Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Cherry Finish?

Posts

Cherry Finish?

#1

Cherry Finish?

Ken Cutler

I have finished turning some cherry pieces with great looking crotch figure. What would be the best way to finish it? I want to pop the grain pattern and then a good finish to protect it long term. I appreciate any response that you may have and I will try to post the finished product when I have it completed.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#2

Re: Cherry Finish?

Donna Banfield

Oil, a penetrating oil that will soak into the wood in the first coat. You will need to apply several coats after each one dries; usually every 24 hours. Boiled Linseed Oil (BLO), Bush Oil, urethane oil, or those home-made 3-part finishes that are composed using 1/3 BLO and other additives. Apply first coat liberally, letting it soak in 20-30 minutes. Re-apply, then wipe dry with several paper towels. I prefer Vista for this. After 24 hours, repeat this entire process. In between coats, scuff the surface with either 4/0 steel wool or a synthetic scuff pad of equivalent fineness, and compressed air to remove debris. Apply as many coats as you think it needs.

Wipe-on poly finishes will be faster and easier, but those are film finishes, and will sit on the surface - no penetration into the wood, which is what makes your figure pop.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#3

Re: Cherry Finish?

don stephan

Although I find it more interesting, many people object to the unevenness cherry can have when first given a coat of oil - the technical term is "blotch." Some areas of the wood are more absorptive than others, so they become darker when oil is wiped about the surface allowing every bit of the surface to absorb as much as it wants. The look is more pronounced with oil based stains. (Spraying such a stain avoids the problem because every bit of the surface is given exactly the same amount of stain.)

Even in multiple coats, linseed oil is reported to water spot easily, and that has been my experience. If you would like a more durable finish, after the one coat of linseed oil cures you can switch to something else. But if your following finish is water based, consider a tie coat of dewaxed shellac over the linseed oil.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#4

Boiled lindseed oil can be difficult......

JamieDonaldson

.. to work with when drying, and I don't know why Donna states that wiping poly finishes don't penetrate? Minwax Wiping Poly is an excellent finish for popping grain, and after soaking in several coats can build additional coats to provide a durable surface finish. It also doesn't have quite the yellow coloration on light colored woods as some other oil based finishes.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#5

Re: Cherry Finish?

David DeCristoforo

Cherry is a fine pored, relatively dense wood. The best thing about it is that it gets better looking with age. My favorite finish for cherry is... none! Any oil will cause the blotchy look previously mentioned. Surface finishes like lacquer or poly will not cause this as much as oil but I don't like the look of those finishes on cherry. What I do like is a bit of wax. I sand to 1500 or finer and then spin the lathe up to around 2000 RPM. A bit of paste wax applied with a soft cloth will bring up a beautiful sheen that can be taken to a high gloss if you wish. Wax might have to be renewed after several years but the gloss will remain and, as the wood ages, a beautiful patina will develop.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#6

Re: Cherry Finish?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

One common characteristic of all cherry wood species is they darken with age. Whether one finish better than the other long term could be discussed until the moon falls from the sky.

Penetrating drying oil finishes (pure) oil finishes do not build a film. Talking about linseed, Tung and walnut oil finishes and do not really penetrate that deep without solvent/thinner. Tung oil will provide the best protection if apply enough coats. Although BLO containers say 100% linseed oil not really sure what is actually in it!

Yes, oil finishes do provide a natural look and feel of wood, but need reapplication to preserve that look. There are many commercial oil blends which also serve the same purpose and dry faster.

Also commercial wiping resin (varnish/poly) products easy to apply and dry fast and do build a film and protect wood. You want to buy a product with no more than 60% solvent/thinner listed on the label. You can mix your own wiping varnish/poly using a 50-50 mix of resin & solvent. Two coat of wiping varnish should equal one coat of film finish. The more solvent more coats needed. Minwax contains 70% solvent!

Film building finishes do penetrate the wood some due to resins, solvents & driers used. Most oil film finishes will impart an amber hue, but will give you a better protection. Clear shellac might not depends upon product or shellac flakes !

Water base/waterborne can be totally clear or also impart an amber hue.

MPO, film finishes will enhance grain & figured wood thru depth of sheen. Think Russ Fairfield’s provides an explanation lot easier to follow at Russ’s Corner.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#7

Re: Boiled lindseed oil can be difficult......

Donna Banfield

Hi Jaimie, I was just stating my experience and my opinion. If BLO takes more than 24 hours to dry, that can has been sitting on the shelf awhile after being opened. A couple drops of Japan Drier can bring it back. Based on my experience, I have found Bush Oil, and currently the home made 3-part finish (BLO, turpentine and high quality varnish, like Behlens or Fiddes), to work best for bowls. These are primarily utilitarian, and the finish stands up to normal use in the kitchen. But it also gives highly figured wood grain the chatoyance we like.

My experience with wipe-on film finishes is that the bowl surface doesn't hold up as well to normal kitchen use. They tend to be shinier when new, but will dull quickly, and the customer is unhappy. This finish is also harder for me to repair if there is a scratch that penetrates through. And I repair any piece a customer has purchased.

Reasonable people differ. Getting more than one opinion on a subject is always a good thing, because then the choice you eventually make is one based on knowledge and hopefully experience.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#8

Re: Cherry Finish?

Sergio

I use Tried and True polymerized linseed oil. It is completely food sfae and easy to apply. In particular I use their danish oil. Usually I give a final coat of wax. I'm satisfied although I'm considering to swith to their Original Formula which is polymerized linseed oil and beeswax. 90% of my bowls are from cherry wood. Here is an example finished with Tried and True Danish oil.


Re: Cherry Finish?

#9

Donna, my response was to your .......

JamieDonaldson

... use of the term film or surface finish, as there is little significant difference among oil finishes when applied and then excess wiped off before drying. The penetration is similar when viscosity is similar, and I find Bush oil to be too thick for my liking. Minwax Wipe-on Poly is an excellent sealing finish, very durable, and only builds a surface thickness with multiple applications. Most all oil based finishes are similar when applied as a sealer in this manner.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#10

Hot BLO *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

I have been busy attending a spring hockey tournament one of my grandsons is playing in and held off replying. Years ago, I made a sofa table for our son and his wife out of cherry that I had milled from our hobby farm at the time. On the Thomas Moser website, famous for his solid cherry furniture and actually from a book on Shaker furniture he wrote in the 70's, I discovered heating boiled linseed oil and applying to cherry. It has become my favorite finish for cherry and cherry my favorite wood. The reduced viscosity allows it to penetrate better and it seems to dry a bit faster too. In an early Fine Woodworking magazine there was a short article about using heated oils. Currently working on four stools in cherry which I am planning to use this on and then when dry top it off with a couple of coats of satin Minwax WOP. I think BLO helps the color develop faster too. This is a shot of a bowl from the link below that taken in December 2009 and turned in February that year.


img

The Joy of Wood

Re: Cherry Finish?

#11

Re: Cherry Finish?

Ken Cutler

Thanks for all of the information about the cherry. I will try the heated BLO and see what it does with a scrap piece. If it looks good I will try the piece. Will post a picture when I have it completed. Again thanks for all the info.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#12

Re: Cherry Finish?

Don Evans

Be very careful heating finishes or any chemical stuff!

Do NOT use an open flame as gases coming off the finish can ignite, use only heat from an electrical hot plate as one example of safer way to do it.

Also I would not do it and breath the fumes coming up off it.

I'm speaking generally here not just about one finish type.

Don

Re: Cherry Finish?

#13

Heating BLO

Mike Brazeau

When I first started doing it, I put some in a coffee can and put in a saucepan with a couple of inches of boiling water, heating the oil to 70C. Now I just put some in the coffee can and heat the bottom with my heat gun and don't worry about temperature too much.

Re: Cherry Finish?

#14

Re: Boiled lindseed oil can be difficult......

Jorge

Donna,

Linseed oil takes a month to dry properly, I use walnut oil, it dries in minutes to the touch and in a day is totally dry. I use a french product, Saveurs de terre" toasted oil, a local health store sells it.