Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

adding weight

Posts

adding weight

#1

adding weight

eliot feldman

I was having some not -so -much fun turning a deep narrow vessel -- a simple cylinder about 3 in diameter and about 14 in deep. It's really too deep , and even with heavy duty hollowing rigs, it just stopped cutting at about 9 inches in. Yet I have turned much larger hollow vessels this deep. So I got the idea that the mistake I made was to turn such a narrow vessel on the outside first, thereby taking away "ballast" wood near the base and leaving only a three inch diameter near the base. I mean ,I've have always turned the outside first. I believe just about everybody does ( unless using an inside light with wet wood). So what about bolting on some more or less symmetrical tube -shaped wood thingy near the base to fool the object into thinking that it still has a heavy part near the base? I will try it next but I though I'd ask here first to see if anyone has tried it. Please note that I am not talking about adding weight to the spindle behind the piece. That won't do anything in my opinion; it would simply make the piece stick out further.

Re: adding weight

#2

Re: adding weight

John Veerkamp

Your problem with this approach is that your weights will be very difficult to get in balance. If you have enough patience and fiddle a lot, it might help. The biggest problem though is the tendency of the piece to flex as it revolves. I don't think that adding weight will help this.

My 2 cents.

Re: adding weight

#3

Re: adding weight

Don Evans

I'm curious, what cutter are u using? If it's one that touches a very very small area like a square 3/16" with the tip sharpened roundess u need to make sure to put enough angle on it so only the cutting edge is hitting the wood.

With that small radii it is possible for the cutter to hit the wood first down from the cutting edge and the cutting edge never touches the wood.

I would try switching to a half moon scraper cutter and see if it does better also.

You have MAYBE more cutting area touching.

Keep in mind that if you are using one of the square stick type cutters the larger it is the greater the possibility is that the top of the cutter (which does all the cutting) isn't touching the wood.

A WAG on my next thing is with those sizes (diameters, etc) you would need a really large angle on the end and edge of the cutter. Maybe 30 degs

If you have a handle made for the half moon scraper I talked about as opposed to a boring bar look at how the cutter mounts on the handle both of the ones I have are made so the scraper is set at a negative angle.

Don -- a WAG if you don't know is a Wild As_ Guess.

Re: adding weight

#4

Re: adding weight

Dick Coers

I'm having a little trouble understanding some of the information. You still have 5" of wood in the bottom and you want to add weight? Or do you want to add diameter? You'll have to describe your tool so we can understand why it stopped cutting. I've had to readjust the tool rest going that deep and it won't take out the nib in the center because it's below center on the long reach.

I can't imagine anyone cutting the inside first. How on earth would you know what form you had? My homemade optical system is good, buy still no X-ray feature!

Re: adding weight

#5

I suggest that you first shape......

JamieDonaldson

... the upper portion on the outside, then hollow down to that area on the inside. Then continue to shape outside in steps, following with hollowing to that level. Leaving mass at the base exterior allows more support in both the mounting and eliminates most flexing as the hollowing goes deeper. Maintaining the desired profile comes with practice, and really enhances the freedom from ooopppsss! ;)

Re: adding weight

#6

Re: I suggest that you first shape......

john lucas

I'm with 2 camps on this one. If your cutter stops cutting then the bevel is hitting the wood before the tip. I'm guessing either you have tilted the whole bar down so it's cutting below center or the cutter has too blunt of an angle on the grind and the lower part of the bevel is hitting first. Could also be the angle of the cutter. Are you sharpening the sides so it cuts all the way around the tip.

The other Camp is with Jamie. When I took a class with Frank Sudol we turned 14" deep vessels to about 2 mm thick. We turned about 3 or 4 inches the outside and then turned the inside down almost that far. Then turned a few more inches of the outside and repeated on the inside. Worked great.

OK I lied there are 3 camps. When I turn my very thin Bowl from a Board pieces it's very easy to get chatter because I turn the whole outside first because the shape is crucial. What I do is Hot glue stabilizing wings from the chuck to the outside of the bowl. Sort of like Flying Buttress's if you know what those are. It's amazing how much it stabilizes the wood while turning the inside.

Re: adding weight

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: adding weight

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Sounds like a job for a steady rest, although I am surprised that you had problems at that depth unless you hogged out to full depth before starting finish cuts.

Re: adding weight

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: I suggest that you first shape......

Brad Vietje

Never heard of anyone using the now-famous "John Lucas flying buttress method" -- sounds pretty cool.

But otherwise, there is good advice here. I use smaller cutters the deeper I go to minimize the cutting forces when well out over the rest, but in practice, I tend to use 3/16" for almost everything except a 3/8" bullet scraper and a larger teardrop scraper for cleanup and smoothing after the bulk hollowing is done. It seems the profile of your cutter is the issue. You can cut as far above center as you wish (though you will leave quite a nib at center), but you really don't ever want to cut below center on the inside -- that can lead to a rather loud and violent incident.

If you can show us the cutter you are using, that would help. Stay at or above center with a slight negative rake and make sure the bevel angle is acute enough to engage the cutting edge w/out hitting the bottom of the cutter, and you should be fine.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: adding weight

#9

maybe another option . . .

hu lowery

First, it does seem that quitting cutting is a tooling issue not an issue with the piece.

However, obviously other issues are possible, even probable. For vibration dampening, to add strength, and to keep my green wood round I have cut a series of MDF circles out of the 3/4" stuff. Cutting one series out of one piece of MDF and one out of another it really takes very little material to get a lot of rings.

Should work great, notice I say should, I haven't had a chance to try them yet!

Hu

Re: adding weight

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: adding weight

Lyle Jamieson

You do not mention vibration but just say it stopped cutting. That is a tool issue not a weight issue. It simply is rubbing on something that is not sharp. My experience shows a smaller cutter is more efficient and takes less wood and works much better than larger cutters.

The other answers were addressing the probable vibration problems. It is impossible to hollow out a 14 inch long piece 3 inches in diameter without vibration. So I start with a much bigger size tree say 8-9 inches in diameter and work in stages as John and Jamie suggest. The vibration from hollowing in your example would come out at the mouth opening and not so much down in the bottom. Vibration inside the bottom would indicate you are exceeding the limits of your boring bar.

Re: adding weight

#11

Re: adding weight

steve worcester

It sounds like a vibration and not a weight issue. Longer vessels will vibrate more for sure. That vibration leads to less efficient cutting. With that said, it depends on what the cutting tip is and the thickness of the bar, and attachment of the cutter to the bar.

But beyond that it is the wood type and the bar thickness.

Without more info, this is not going to get solved.