Trying to turn a pepper mill everything coming off the Nova chuck is out of round. I put my dial indicator on the outside of the chuck and it shows no runout put it on my machined round rod and it shows about .025 runout. Tried loosening it turn and try another spot same thing. Is this normal or do I have a bad chuck. Thanks for any advice you can offer. Earl
sounds like something is wrong with the chuck jaws or jaw slides. remove the jaws and chuck up a round piece in the jaw slides. Maybe something like a socket or other metal piece that will fit in the opening. If it runs true then It would have to be the jaws. If it's still out then it has to be something internal. First thing I would do is look for burrs on the jaws, both the mating surface to the chuck face and the gripping surface of the jaws. Hopefully some of these suggestions will help you find the problem.
The jaws can go out over time. I first saw this mentioned in a Richard Raffans video. Some weeks later I noticed my jaws were sometimes close to true, sometimes not so close. It depended on how I closed the jaws. Drat, Richard Raffans was right.
If you can re-position the work in the jaws and measure runout, I expect the runout will vary which will be a sign the jaws are the root cause.
O.K. took the jaws off (all on the right #) put my machined round piece in and the runout is now .002. Tomorrow I will clean the jaws and the chuck as good as I can and try again. I am crossing my fingers but I have two sets of jaws and been having problems with both. Thanks everybody for all the replies. Ear
When I first received my Nova2, and prepared to clean out the shipping gunk, I "dinged" the body under each slide with the number of dings corresponding to the slide number. That will make sure I get the correct slide returned to the original slot after cleaning. I also put anti-seize compound on the gears inside, the jaw slides, and the screw threads for the jaws. Makes everything slicker than you know what, and the screws don't get "stuck".
IIRC, do not tighten the jaw screws to start with. Leave them just a little loose (1/8-1/4 turn?) and scroll in to a tight fit. You may have to bump them with a rubber mallet. When aligned tighten the jaw screws. Check the current manual to be sure. I believe the jaws are sliced apart from a turned billet so they should be round.
I do coat the screw threads with oil. For the pinion and jaw slides I coat in aerosol Teflon and do not add grease or oil to collect dust. Just hit with the air gun once in a while.
Loosen the jaw acres slightly then tighten the jaws so they all touch. Then tighten the jaw screws it should run true after that. Don't know why I didn't tell you that the other day. I guess being away from the lathe for so long made me forget some of the simple things I do each time I change jaws. The jaws don't go out of round they are steel and I doubt the move. However the holes in the jaws and the mild amount of tolerance needed to make them fit easily means that you can install them slightly off That's why it's important to tighten them so the register against each other before snugging up the screws
Here is something you can do to get a rechucked piece to run true. Mark one of the jaws and mark the piece you are turning. If it still does not run true loosen the jaws a little but. Bring up the tool rest and use a bowl gouge "upside down" round side up. Turn the lathe on at a slow speed. Hold the gouge under the piece as the lathe is turning. Up a small amount of upward pressure under the piece. This will get your piece running true....most of the time.
The problem is not the chuck as long as whatever you have in the chuck is firmly griped when you turn the wood it will have a center and the wood will be round.
First turn something to round without using the tail stock.
If this item is not round and your tool is not moving in and out on the tool rest, that means your center is changing. You could have play in the bearings.
If this item is round them the tail stock is pulling the work off center. The centers may not be aligned and or bed may not be level front to back and end to end.
Now if you are trying to remove the work from the chuck turn it 180°and mount it in the chuck and have it run true to a few thousands. That would be a job wood working tools were not designed to do.
Finally got it right. By adjusting the jaws several times before getting it right. So I guess I will have to be more careful when changing the jaws from now on. Read the manual thats a novel idea. Thanks to all who replied. Earl
Walta thanks for your suggestions. As soon as I get caught up I will try your idea of tuning something round then bring the tail stock up and see. You mentioned the bearings I have thought of them before. When I turn a pen my mandrel has a morse taper an I have to set it in the exact spot or else I will have bad runout. I first thought that might be bad bearings but I now think it may be my morse taper. My lathe is a 12" psi. Again thanks for the suggestions. Earl
Even if the chuck has considerable runout, you have a single axis, and anything turned will be round. If its not round, then its a tool control issue, or sanding issue.
If you try to remount it in another chuck or something, it may not run true because the tenon and piece are now on different.
If it was as simple as runout, there would be a lot of people turning (intentionally) oval work.
Doesn't matter if the chuck is bad, the spindle is bent, it won't make an out of round piece.
You can force the tailstock end onto a different axis if the centers don't align OR if the piece is not flat on the end and the center forces it off the true axis-in that case it will be round after turning until the center is remove and that end will wobble, but its still round-just not aligned with the true axis. Bringing the center up to a revolving piece that has been faced of will let you see if it is aligned.
John brings up a good point. Before drilling holes that need to be accurate I make a small depression using the toe of my skew. This runs true because of what John mentioned above. Since you are starting with a truly centered depression the drill will be more likely to run true.
I agree with John and John but would point out that you need to stick with the chuck all the way. If you turn the mill to completion between centers and then mount it in a chuck to bore it out or add any other detail, you will have problems.
There are a quite few methods to make a pepper mill on the lathe & as Dennis mentioned when you move from between centers to a chuck mount you highlight any "errors" in the system. I prefer to drill holes for pepper mills first on the lathe then mount between centers using plugs as much as possible.
John Jordan's comments about turning on the single axis is true if turning both inside & outside on the one mount; or the blank is remounted in the same or near to the same position relative to the chuck jaws each time. More so when reversing a bowl blank. Many turners mark the blank to show the position of say 'jaw 1" so the can return a blank to the same mounting position.
Look up "precession" and "eccentric errors". Surveyors are very familiar with errors caused by eccentricity errors which is very similar to the bowl blank axis not being on the lathe headstock-tailstock axis.
Eccentricity errors are the cause of the thin on one side & thick on the opposite side of the bowl rim issues.