Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

a photo finish...

Posts

a photo finish...

#1

a photo finish...

darrin hill

no.. not the kentucky derby..

in an attempt to reduce glare.... i've been taking highly lacquered hollow forms and sanding them down to reduce shine.. When you photograph them with full lacquer, the white of the background reflects on the bottom and any weird issues with your lighting is glaringly obvious..

This is about 8-10 coats of wipe on poly...



this is after buffing with 0000 steel wool



this is after sanding with 2000 grit sand paper, since to me steel wool and sand paper are not the same thing... but 0000 steel wool is supposed to be the same as 400 grit sandpaper.. but not the same thing... and no... I'm not worried about the exposure or anything except the glare...


the only problem is in photoshop i can see scratches... so if you were submitting to a gallery/museum, is there a better way to approach this?

I had that thread going with my hollow form before valentines day, but i had dropped ALL my cameras off at a repair shop so that i could get everythign cleaned for wedding season... I felt so naked without a camera... just got them back so i can start playing again..

this is my new photo of that same vase.... i reduced the flash on the right from 1/2 power to 1/16th.. I am wondering if this will wind up being a ratio thing on a permanent basis or is each item going to be different...


now remember... we're using soft boxes.. i am wanting soft light... pinpoint light won't work on a rounded form...

here is one from the earlier thread.... any difference?


Re: a photo finish...

#2

Re: a photo finish...

John Lucas

Nice although I don't know who told you 4/0 was equal to 400 grit. In my experience it's much finer than 600 grit. I usually polish my brass turnings up to 600 grit and then start with 4/0 steel wool before going to polish or buffing compounds.

Re: a photo finish...

#3

Re: a photo finish...

Sergio

Somebody can explain to me wich is the rationale for using a super shiny finish and then dull it! I personally think that wood is wood and should never covered in plastic. Shellac is antire different and much better option for fine decorative craft.

Here is a link that compares the various grits and steel wool.

Of course steel wool cuts with burs and sand paper scratches which is different thing. After 220/340 sandpaper burnishs rather than cutting which is another thing.

Re: a photo finish...

#4

Re: a photo finish...

Darrin hill

I make em shiny cause shiny has a tendency to sell better... Not always, but ...

But I had to strip it cause it won't photograph well... I will reapply after photos..

But John.. What about w flat lacquer finish for photography then adding a gloss?

Re: a photo finish...

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

No no no to a flat lacquer finish if your end result is to be glossy. It's like putting a diffuser over a photograph, and then later adding a piece of glass. The diffuser is still present.

Re: a photo finish...

#6

Re: a photo finish...

John Lucas

Flat lacquer has things in the finish that reflects light at different angle so it appears flat. I wouldn't think you would want that under a clear gloss finish.

As you can see in Darrin's photo the hotspots appear much softer and you can see the grain and figure better in the more flat finish. What i used to tell people to do is don't finish it all the way to super gloss and then dull it down. Just stop the finish process somewhere below the super gloss.

There is a downside in that your piece doesn't look super glossy. That's why I developed a system of using Polarized light and smaller light sources so you can light the piece and have just one small highlight. This way it appears glossy but doesn't have all those bad reflections. Not an easy technique to do.

Re: a photo finish...

#7

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

polarized filter on your strobe or in front of the lens? those things are not cheap...

Re: a photo finish...

#8

Re: a photo finish...

Phillip Medghalchi

Darrin, somewhere I read that you are not really supposed to use steel wool, because it scratches the wood and if you send the picture and someone has those fancy photographic program they can blow up your picture and really see the scratches. the other thing is why would you want to put a shine then sand it back for the photo and then reapply? That's too much work. I guess that will also effect your end result too.

I think between John and Jaime Donaldson they have given enough tips that if we compiled them we should be able to achieve the results that we are looking for.

The lighter color wood looks a little different in the second pic., but it doesn't look sharp and crisp. My 2c (doesn't mean always right)

Re: a photo finish...

#9

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

Patient: "Doctor, it hurts when I do this"

Doctor: "Don't do this"

You don't like the reflections of a white background on the bottom of glossy items.

Perhaps you should not place glossy items on white surfaces.

There are other ways... Give it some thought.

Re: a photo finish...

#10

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

phil... its not something I'm going to do every time... Its just that of the 10-15 pieces i have here are mostly high gloss.. and I'm experimenting with glare...

the only way to photograph pieces I've already done is to remove the lacquer... i wasn't planning on it... but i dont like the shine...

so the only way i can photograph my ALREADY finished pieces, the way i want without glare, is to ether remove the lacquer, or buy 200$ polarizer filters .... and each flash i have needs a filter...so thats $400-$2500 worth of filters..

trust me... this is something i won't do again.. i just want to photograph what i have...

Re: a photo finish...

#11

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

i like gloss.. i like white backgrounds..

i can do without the gloss until AFTER i photograph it though..

Re: a photo finish...

#12

Re: a photo finish...

Phillip Medghalchi

Darrin, try calling Jaime, or John on he phone and ask them to help you. I am sure they give yo some tips that wont cost you that much. Heck I talked with Jaime and it appears that he spent most of his life playing and working with cameras and photography. From what I understood he has on the job experience and John retired as a photographer. We all are very blessed and lucky that we have two professionals giving us all these advise w/o charging us. Heck some one said that he pays to a professional photographer to take pictures of his work every time he makes something.

I have a feeling they can help you.

Re: a photo finish...

#13

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

snicker... only reason john has more experience is cause he;s older than me..

remember,... I'm a Master Photographer.... but mostly do people... just seriously getting into trying to submit to a couple of galleries so i want pristine perfection...

d

Re: a photo finish...

#14

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

sides.. thats why I'm posting here.. to get them to tell me what I'm doing wrong..

i cant learn via telephone conversation, or looking at the internet... i only learn by doing..

Re: a photo finish...

#15

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

"the only way to photograph pieces I've already done is to remove the lacquer..."

That is where you are missing the key point.

This is not the only way to do it. I could list a few ways (I was a commercial photographer in a previous career), but would rather let this group explore.

Yes, it takes more effort than just placing an item on a paper background.

I tend to think of photography as the final finishing step for a Woodturning project. It can be worth exploring the various tools and techniques available.

Re: a photo finish...

#16

Re: a photo finish...

John Lucas

You can buy polarized sheeting to fit in front of the lights. Yes it is expensive and of course you need a polarizer on the camera. But it works. Also when a light is placed in such a way that the angle is over 90 degrees from the camera position that light is now polarized and the polarizer on the camera will eliminate that glare. I often used a backlight or rim light to shape objects and using the polarizer allowed me to change the intensity or even get rid of the glare from that light.

Re: a photo finish...

#17

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

Darrin,

I like gloss. I like white backgrounds too.

That doesn't mean that the best/only way to make a photo is to physically place the subject directly on top of the white background.

"Doctor it hurts when I do this"

"Do something else!"

Re: a photo finish...

#18

Re: a photo finish...

darrin hill

yah.. and I'm a professional portrait photographer who can do commercial, but not the nit picky stuff I'm trying to do... never used polarizers period.. either on lights or lens..

town I'm in had their choice of commercial photographers... me or no body.. that was their choice... so i never had to get picky...

I'm trying to get u guys to tell me if I'm on the right track or completely wrong..

but I'm also trying to take finished objects and trying to redo them to fit what I'm doing.. hence removing the lacquer.... I'm also trying for consistency... i want to try to have all the background look the same, at least try to, rather than have a website where one page, every background is different..

hence the white... so i need more ideas...

d

Re: a photo finish...

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

Darrin, I would be happy to discuss the options on the phone if you like. Send me an email if you would like to chat.

Re: a photo finish...

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

Removing the finish on an object would never be a option for me as a commercial photographer. Imagine me telling the maker of a chrome bowl that I can't photograph it unless we dip it in an acid bath to remove the chrome

Re: a photo finish...

#21

Re: a photo finish...

Stuart Johnson

Years ago I remember reading something about spraying chrome and sparkling glass with something that cut the glare. I almost think it was a soap solution... of course I might be mixed between photos and cleaning an engine block.

Re: a photo finish...

#22

Alan Zenreich

Re: a photo finish...

Alan Zenreich

Stuart, it's called 'dulling spray'. Horrible stuff.

Re: a photo finish...

#23

Re: a photo finish...

John Lucas

Well as a University photographer I did it all. Certainly wasn't an expert at anything but maybe shooting craft work. We often had to shoot product work for the local add agency because there weren't any other photographers around.

We also had what they called a business incubator. Students went around talking to business's and worked with them to develop online presence and other digital advertising. So we traveled around a lot shooting photos in factories and headshots of all the executives and products they made.

We of course shot all the sports which was quite difficult because it's different than other sports photographers who just need those really glamorous shots of the big guys. We had to get a good action shot of each player. That could be really difficult for linebackers and guys who don't do much after that first good block.

Weddings. Yea I hate doing them and I'll give Darrin and other wedding photographers a million pats on the back for doing those things. Every once in a while when your in a small community you simply can't say no and have to do one. So you get online and look at photos by the real wedding photographer and try to emulate them as best you can.

Because the Appalachian center for Crafts was part of our campus I shot a tremendous amount of artwork. Everything from glass, jewelry, ceramics, wood, you name it. I remember one time we were shooting pieces for the state meeting of tennessee artists. One lady wanted to stay with the ring we were shooting. It had an antique diamond (whatever that is). Anyway she told us it was worth $25,000.

I had to develop some really interesting techniques because our studio was too small and we often had to rush jobs because we would be stacked up with work.

One time a woodworker in Knoxville asked if I could shoot the pieces in a show they were having. It needed to be dine in one day. He said there would be 25. This is everything from furniture to turnings. He called back later to say there would possibly be 36 including a full size canoe. I said all we do is try. when the big day came I shot 56 pieces of art. Tables, chests, chairs, jewerlry boxes, turnings, the canoe. The club carried the pieces in and I had one club member at each light. I would direct them where to move it and how to aim it and then I would shoot. They put out a really nice book with the images.

Like Alan said. Quite often you can't dull a piece with steel wool. Dulling spray didn't work worth a damn and I would never spray a piece without asking the client because I didn't know if the spray would damage the work. consequently I developed techniques to reduce the shiny glare that didn't require altering the piece. One method I used a lot was to attach wire screen to a small rod. About 3 layers would dull a reflection about 1/2 a stop or more. I cut it to size and positioned it just so. I could add more if necessary. The polarizers were another choice. You can buy polarizing sheets a lot less expensively at some of the hobby science places online.

Re: a photo finish...

#24

Re: a photo finish...

Phillip Medghalchi

Darrin, now you're going to be charged by the hour. $75 :D :b

Correction, by each post.

Re: a photo finish...

#25

Re: a photo finish...

Darrin hill

That's ok... I charge $200-250 per hour for photography.. Lol