Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Posts

Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#1

Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Chris Hoehle

One personal challenge I'm working on is mastering the Richard Raffan back cut for hollowing end grain and I've decided it would be advantageous to have a 5/8" diameter gouge for this, so I'm looking at Thompson tools and deciding if it would be better to have a spindle gouge or a detail gouge for this application. I'm leaning towards a detail gouge (his shallow detail gouge isn't available in this diameter so luckily the choice has been narrowed down somewhat).

Video of the technique I'm talking about:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zz8r7zhnSg

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#2

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I don't know what back hollowing is. My wife hollows 100+ end grain Christmas ornaments yearly. This is mostly done in ambrosia red maple and tropical hardwoods with a Hunter #1 tool. She bought her first one in 2006 and hasn't looked back. She hollowed fifty red maple 2" diameter bells before she needed to turn the cutter for a fresh edge! The Hunter is the only tool that touches the inside. Don't spend your free time sharpening, Keep on hollowing with a Hunter!

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#3

a 5/8" gouge is huge for this

Dick Coers

Never made the cut, but a 5/8" is huge. Maybe you are doing 10" diameter stuff though, you didn't say.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#4

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Chris Hoehle

Yeah, I have a hunter tool I need to try out more as well (and some of the old Mitch Wolok hook tools also), so It's not like I don't have other options, but I want to master the back hollowing cut regardless, it's a personal challenge/"building skills to be a completely competent master turner" kinda thing. (In other words, the thought of a cut or technique out there that I don't yet know how to do gets under my skin and I want to learn how to do it just because).

Also, in the hands of a master like RR, nothing is faster than this cut for end-grain hollowing small boxes. In some of his videos, he has a 3" deep, 2 1/2" diameter box hollowed out in less time than in took me to type this!

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#5

Re: a 5/8" gouge is huge for this

Chris Hoehle

Nope, nowhere near 10" :D

Just end grain boxes of the "usual size" i.e. 2-3" diameter, 3-5" tall. Just was thinking the larger diameter tool would be better for hanging off the rest cutting towards the bottom of the taller ones.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#6

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Kind of interesting watching the video. Richard would have the job in about 5 seconds with much heavier cuts.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#7

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

bill tucker

RR sharpened a spindle gouge for me to try this cut during a class. One of the tricks was his free-hand sharpening which allowed him to extend the left cutting edge back. The trick was to put an edge on the side without rolling it over too much. If you try to use a veri-grind, it usually will roll the edge over such that the body of the gouge contacts the wood just before the edge. At least that what it seemed to be doing. With his grind, it worked......with mine, not so much. Good Luck.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#8

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

don stephan

Just last week I received a 1/2" spindle or detail gouge from Doug Thompson for back hollowing. Wish I could tell you which particular version I received. I've always used the back hollowing signature gouge from Craft USA but it is back ordered so I decided to get one from Doug. The Raffan gouge always felt more stout, perhaps because it is not as long. I wouldn't expect the larger diameter of a 5/8 gouge would present any problems in use.

I was able to remove wood equally quickly with either tool.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#9

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Joe Herrmann

The gouge we used for back hollowing in Richard's class was a 9/16" spindle gouge.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#10

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Long left bevel

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Bill, I haven't specifically tried to do a grind for back hollowing, but you can avoid the round-over by opening up the angle of the varigrind jig to the extent needed. I would start with the jig angle in about mid-range and increasing it if needed. You might want to experiment a bit.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#11

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I forgot to mention that although I do not do a lot of end grain back hollowing, when do need to so, I grab a long sidegrind bowl gouge. It works well for me.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#12

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

George

I use the 1/2" detail gouge for this cut. If it is a smaller box, the 3/8 works too. You can't hang as much tool over the rest.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#13

Re: Long left bevel

bill tucker

thanks - will give it a try

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#14

Steven Antonucci

Best gouge is a hook

steven antonucci


Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#15

I like the Hunter Hercules for rough stock removal

john lucas

followed by the Hunter #5 for cleaning up any tool marks and tearout. I used to use the Hook tool and then the Ring tool but you never have to stop and sharpen the Hunter cutters.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#16

Re: Best gouge is a hook

RCH

Jamie Donaldson recently loaned me a hook tool to try since I'm interested in various aspects of traditional turning. I spent some time using it to cut face grain to hollow a bowl from a chunk of cherry. I was really impressed by how smooth the tool left the surface, even in the hands of someone who had never touched a hook tool before. Hardly would require even fine sanding.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#17

Re: a 5/8" gouge is huge for this

Dale Miner

I spoke with RR at a symposium about this. He recommended a 3/8" spindle gouge (European measure).

When commenting that after about 2.5 inches deep I was having trouble he pointed out an area on his gouge that had a touch of relief ground on the bevel and said that small change would help. He also commented that 2.5" to 3" was about the limit for the back hollowing cut.

My personal experience is that 2.5" to 3" diameter is also the limit. Beyond that diameter keeping the bevel against the wood without having a catch or heavy chatter becomes near impossible.

The back cut is useful for quick stock removal. Finishing cuts, not so much.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#18

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Sergio

Spindle gouge.

Size depends on the size of the hollowing you want to make but... Can somebody explain to me where is the advantage of this cut vs the same identical cut at 9 o'clock? Meaning almost parallel to the tool rest? This is what I use, easy, no catch if you you want to try, fast and efficient.

I love Raffn books, but this is beyond me.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#19

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

john lucas

I'm with you although the cut I do is really more of a scrape. Raffen is rubbing the bevel on the side the way he does it and removes a lot more wood than I do. Still I'm able to open up a box in just a few strokes using a 3/8" thompson detail gouge ground with swept back wings using the same setting on the wolverine jig that I use on my Bowl gouge.

Lately (before February when I had to move my shop) I started using the Hunter Hercules to rough out the inside of a box. It goes at least as fast as the detail gouge for me. Because it cuts like a scraper you can cut in both directions, from the rim down and then back out toward the rim. Leaves a pretty good finish as is but then I take the Hunter #4 or #5 and clean it up which leaves a finish I barely have to sand.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#20

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Mike Foster

My take on this is that Richard devloped this method way before all of the myriad of hollowing tools that are on the market now. He was doing large production runs (scoops were the major thing) and time and efficiency was essential to him. I've seen him demo this a number of times (first time about 20 years ago in Phoenix) and it is truly awesome to watch. I can do the cut and it really is efficient and fast. Takes some practice to get the hang of it. It is a blind cut, and it is a cut, not a scrape, so it can be a little daunting because you can't see what's happening. I like to do it once in a while just because it is a fun cut quite different from what we usually do.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#21

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I agree and would add that Richard regarded this cut as a fast roughing out procedure, not for finishing the inside. He typically used scrapers inside, as I remember.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#22

Thanks for all the tips so far. Any grind pics?

Chris Hoehle

Thanks to all those that commented so far. Some that have had success have mentioned grind modifications to the left wing and I think I get what y'all are saying at least enough to get started, but if anyone that has had some success with this cut could post a pic or two of their grinds or talk more about that, it would be really helpful.

Also, I definitely realize there are plenty of other ways to hollow. I've got hook tools I need to make a handle for (and making some of my own out of drill rod per Alan Lacer's instructions is "on the list" for someday too) and I've got a Hunter tool I haven't played around with much. I think a couple of Mike's comments sum up why I want to play around with doing it this way:

"I can do the cut and it really is efficient and fast"

"I like to do it once in a while just because it is a fun cut quite different from what we usually do. "

Seems kinda like rolling beads with a skew to me- not something every turner is going to want to learn how to do necessarily, but really sweet once you get through the learning curve.

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#23

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

mo'wood

I use a common ⅜" spindle gouge with a swept back grind, though larger sizes will work too.

A few details that may help you avoid exceptionaly memorable catches when doing the back-hollowing cut are:

1. The gouge flute is rolled over to the right, and the path of the cutting edge (left wing of the gouge) is nearly straight up to 12 o'clock in relation to center, while the handle stays on the left side of the axis of rotation while dropping down.

2.The cut is started just inside the edge of the opening, so that the back of the gouge rubs the edge of the opening.

This was the key for me to become comfortable with this cut: you use the surface of the interior and the edge of the opening to lever the tool up into the interior, while still keeping contact with that tool rest, which can't be set too low or too high. The cut starts at center, but the bevel rubs a lone that is nearly vertical, while the cutting edge works between 12 and 2 o'clock. There must be room to drop the handle without striking the lathe bed, and forward pressure must be maintained to keep the bevel on the wood.

It works best with a grind that isn't too steep- a slightly rounded left bevel helps too. And lots of practice. And a sense of humor. And catch-proof wood.

Good luck!

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

#24

Re: Best gouge for back-hollowing cut? (end grain)

Chris Hoehle

Thanks! This is very helpful. The shop is a mess right now getting rearranged for a new bandsaw coming next week but I'm looking forward to getting things organized again and trying these tips out.