I've felt a lot of glue lines on segmented work where the wood moves, or the glue moves, or both. Mesquite is known as one of the most stable woods. An air dried burl may be the most unstable wood. The biggest help is to not be in a hurry. I would build a retired refrigerator bowl kiln for the hollow forms after roughing if I was doing it.

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#6

ebd

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

ebd

I wouldn't worry. It's far more important that the segments have perfect joints and the joint between the ring and the solid part(s) are perfect. I've got many bowls with top and bottom solid and a segmented ring between that I made as prototypes out of all kinds of wood. They sit im my shop year round and none of them has had problems with joint failure. The shop goes from near 100°F with high humidity in the summer to negative numbers and no humidity in the winter. When I'm working diring the winter the temp will jump to around 80°F in a very short time when I fire up my barrel stove. Those are some pretty extreme conditions but still never had a joint fail.

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

#7

Re: Kiln dried vs air dried vs ...

Bill Jacksonville, NC

While kiln drying produces a lower wood moisture content. True, but only for a little while, all wood will seek equilibrium with relative humidity in the environment so MC bound to change. To be safe let your kiln dry wood hang out in the shop for week or two before working so can reach same EMC as your air dried wood.