Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Grinder trouble

Posts

Grinder trouble

#1

Grinder trouble

Jorge

Hi,

my grinder just went south, it was always a shaker until it got to a certain speed, but now when I turn it off when it goes below that threshold it shakes violently, so it is time to replace it.

When I bought it I tried several brands, none of them went to "sleep" a Delta was particularly bad. What is out there these days that is good?

Thanks for the advice...

Re: Grinder trouble

#2

Re: Grinder trouble

Donna Banfield

Jorge, the Rikon, carried by Woodcraft has gotten very good early reviews. Bill Blasic did a comparison between the Rikon 8" and the Jet 8". His opinion, the Rikon, being half the cost of the Jet, performed just as well.

I haven't seen anything bad on the forums about the Rikon, either. And it will take the CBN wheels.

Re: Grinder trouble

#3

Re: Grinder trouble

Jorge

Thank you Donna, much appreciated, glad you mention the diamond wheels, it was on my mind.

I'll look into the Rikon, the good thing about Woodcraft is that we can return with no hassle if we don't like it.

Re: Grinder trouble

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Grinder trouble

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Jorge, I too recently bought one of the Rikon slow speed grinders that were on sale to replace a Delta full-speed grinder that had developed some starting issues. I have a few comments to offer. First, the Rikon looks like a toy compared to the Delta. Second, despite that, it runs well and is virtually vibration free with two CBN wheels mounted on it. Third, the shafts are a bit short and you cannot quite get a full thread on the mounting nuts when using two D-Way CBN wheels. The last does not seem to be a problem, however and I am quite satisfied with the unit.

Dennis

Re: Grinder trouble

#5

Thank you Dennis


Re: Grinder trouble

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Baldor slow speed...

Jesper, Denmark

Probably not the economical choice, but I have had my Baldor 8" for 20 years now. Dead quiet, solid cast iron construction, 3/4" shaft and an 80 grit Norton 3X on one side and a 180 grit 40 mm CBN on the other side. The CBN fits with the safety cover on, but had to shim out the end plate 2 mm.

It will outlast me.

Re: Grinder trouble

#7

Re: Grinder trouble

Bill Howatt

Have you tried running it without the wheels? Shaking grinders often mean the wheels are out of balance, not the grinder.

Bill

Re: Grinder trouble

#8

Ric Taylor

Re: Grinder trouble

Ric Taylor

Jorge,

CBN wheels and diamond wheels are not the same thing. They are very different.

Ric

Re: Grinder trouble

#9

Re: Grinder trouble

john lucas

Don't use diamond wheels for turning tools. They clog up.

Re: Grinder trouble

#10

Re: Baldor slow speed...

Jorge

Jesper,

You are right Baldor is high quality, less expensive in the long run.

Thank you!

Re: Grinder trouble

#11

Re: Grinder trouble

Jorge

Bill, yes it still shakes

Re: Grinder trouble

#12

Ric and John

Jorge

Thanks.

I knew that, I was not thinking when I posted. Sorry.

Re: Grinder trouble

#13

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Grinder trouble

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I've been using a slow speed General Int. for 15 years, they are common and with the One Way balancers it's prime for my money..

Take care, Jim

Re: Grinder trouble

#14

Re: Grinder trouble

Mike Brazeau

Not sure it has enough umph for CBN wheels.

Re: Grinder trouble

#15

Re: Grinder trouble

John lucas

My slow speed woodcraft grinder has a 3/4 horse motor and it struggles to spin the CBN wheel but its been doing it cor over a year now with no problem

Re: Grinder trouble

#16

What grit do you prefer for CBN wheels?

Jorge

Honing after sharpening?

My carving tools very seldom need grinding, I just keep honing them.

Would honing help the turning tools?

Re: Grinder trouble

#17

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Controversial opinion.....

Jesper, Denmark

The way you cut with chisels and carving gouges is vastly different than how you use turning gouges.

If you really look at the way a bowl gouge cuts in the traditional push cut, the very tip cuts like a chisel, but the wings do the initial hogging off in scraping mode. The further away from the tip, the more the edges functions as a scraper.

The burr is quickly worn off the tip, but actually does the cutting on the wings.

The logical conclusion then is: Honing is not advantageous for bowl gouges.

I use mostly Thompson tools. 80 grit Norton 3X makes a lasting burr on scrapers. A 180 grit CBN is used for all gouges without honing. Skews are free-handed Cap'n. Eddie style on the CBN. The burr on tools with an included angle around 30° or less is very small and weak, so disappears very fast. Mostly, I do not hone skews, as it seems unnecessary.

Re: Grinder trouble

#18

Re: Controversial opinion.....

Jorge

Thank you Jesper

Re: Grinder trouble

#19

Re: What grit do you prefer for CBN wheels?

john lucas

I don't hone my turning tools either. I do hone the skew sometimes when I think the wood will be a problem. I don't know where you draw the line between finer and finer sharpening. Let me define what I'm saying first. What I call honing is the final leather stropping of carving tools and razor blades. What I call sharpening is using some sort of abrasive to remove material.

I have been playing with sharpening with finer and finer grits to see if there is an advantage. A very good article in Woodturning magazine a bunch of years back more or less proved that sharpening to much finer grits made the tool edge last longer. So that's a given. I haven't really been able to prove it myself yet.

Do I get a finer quality cut with finer grits. Yes. When turning some exotic wood spindles last year I sharpened the same tool on the Tormek at 1000 grit (if you believe what they say) and then some on my 180 grit CBN. I could see the difference in the wood although it was subtle enough that 600 grit paper easily polished the surface afterwords. Could not really tell if the edge lasted longer.

I have also used a strip sander in finer grits and the tools do seem to hold an edge longer but the speed is too fast on my strip sander and it's extremely easy to blue the tool edge at anything finer than 180.

I do like the Tormek but you do wear the wheel and it will eventually have to be replaced. I think my preference in sharpening at this time the 180 grit CBN. It doesn't wear. GRinds fast enough that you can easily change an edge or correct a sharpening error yet it still produces an edge that is sharp enough to leave a very clean cut on the wood. I still might invest in the newer 320 grit CBN but I'm not sure it's much of an advantage over the 180 and is a lot of money. I have sharpened on my 3320 grit sanding belt and do like the edge better but it's just too easy to blue an edge. The CBN cuts cooler so maybe it won't be a problem.

I think a good choice for newer turners (I know you aren't new) is an 80 grit wheel on one side and 180 grit on the other. The 80 would let you shape new tools that don't come with grind you want, or to reshape a current tool, and the 180 would be your general sharpening tool.

Re: Grinder trouble

#20

Re: What grit do you prefer for CBN wheels?

Jorge

Thank you John,

Shopping around for that CBN wheel.