Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

Posts

Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#1

Jesper, Denmark

Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

Jesper, Denmark

here in a local forum, there is a long and heated discussion of the merits of the Dovetail type jaws, such as on a Vicmarc and clones thereof and the Stronghold/Talon serrated types.

My preference is strongly (sic). for the Stronghold type, as i have seen far too many pieces flying off the dovetail type if the tenon has not been properly matched to the jaw diameter.

What say you?

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#2

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Sergio

Vicmarc, no doubt. I had a stronghold with serrated and sold it. Now I have three Vic 120 abd one 150.

Here is a vase hold with a vic 150. Hollowed free hand no steady. I do not have pictures of the bigger I made.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#3

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Dale Bonertz

I imagine this is one of those questions where it depends on what you are used to using. I know of three people who owned the serrated chucks and never could feel confident with them. As soon as they thought they had it figured out they would lose another piece. All three purchased dove tail chucks (two went vicmarc and the other I think nova but I don't remember for sure). Once they learned how to easily make the dove tail tenon or recess they claim they have not lost a piece. It is so easy to make the dove tail tenon/recess. Contrary to popular belief they don't have to be perfect for holding power, close works fine. In either chuck serrated or dove tail the most important aspect IMO is making the shoulder flat for the jaws to rest against.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#4

I switched to dovetail.

Doc Green

I started out with a Oneway Talon and a Stronghold using serrated jaws. Then I bought a SuperNova2 which has a small dovetailed lip on what is basically a smooth jaw. At first I didn't care for it but came to realize the benefits of the small dovetail. Now I have dovetailed jaws on my three go-to chucks.

The primary benefit of the dovetailed jaws is that I find it easier to re-chuck a piece and get it to run true. Also, with the dovetails, I feel comfortable using a narrower tenon when the situation calls for it. Recently, I mounted a small piece in dovetailed jaws on a tenon that was about 2.5" in diameter but only 1/16" wide. (That's about 62 mm and 2 mm.) That would not have been possible with the serrated jaws I have.

As noted above, the shoulder of the tenon is very important. It should be cleanly cut and the shoulder should be forced against the front of the chuck jaws. To make a dovetailed tenon, I first form a square tenon and then use a spindle gouge (most of the time) to convert the square tenon to a dovetail. The last step takes no more than 5 seconds to do.

The holding power of a chuck depends upon many things such as whether the wood is green or dry, sound or degraded. But in all cases, taking a bit more time to cut a clean, well-shaped tenon will pay off.

Also, in most cases for the maximum holding power, you should use the largest-diameter tenon your chuck and the workpiece will allow. There is one exception: turning a piece that extends "way out" from the chuck jaws (like a tall vase). In that case, using a smaller tenon that matches the natural curve of the jaws give a stronger grip that resists the tendency of the workpiece to move sideways. But that's another story.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#5

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

John Lucas

absolutely love my Vicmarcs. I've never had a piece fail due to the jaw design. I have had a few fail where the tenon was too small or had a defect in the grain running across the tenon. I don't go to extremes to fit the dovetail to the jaws. I take my parting tool and angle it so it cuts a sort of dovetail shape. It probably doesn't match the steel dovetail exactly.

Probably the weakest part of the dovetail design is if you take small jaws and open them up really large to take the wrong size tenon. Then only the 8 corners grab the work. However this can be a good thing when you have to remove a piece and reinstall it. Those 8 corners leave deep impressions that are easy to get the jaws to go directly back into those slots.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#6

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

robo hippy

If you are losing pieces when using dove tail jaws, it isn't the dove tail that is at fault. The dove tail joint offers a locking wedged joint which is much stronger than finger joints (from the flat work world). I use a shaped scraper to form my dove tails. I just can't see the serrated jaws having any advantages at all.

robo hippy

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#7

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Cyril Griesbach

I have them all and no problems.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#8

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Barry L Elder

Vicmarc, no doubt!

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#9

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

John Veerkamp

Oneway also has dovetail jaws for the stronghold and talon chucks. I haven't used the serated jaws for several years now and have had no issues. My issue with the serated jaws is the groves left on what often becomes my foot.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#10

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Don Orr

I have both but my go-to chucks are the Oneways. I have never had a problem with either style. One thing I do with my tenons is to make them a very slight dovetail shape when using serrated jaws. I think it might give me a little better grab as it compresses the fibers. No proof though. Seems to work for me. I do cut the tenon instead of just scraping it to shape. I want the wood to be as solid as possible where the chuck grips-no torn areas.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#11

the mystic of dovetail

David Staeheli

I feel like I am a production turner. In, out and gone. I have dovetail jaws and they sit in the drawer gathering dust. Dovetail jaws seem to me to be like having the bragging rights to using the skew or turning to 400 grit. When it happens, great, but if not, move on. I don't have many pieces demount anymore, but back in the day when I tried to use dovetails, I had a higher percentage demount when using them. With more irrecoverable tenons. Maybe because I use a fair percentage of softer woods. I don't think serrated jaws crush the wood the way dovetails do. I realize what I'm saying is sacrilege and am doomed to be burned at the stake but serrated jaws are working way better for me than dovetails.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#12

subject line is a little misleading...

Jeff Smith

...you can get Oneway jaws either in dovetail or serrated/profiled configurations. I've got and used both, but prefer dovetailed jaws for both the Talon and Stronghold chucks. Even got a couple of Stronghold chucks with a set of Oneway versa slides that are matched to Vicmark jaws. I don't see much difference between the two, except the Vicmark jaws are a little beefier than the Oneway equivalents. In use, there is little or no difference.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#13

Vicmarc make "shark jaws" too ...

Geoff Whaling

I've used mostly Vicmarc & Nova & much prefer the Vicmarc dovetail jaw system. I own but do not use Vicmarc’s shark jaws as “shark jaws.”

Interesting that turners do not realize that Vicmarc also have a very good range of chuck jaws, including shark jaws (stronghold equivalent),

http://www.vicmarc.com/downloads/Vicmarc%20Cat%20A4%20web.pdf

http://www.vicmarc.com/downloads/4%20Jaw%20Chuck%20Manual%20Aug%2010.pdf

Shark jaws available as

VM90/100 - 48,55,74 & 88 mm

VM120/150 - 55,68,83 & 130 mm

Std dovetail jaws,

VM90/100 - 50,70,& 100 + step & multi jaws.

VM120/150 - 68,105,128,148,173,198, & 223 mm + step & multi jaws.

Doc Green's advice is very good, however I would like to make a couple of points -

- maximum holding power does not come from using a jaw set at maximum extension.

- maximum holding power does come from using the jaw size matched to the appropriate tenon size for the bowl when the jaw set is near its original manufacture diameter (perfect circle) with allowances for some compression of the tenon or recess.

- my personal experience is that making a crisp well made corner from the dovetail to the face is more important than perfectly matching the dovetail taper. This is the registration face for the jaws/bowl. A poorly cut face permits compression which then generates wobble or loose jaws etc.

-I prefer to cut my dovetail taper slightly mismatched (steeper), or slightly oversize on the base diameter of the tenon, this compresses the base slightly more than face and draws the tenon/blank down onto the face of the jaws.

- it is not safe to cut the tenon dovetail taper "under size" i.e. "flatter" or the tenon base diameter smaller than the matching diameter of the jaws. This generates vibration.

- on Nova dovetail jaws with the two bevel system I like to cut a slight relief on the micro dovetail to prevent generating a crack.

-Vicmarc’s shark jaws can be used as what I like to call “extension dovetail jaws.” Check out the design of the face of the jaw set. It is a dovetail jaw just offset from the chuck body and is very handy in some applications.

As an example the standard jaws supplied with a VM120 will grip a tenon from 38 to 85 mm however the 105 mm jaw set will have a much stronger hold/grip on an 85 mm tenon than the 68 mm jaw set. Proven!

This is where most turners have problems with dovetail jaws - they simply do not understand the properties of wood or the mechanics of jaw gripping power and actually use undersized jaws on large tenons.

I have suggested to Marco Verrecchia that they change the wording in the Chuck Manual from "+37 mm for max grip, - 3 mm min grip" to "+37 mm for max exten, - 3 mm min exten" to over come the confusion about maximum gripping power / strength.

PS Nova have a good explanation on page 12 about how to overcome the jaw run out issues some users have with jaw sets.

http://www.teknatool.com/products/chuck_accessories/Jaw_Sets/downloads/Accessory%20Jaws%20Manual.pdf

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#14

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Bill Howatt

All my chucks are Oneways now but I've never owned a Vicmarc and I agree this thread really is a discussion on jaw types.

There is no denying dovetail jaws are good but they are only at their best when the tenon size closely matches the almost closed size of the the jaws for maximum contact and the angle should be close.

The Oneway profile jaws grab almost any external tenon size well and I've hardly ever even have had to remount a bowl after a very bad catch. Never lost anything right out of the chuck.

There is more crush damage but that doesn't bother me because I always shape the tenon area considerably when finish turning. What does bother me is a bowl foot that screams "This was the tenon!" to me.

Bill

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Thanks......

Jesper, Denmark

Thanks for the responses, especially the clear and thoughtful suggestions and recommendations.

The strong preference for Vicmarc surprised me, but, hey, the reason for asking was to get a realistic answer.

I'll stick with my serrated Strongholds, mainly as i have 20 years of good experience with them and I really like that they are not sensitive to spigot/tenon diameter and hold square stock well - and I already own three.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#16

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Chris Hoehle

Another happy Vicmarc user checking in- I've got two, a VM100 and a VM120, with the supplied jaw sets (so 2" and 2 1/2" respectively, I think), and a 4" set that is just the right size for a recess in 12" or so platters.

Do any other VM users know if there are any of the regular dovetail jaws available in 3"? As others have commented (and this has been my experience too), maximum holding power comes with the jaws at their true circle diameter (i.e. barely open, with maybe a 1/16" or gap between the jaws), and I've been looking around for a 3" set to kind of have a range of sizes but it seems like the only thing they have in that size is the (more expensive) shark jaws and extended reach jaws.

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strongholD

#17

Re: Scroll Chuck - Vicmarc/dovetail type or strong

Geoff Whaling

I placed links to the Vicmarc catalogue etc in my post "Vicmarc makes shark jaws" above. To my knowledge they do not make 3" jaws for the 120. The nearest is 68 mm which is about 2 3/4".