Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Posts

Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#1

Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Does anyone know how I might be able to fix this? The carbide tip on a gouge I own continues to turn on the main shaft. It's not a huge deal but when it gets turned I can't present the tool perpendicular to the work. I have to be real careful.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#2

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

John Lucas

We need more info. Is it homemade or factory. If it comes Hunter it will have a tapered shank screw. If it has a flat screw and especially if the surface the cutter sits on in not perfectly flat good luck. I had one homemade one that would try to spin. I took extra care with a file and flattened the surface and it stopped. I now have a milling machine which of course makes it much easier

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#3

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Sorry John, I don't recall the manufacturer. It was from a WC secret Santa exchange a few years back. I attached sketches of the issue, not sure if you saw those. I will take photos and post them.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#4

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

John Lucas

Sorry. The sketches won't open on my phone. My computer is at the Docs right now. Typical carbide cutters have a tapered hole and should have a screw with a tapered shank that exactly fits. These generally have a torx head. If you have a standard straight shank screw that could be your problem. You might be able to cut a small piece of sandpaper to place between the cutter and the base if you don't have the proper screw

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Lyle Jamieson

The drawing is not Hunter, sloppy fitting squarish cutter, not nanograin.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#6

Bill Blasic

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Bill Blasic

Wow you can tell from a drawing that it is not nano grain? I received the same kit perhaps this year from the Secret Santa Exchange and it does tilt on the holder just like the picture but once tightened it stays in place and I do believe the cutters that were sent to be some sort of nano grain as they are very shiny and sharp!

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#7

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Darryl

It does not appear that the cutter lies below the shank of the tool. It has to have a "shelf" at the back that it fits down below. A file should allow you to deepen the shelf so the edge of the tool at the back hits it.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#8

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

kkruizen

I would continue to use as is. But you could go to the hardware store and get some JB Weld. Then clean the insert seat with a wire brush and clean with alcohol or lacquer thinner and put some scotch tape on your bottom and edges of the insert and tighten in the position that you want, then tape both sides of the tool (like a dam to retain the JB Weld). Mix the JB Weld and using a putty knife and force it into the space and mound it up a little above the insert and let it CURE. After it has cured sand by hand to the same level of insert (should not take much effort). Then remove the insert and tape from side of the shank and sand JB Weld by hand to the sides of the shank sanding from the insert end into the shank so that the JB Weld is supported. Remove the tape from the insert put a light coat of paste wax on it and reassemble. This should hold up fairly well because it basically a glued in spacer and there should be little to no cutting pressure on it. Good Luck!!

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#9

Carbide tip New 'PIC'

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

This is not a Hunter carbide tool but it does have a torx screw and not a Hex screw as drawn. I drew this in Sketchup. This is a side shot.

The shelf or notch that the cutter sits on is square at the back vertical. I've tried cranking down on the screw as much as possible but the tip still turns. I'm not sure what everyone means when they are talking about a tapered shank.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#10

Re: Carbide tip New 'PIC'

Dale Miner

I think you are refering to the cutter rotating on top of the seat. Good tooling would have a pocket that prevent the cutter rotating unless the cutter is round.

With what you have drawn, I would try putting a small drop of epoxy under the cutter and tightening it down. Once the epoxy sets it will take a good bit of force to break the bond and allow the cutter to rotate. When it is time to manually rotate to a sharper edge, a little heat (with the screw removed) and a tap with a hard piece of wood should dislodge the cutter fairly easily.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#11

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

klowwn

I had one tool that kept doing the same. For me it worked to use a small drop of CA glue under the cutter and screw it down. Let the CA dry before using. When I need to rotate the cutter for a new edge I use a lighter to heat the CA glue to soften it then rotate and repeat the process. Not sure if it will solve your issue but it has worked for a couple years on a homemade tool for me

Ricc

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#12

Re: Carbide tip New 'PIC'

John Lucas

What we mean by a tapered shank is the hole in the cutter is tapered narrowing from top to bottom. The area below the head of the screw should have this same taper. These two tapers locking together are what keeps the cutter from rotating. It's possible the screw isn't seating all the way down. Building up the platform with epoxy may raise the cutter and let the screw seat deeper to lock the tapers in place

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#13

This may be the problem.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I took actual pictures and it appears that the screw hole was not drilled perpendicular to the cutter head seat or shelf on the main shaft. This prevents the taper on the screw from sitting properly into the countersink of the cutter head or bit. What do you all think and can it be fixed?

Thanks everyone.

Ray



Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Lyle Jamieson

Nanograin is not that shape. See photo below. It is not shinny. It is not round. It is not cupped shape. It is not nanograin. There are many folks being fooled by manufacturers claims. If you have used Mike Hunter tools you would see the difference.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#15

Easy Fix

John Kaner

A machinist can mill the correct clearance and then drill/tap the proper screw hole. The full width of the bottom of the cutter needs to be supported. Then the front of the tool holder needs a relief ground. Thus only the cutter edge will be used. The cutter as it is now positioned will take a big bite...

Hope this helps... Small world, I'm from Hamilton Township. Lived by where I-95 passes Independence Mall...

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#16

Re: This may be the problem.

John Lucas

Coat the screw , cutter , and screw hole with wax. Put a layer of thick body epoxy down such as JB Weld. Re assemble it but don't tighten the screw down hard. Just enough to seat the screw into the cutter and get it sitting flat. When it dries take it apart and clean the wax off with mineral spirits. The. File the excess epoxy off.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#17

Bill Blasic

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Bill Blasic

Lyle just because you wrote an article on carbide does not mean you know everything there is to know about carbide. Just like I wrote an article about CA glue does not mean I know everything about CA glue. In your article you say that nano grain sometimes referred to micro grain, well 1 micro grain of carbide is equal to 1,000 nano grains of carbide. You also state that nano carbide has a mirror or glossy finish - isn't that shiny? Nano grain carbide starts as a powder before it becomes a cutter of any kind and heat pressure molded it could be any shape. And believe it or not nano carbide can be used to make stuff that isn't a cutting tool.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#19

+1 on John's idea, but....

Dick Coers

I prefer using vasoline instead of wax. Especially where threads are concerned. Also by using epoxy, you can close up the fit on the back of the insert which will hold it in place better. I learned that technique from a friend that uses epoxy to make flat surfaces all the time. His favorite trick is a light coat of epoxy, vasoline coat a piece of 1/4" glass, then float the glass over the epoxy.

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#20

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

Brian Roberts

I may be missing something.....??

If it is the correct insert for the tool then either the tool or insert....or both....are defective.

If they are commercially made why do the manufacturers job?

Return for replacement!

Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#21

Methinks this is semi-home made tool.


Re: Carbide tip issue 'PIC'

#22

Thanks for all the input everyone. 

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I'll let you know the outcome.