Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Actually defending carbide tools...

Posts

Actually defending carbide tools...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Actually defending carbide tools...

steven antonucci

I read the carbide thread with the usual amusement we get when discussing it, but I actually found a use case that I think I prefer carbide over tradition WITH A REASON THAT IS SCIENTIFICALLY SUPPORTED! :)

Carbide is hard. Wood is not (comparatively). What if you weren't turning wood, but something substantially harder?

I've been casting pewter accents in some recent work. Pewter is substantially harder than wood, but it still cuts easily with traditional tools...so that isn't it.

If you've ever put brass or copper ferrules on a tool handle, both are substantially harder than pewter...but you can cut them with traditional tools. You will need to sharpen when you are finished, but they both will work.

So...what is it that carbide is the right answer?

Stone. In my case, it is alabaster, which is pretty soft as stone goes, and could be cut with traditional tools if you wanted to sharpen every 2 minutes...but carbide just works better here. My hollow form (Still in progress) was 99% turned with a Hunter cutter (inside and out), except for the undercutting...because the swan neck tool is on loan to a friend. Perceptually, the cutter feels no different than when I started...

I'll post a picture when it is done later today.

Steve

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#2

Steven Antonucci

Results are in...

steven antonucci





Caliper measure estimates 1/8"-3/16"... none of the chatter you would expect with wood. Turned with NIOSH mask on to mitigate stone risks. one more block...but not today.

Steve

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#3

Re: Results are in...

Clifton C

Nicely done Steven, however, I was told the best way to turn alabaster was on someone else's lathe... :D

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I've been using carbide for about 8 years. I know it's mostly pens, but I can't see why I'd stop using carbide, it's another tool in my set. There's more than one way to do things so my process works best for me.

Take care, Jim

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#5

'THAT' is COOL !!

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Again, I am amazed at the things you guys and girls make. Nice job Steve.

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#6

Re: Results are in...

John Lucas

Great job Steve. Looking forward to seeing the finished piece. About 20 years or more I was at a demo with Rude Osolnik and someone asked him what kind of lathe to use to turn alabaster. He said, someone else's.

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

#7

Re: Actually defending carbide tools...

tomB

Beautiful piece, you go thinner than I dare to at tis point.

I too use carbide on alabaster, found it worked well. I also use a couple of scrapers and my JJ hollowing tools with the 3/16 bit. But the round carbide blades provide the best final cut.