Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Portable Lathe

Posts

Portable Lathe

#1

Portable Lathe

MNRon

I have a PM3520b that I love. The only problem I've found with it is it's pretty hard to load up in the RV and travel with.

I was about ready to pull the trigger on a Jet1221vs with their 15% discount to use as a travel lathe, but the weight is giving me pause. Lifting 120lb in and out doesn't sound like a good recipe for longevity of my back (which has no problems now, but none of us are getting younger).

Now I'm debating between the Nova Comet2 ($500 with novachuck included), a Jet1015vs ($600, I have a Oneway Talon I could use with it); both are ~75lb ... and still haven't completely given up on the Jet1221vs.

What are people's thoughts and recommendations?

The Comet2 has 12" swing; I don't like that the lower range is only 250-700, while slower would be nicer I can live with 250 for small bowls etc but don't like that I'd need to change belt pulleys to move from 300rpm to 1000rpm range where I expect I'd like to on the same piece; additionally it doesn't appear as 'substantial' as the Jet's. It is pretty cheap though...not that price is really a deciding factor among these.

The Jet1015vs is only 10" swing. It also doesn't reverse, which is nice when switching grains in sanding but not a show stopper. It also has a slightly smaller motor vs the Comet2. Did I mention it's only 10" swing?

The Jet1221vs pretty much fits the bill, other than the weight...

I know that I won't be turning the same size bowls, platters, etc as I can at home. Still it would be fun to set up a lathe and play. I'm not much on pens and stoppers, but there are a lot of smaller bowls/boxes/plates etc that I could have a good time playing with. Would I be sorry getting the Comet2 instead of sacrificing a little diameter to get better quality with the Jet? Should I just 'suck it up' and get the Jet1221?

Thanks for your advice,

Ron

Re: Portable Lathe

#2

Bill Blasic

Re: Portable Lathe

Bill Blasic

Ron,

If it were me I would go with the Nova. Simply because I could add the grinding wheel to it meaning I don't have to take a grinder to sharpen my tools. That plus the weight difference of the bigger Jet would make it a better choice for traveling. If I were buying for my shop I'd go with the Jet 1221vs or the ones I chose which are the Delta 46-460s. I know you have folks out there saying Delta parts are hard to get but between mine, the clubs and other members in the club there are over a dozen 46-460s and not one problem with them since they came out. I didn't mention them for traveling because they weigh in at 97 lbs. That said I'm sure that you could probably devise some method for mounting a fold up system on wheels that might make it viable to use one of the heavier midi lathes.

Re: Portable Lathe

#3

Re: Portable Lathe

John Lucas

I turned for many years on the earlier Nova comet. An excellent lathe. I have also owned the jet mini as well I never really minded having to switch pulleys. It's fairly quick. The nice thing about the single speed is you don't lose any power. Having worked on the powermatic you've been spoiled by lots of power. That's part of why I went with the Delta midi but it weights 100 lbs I have t turned on the new Nova mini but I've owned 2 nova lathes and they were both excellent.

For me it would boil down to the little things between the two because they are both good. How easy is it to change the belt. Does the Nova have a standard tool

Post size (I remember my Nova comet had 5/8 post where the jet had 1/2" which is more standard ) the extra swing of the Nova would be nice

Re: Portable Lathe

#4

Bill Blasic

Re: Portable Lathe

Bill Blasic

John,

Every mini or midi lathe I've owned (Delta, Jet and Rikon) have had 5/8" tool posts.

Re: Portable Lathe

#5

Re: Portable Lathe

John Lucas

MyNova comet which was one of the first minis beside the Carbo-Tec had a 5/8 post. I think that was better I recommended that to Delta when they came to our club to ask for suggestions. Don't know of the new Nova Comet has 1/2 " or not. 1/2 is standard among the minis as you noted and so are the aftermarket tool rests. That's why I mentioned.

I did own a Rikon for a while and really liked it. It had the easiest belt changes of them all

Apparently the Steel City granite bed mini died It was an interesting concept but its weight sort of defeated the concept of the mini which is portability

I love my Delta midi. Good power and variable speed. Not horribly heavy although you better be careful how you pick it up. I had Vic from Bestwoodtools make me a special adaptor to fit the spindle so mine is now 1/4x8.

Re: Portable Lathe

#6

Re: Portable Lathe

MNRon

John and Bill, not sure if you're helping me here :) You've added in the Delta to my short list now, I'd originally excluded it from the web complaints I'd read.

OK - Jet's are out. 1221 too heavy, 1015 not enough swing.

Comet is attractive based on features and weight, but doesn't appear to be Robust (pun intended - I would get one of their rests for it).

Delta has a beefier motor, and more solid construction. The price of this is 25lb more, and it still requires a belt change to move from 300-1000rpm.

As you've mentioned, I'm spoiled by my Powermatic. Would I kick myself for getting the Comet because it stalled all the time vs the Delta? What are your experiences moving the Delta around, specifically up and down like out of an RV?

I'm leaning towards the Comet, but if the Delta didn't require a belt change from 300-1000rpm or weight wasn't an issue I'd go that way instead. Sounds like there are good user experiences on the Delta, anyone have experience with the Comet?

Re: Portable Lathe

#7

Re: Portable Lathe

John Lucas

Belt changes are very quick on the Delta. It has a quick release lever to release and tension the belt. That's just a non issue for me. The weight of the lathe could be a problem. I added a handle to make it easier to hold onto I modified the stand using quick release knobs so I can take the stand apart very quickly for hauling.

Re: Portable Lathe

#8

Re: Portable Lathe

MNRon

John, do you regularly travel with your Delta? Do you find the weight to be a significant issue that you don't look forward to taking it somewhere, or is it something you really don't think about?

Re: Portable Lathe

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Portable Lathe

Keith Tompkins

I have a Rikon midi that I sometimes travel with. 12" swing, easy belt changes. I prefer belt changes, some lathes loose too much power with variable speed at low rpm. Rikon is 75 lbs. Could you rig up some sort of hoist?

Re: Portable Lathe

#10

Re: Portable Lathe

George Guadiane

I was going to get a 46-460 for travel and demonstrations, but I've decided to go with the 719200 JET JWL-1221VS: 12 Inch X 20 Inch Variable Speed Wood Lathe.

They are both EXCELLENT and have virtually the same features, but the one advantage (in my opinion) is the lower low end speed - 60RPM. That makes it more plausible to put finish on the rotating piece.

In my opinion, dealing with the weight so that you have the best tool is worth the effort/additional expense. Don't do anything to hurt yourself, get some kind of dolly/hoist setup, which is what I'll probably do.

Re: Portable Lathe

#11

Re: Portable Lathe-Vicmarc

George Hurlburt

I have an Vicmarc 100 lathe. 1 x 8 thread. 10" swing, 5/8 or 3/4" post not sure. It's mounted on board. Separate motor and switch. Belt change in seconds. To carry I take off tail stock. clamp down the motor which is on a board. Because of my setup I might have 10 speeds if I want to use it. All fits on a card table or banquet table. As with much of machines I purchased about 10 years ago at the right prices.

Re: Portable Lathe

#12

Re: Portable Lathe

John Lucas

Well I do t move it a lot but when I do I don't half hazardly pick it up. I think about ways to not use my back more than I have to. I only weigh 162 myself. If I had to pick it up from ground level it would get my attention. Moving it from the stand to the trunk and back out is t too bad

Re: Portable Lathe

#13

Re: Portable Lathe

MNRon

Thanks all for your replies.

I took a quick look at Rikon, looks to be in the Jet 1221 weight class. That's still the lathe I would get if I weren't concerned about lifting it in and out of the 5er basement all of the time.

John, I'm 200lb and did pick up a packaged Jet from the floor at the store Saturday (~140lb I think); as you say, it did get my attention which caused me to kick this thread off.

I think I've made my decision. Tossing around 75lbs seems attractive vs 100lb or 120lb. I plan on ordering the Comet and will use the 30day 'return for any reason' policy to run it through some paces here to make sure I'll be happy with it. If it seems too restrictive I'll jump up in weight class and start thinking about easier ways to move it.

Given I haven't been able to get much feedback from those that actually have turned on the Comet2 (youtube videos are sparse too) I'll try and post some feedback on my findings after I've turned a few things with it.

Thanks again,

Ron

Re: Portable Lathe

#14

Re: Portable Lathe

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Here is review of 1221VS lathe that we just purchased:

This is a review of the JML-1221VS Jet midi lathe. This is a nice lathe but there are a few design problems. The lathe had to be disassembled to get it into the shop. That was expected due to its weight. Half of the hardware was SAE instead of metric. You do not expect a lathe made in China to be anything but metric. This was confusing.

The lathe is held down with 5/16"-18 SAE bolts. Holes are tapped into the bottom of the lathe. Most lathes are held down with ears and thru bolts. If the lathe is attached to the Jet metal stand everything is fine. However, if it is mounted on a wooden stand, the holes in the bench must be perfect. Lining all this up with holes you can't see and about 130 pounds of lathe on top is EXTREMELY difficult! Jet should have included a full-sized, printed footprint template instead of a 8" x 4" picture of the layout dimensions. Keeping holes that are 29" apart square and perfectly spaced is not fun. Using oversized holes and fender washers did not help very much.

Once the lathe is mounted ( a two hour chore for two people), it is very sweet. The only cosmoline was on the machined surfaces of the ways. It did not smell like fish oil. The drive and tailstock points line up perfectly. The speed ranges are about 5% wider than advertised. The forward/reverse switch can be done HOT while the lathe running. The spring loaded belt tightener works good after you figure out how it works. There is little explanation in the manual, only a drawing with a couple of arrows. The 6 groove poly V belt should not slip. The banjo and tailstock hold-downs work well with little force.

I tested the motor by trying to stall the lathe in the middle belt range. The ~2" diameter faceplate was on. At 0% pot position, I could stall the lathe with leather gloved fingers around the faceplate. At 5% pot position I could not stall the lathe. I did not want to tear my arm off. I have done this same assembly with four other lathes, I am glad that I don't have to do it again. This is Mama's lathe, she is HAPPY!

Re: Portable Lathe

#15

Re: Portable Lathe-Vicmarc

Geoff Whaling

Unfortunately the Vicmarc VL100 is no longer in production. If you can find a second hand EVS VL100 buy it, you won't be disappointed. I have both the older VL100 belt change & the new VL150 which is a superb machine. The VL150 EVS purrs like a kitten with the muscle of a tiger. I also have the older Nova Mercury the predecessor to the Comet. It has been a good machine until the VS died and Nova were hopeless with customer service here in Australia.

Re: Portable Lathe

#16

Nova Comet2 Lathe Review - long

MNRon

As discussed in the above thread, I made the decision to purchase a Nova Comet2 lathe primarily to use as a travel lathe in our RV. Primary considerations were 12” capacity, weight, and variable speed down to 250rpm. This lathe is only 75lbs, and has a small footprint to store (6” front-back, 32” width, and 14.5” tall). The lathe arrived a few days ago and I’ve turned several objects, and made a knock-down travel stand for it. Below are my comments on the lathe for others benefit.

For perspective, this is my third lathe. I initially purchased a Jet1236 in the mid-90’s and turned on it off and on for 10years. At that point I sold it and upgraded to a Powermatic 3520b which I’ve used more over the last 10yrs, but again more sporatically until this last year when I retired and have since generated more shavings. I’m an intermediate woodturner and have turned several hundreds of objects, mostly ~bowls but some between center work as well.

The summary if you don’t want to bother reading the rest - The Comet2 is a good lathe that meets my expectations. It won’t replace my Powermatic when I’m in the shop, but will allow me to turn while traveling and just move outside at home sometimes when the weather is nice.

Set-up was trivial, it does require the motor to be run at high speed for 1hr to set the brushes which provided time to make a few fixes: File tailstock block and ways to make it easier to slide tailstock on; remove belt cover screw (tedious) and epoxy magnet onto cover to hold closed instead; and ultimately reposition spindle pulley so that belt ran quieter. The handwheel doesn’t have a locking set-screw which concerned me as I often slow the turning by grabbing this but it hasn’t proved to be an issue yet.

I also immediately replaced the live center with an extra real live center/cone that I had, and purchased a 9” Robust tool rest to replace the 6” rest it comes with. The bolt holding the tool rest post height had to be filed as it wasn’t tapped square and had a burr that gouged the post and wouldn’t initially hold. After filing the end of the bolt it holds well and even though the banjo feels like a toy, it does a very good job holding the rest solid.

So far I’ve used it to turn a couple bowls (7.5”x3.5” oak, 7”x2” oak), a couple of plates (9” maple, 11” oak), and a peppermill (8” walnut) along with a few shop accessories. The lathe has performed well. After quickly learning I couldn’t take the cuts I do on the Powermatic, I’ve found it to have plenty of power on all speed ranges. In fact, after the stalls on the initial bowl while learning to take lighter cuts it hasn’t stalled on any other projects (including the 11” plate) and I find I remove wood plenty quickly with sharp gouges. The quill only advances an inch or so with a Jacobs chuck in it so drilling a peppermill takes a few repositionings, additionally when under load the quill does not advance and retract very smoothly. I think I’ll have to watch the pressure I put on the quill.

I also made a knock-down stand for traveling with the lathe in our RV. The legs are angled 11.5deg out in the front and back, and 5deg out side to side. The stand is solid front to back, so the lathe balances bowl blanks pretty well. Again this is a relative comment, I can’t spin uneven blanks up like on the Powermatic, but as long as I start large objects relatively round it works well enough to true them and then I can run speeds up as much as I want. The 5deg leg angle along the axis of the lathe is insufficient and should have probably been ~10deg along with more than the 3” purchase where they intersect the table. The table wobbled along the axis some until I added a gusset across the back which eliminated this issue.

Bottom line – the Comet2 is a solid midi lathe that performs very well after minor tune-up. It’s the smallest and lightest of the 12” ones I looked at, and a very good deal at $400 including a G3 scroll chuck. I’m glad I purchased it. If I wasn’t moving it around I think I’d still go with the Jet 1221 for additional heft, ability to run speed down to 60rpm, and the ability to run 300rpm-1000rpm without changing the belt positioning…but then again the Jet is twice the cost of the Comet2… I’d definitely recommend the Comet2 to anyone looking at it seriously. It appears well built enough that I expect to say the same thing in a few years, I hope so.

I have a couple of pictures I'd like to attach but can't figure out how, if someone could enlighten me...

Re: Portable Lathe

#17

Re: Nova Comet2 Lathe Review - long

David Walser

Thank you for the detailed review. It sounds like the Nova Comet2 is a good value.

Re: Portable Lathe

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Nova Comet2 Lathe Review - long

Brad Vietje

Hey MNRon,

Thanks for the review. When posting, just above the empty box where you type your post, is a little blue circle and the text: "Upload embedded file: then a little grey box: Browse...

If you reduce photos so they are under the 100 kB limit, and have them somewhere on your computer, you can insert them right into the text by using this "Browse" button to find them. they will be inserted into the text wherever the cursor is, like this:


You won't see the photo itself unless you preview the message before sending. Instead, you'll see jibberish, like this:


As you can see here, you can do this multiple times in a single post. To reduce the size of the photos to get them down to 100 kB max, you can use many programs, such as Photoshop, Pixresizer, etc... Some are free downloads.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Portable Lathe

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Portable Lathe

Keith Tompkins

Bill, One way to simplify using a wooden mounting surface....install the bolts in the threaded surfaces...even better, set screws. Place the lathe on the wood surface, trace around the bolts/set screws. Move the lathe, drill holes. If set screws are used, drop the lathe in place with the set screws still installed. ..the lathe will just fall into place. Remove one at a time, replacing with a proper bolt.

Re: Portable Lathe

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Portable Lathe

Keith Tompkins

I should say long set screws or studs.

Re: Portable Lathe

#21

Re: Portable Lathe

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Keith, your method is exactly what I planned to do. The bench was layered 2" x 12" with two layers of 3/4" plywood. I could not find 3 1/2" studs or set screws. All the hardware stores were out of 5/16" all thread. Thanks for your input.

Re: Portable Lathe

#22

Re: Nova Comet2 Lathe Review - long

MNRon

Thanks Brad, but when I reply here I don't have anything between the Subject box and the Text box below it. Nor do I have the emoticons on the left side you show. Not sure if my settings are different or why?