Re: Controversial opinion.....
Jesper, Denmark
The way you cut with chisels and carving gouges is vastly different than how you use turning gouges.
If you really look at the way a bowl gouge cuts in the traditional push cut, the very tip cuts like a chisel, but the wings do the initial hogging off in scraping mode. The further away from the tip, the more the edges functions as a scraper.
The burr is quickly worn off the tip, but actually does the cutting on the wings.
The logical conclusion then is: Honing is not advantageous for bowl gouges.
I use mostly Thompson tools. 80 grit Norton 3X makes a lasting burr on scrapers. A 180 grit CBN is used for all gouges without honing. Skews are free-handed Cap'n. Eddie style on the CBN. The burr on tools with an included angle around 30° or less is very small and weak, so disappears very fast. Mostly, I do not hone skews, as it seems unnecessary.