Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Bad vibes on the JET 1642

Posts

Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#1

Bad vibes on the JET 1642

mreagan

I've had my Jet 1642 lathe for a few years and have loved it till yesterday. I started turning larger bowls 14"-ish and yesterday noticed vibrations at anything over 330 rpm as I roughed the outside. assumed it was the piece of wood and I continued on.

After first rough out on the outside still had vibration >300 rpm. Thought it might be technique so I re-turned really slowly. Got to about 400 rpm range without vibration. But every time I cut I noticed that the depth of the cut varied on the same portion of the bowl. Cleaned the lathe and bottom of the headstock, checked the faceplate and everything was secure. Tried turning without the spindle washer. Still had slight vibrations in the 400 rpm range and large vibrations the greater the speed. Ran the lathe without the bowl and noticed vibrations especially at the 600 range with no load. Removed the plate for belt turning and watched and I swear I see a slight vibration in the shaft, not sure if it’s bent shaft or a bearing is bad.

Before I call Jet customer serivce and potentially make my self look dumb, any other suggestions?

matt

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#2

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

Dick Coers

Any noise? If a bearing goes bad it will have a rumble to it. Bend a shaft? Highly unlikely. Ever try to bend that diameter of steel shaft in a vise? It takes a LOT of effort. A visual check is no way to verify a problem. A dial indicator will be the thing to use. In my opinion, any time you get to the limits of the lathe capacity, you can witness the limitations of the machine. That's a good machine, but not a large bowl machine. Slacken the belt and check all the set screws.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#3

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

ben d.

Had about the same thing on my 1442 when it was new. My lathe came with what was referenced as electric motor bearings on the spindle shaft which was easy to spin but few balls in the bearing. After beating things out with Jet and no different bearing available I went to a bearing supply house and bought precision bearings, installed them and the problem went away.

So I figure with what you have said you have bad bearings on your spindle shaft.

That type bearing is quite more expensive it is the best replacement.

As was said above not a big bowl turning lathe but sufficient.

ben d.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#4

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

John Lucas

did you check to see if the motor was locked down. Check to see that the lathe is level and all 4 feet have the same weight. I do that by loosening and adjusting the leveling feet trying to feel about the same pressure on each one. that is after i get it level.

I haven't had one of those lathes apart so I don't know if theres any adjusting nut to tighten the bearings.

Could the belt have a bad spot in it. Sometimes if they sit a while they get a sort of lump that will cause vibration until it warms up enough to flatten out. Or there could be a torn spot.

These are all just guesses.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#5

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

Craig Daymon

If it does prove to be bad bearings, they are not too difficult to change out and you can put in much better bearings than those provided by JET. I did this for my JET Mini. (I was pretty agressively learning to turn multi-axis and really beat them up.) I have a 1642 as well. Lots of reasons for vibration as it is not a terribly stout lathe, especially compared to the 3520 I had a few years back. Putting in a shelf between the legs and weighing it down will help, but since you are finding issues without anything on the lathe it may well be the bearings...possibly pushed beyond their limit by this last 14" bowl.

Roughing out, with or without good bearings, can make the lathe dance. That can be reduced by adding mass to the lathe, like using the shelf an additional weight. As big as my 3520 was, I had a good size box installed between the legs that I put sand bags in to add to its mass. (I miss that lathe.)

Oh, and make sure it is level and the bed is straight. It should be straight if levelled correctly.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#6

Bearings?

Geoff Whaling

One would hope it is not the bearings or a bent shaft as it doesn't say much for the manufacture quality of the machine if it is. Having a photo of the setup & a little history of yourself & the machine - like experience & typical projects plus use - heavy / light, hobby , semi-pro turning ?? would help a little. Even the species of timber - green / wet / dry? re-turning or re-mounted?

As others have said I would be checking worn / damaged belt, motor lock down, slipping / wobbling pulley/s, and the face plate mounting, face plate accuracy (wobble) and the setup - leveling of the machine first & to rule out that possibility. Something we should routinely do occasionally anyway..

When you say it vibrates without the work piece makes one think drive train - motor, belt, pulley possibly shaft. Sort of rules out the face plate & work piece balance but not necessarily so.

I assume you are twice turning previously roughed out blanks? When you say "After first rough out on the outside still had vibration ...... But every time I cut I noticed that the depth of the cut varied on the same portion of the bowl."

A visually noticeable & varying depth of cut at slow speeds usually indicates bowl movement & imbalance. Either the wood itself is moving or the blank is moving on the mount - the face plate.

Maybe I'm stating the obvious - the wood will move through drying and releasing stresses in the timber as you turn green or dry or re-turn a previously roughed out blank.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#7

Re: Bearings?

John Jordan

Its not bearings etc. His second sentence said he has started to turn bigger pieces.

The piece needs to be shifted until the center of balance has been found.

Also, all legs need to be contacting the floor the same, just as John said. The best way is to turn the lathe on while the piece is on it, and while it is shaking, use your finger and touch the contact where the leg meets the floor on each leg. Your finger is touching BOTH the floor and the leg. You will feel the the seperation as the leg lifts off the floor slightly. If the lathe has leveling pads you can turn it while the lathe is moving, and it will magically stop shaking when the screw has taken up the slack. Shaking the lathe with your hands is not the same and WON'T work, but its a good place to start. Weight on the lathe is not nearly as important as this step, you just have a heavier lathe shaking.

Your lathe is capable of dealing with a moderate amount of shaking due to out of balance if you get the legs setup. But one needs to be reasonable in their expectations

Work between centers so the piece can be shifted to balance the piece before mounting on a chuck or faceplate.

Again, vibration and shaking due to out of balance pieces, and vibration are not the same.

I don't see any point in criticizing the lathe manufacturer when one doesn't know whats happening.

Be careful out there. :)

John

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#8

clarifications and question for John

mreagan

Wow thanks for the all the responses! A lot to clarify,

John, I did level the lathe. The lathe has since danced across the floor as I was roughing out a couple of large blanks. I haven’t checked to see if she is still on the level…. I was intending to bolt her down to the concrete, but haven't gotten around to it. Would you recommend this? I’ll try turning between centers on my next go around, but that will be awhile as this is my last piece to rough out and I have a lot of finish turning to do.

I'll check the set screws and belt tomorrow. I have a friend with a dial caliper, but i won't have the time until next month to check it out.

I'm a hobbyist who on a good week gets 8 hrs turning in. Often times my "Uncle" sends me overseas and I get no turning for a week or two. I've had this lathe since '12 and only turned for about a year before that. I've primarily turned bowls and consider myself a beginner with a couple dozen finished and another 40 roughed out waiting for finish turning.

I do turn fast, even when my skills weren't so good. I've since improved. not sure if high rpm and larger pieces added to this issue, or maybe i'm noticing something that was always there. In any event, I intent to turn slower as I think my skills improved to where the time difference between turning fast and slow is negligible.

My friend who has a lot of bowls under his belt and I'd call “semi-pro” turned a demonstration on this lathe and doesn't recall any issues.

It's not the faceplate. I’m using the 6” from jet faceplate with 8-10 screws. The wood won’t move in the faceplate.

Last, I should have stated in my original post that I only roughed out the outside of the green walnut bowl or turned the outside of the bowl. I have yet to do the inside which I normally do in one session. I would have turned it all in one night, but I was determined to fix the vibration issue and ran out of time. Not sure if this changes anyone’s mind, let me know

matt

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#9

That went well then

Geoff Whaling

Matt a bit of background does help. Hope you can get this one resolved fast, as its not fun loosing precious turning time while trouble shooting. Good learning opportunity though.

I guess my words came out wrong John.

What I'm saying is we all should do the routine maintenance & inspection stuff anyway. Look for the common reasons for vibration - lathe setup, wood movement & mounting issues. Bent spindle shafts etc while they may be possible they are unlikely and rare. I agree many are quick to blame the lathe or manufacturer before resolving the more common issues.

Matt, We don't get your walnut here so I'm not familiar with it. Does it have hard & soft regions in the bowl blank? Johns comment about "The piece needs to be shifted until the center of balance has been found" & yours "I noticed that the depth of the cut varied on the same portion of the bowl" hints that it may do. If it does it could simply be a weight imbalance in the blank causing vibration or varying hardness could be causing the tool to slightly reciprocate in & out creating a weight imbalance. The varying depth roughing cuts around the circumference of the blank occur as the gouge "skips" when it passes over hard areas. This can be more pronounced at slower speeds and with forcing dull tools. It could also be your technique - the sequence of how you make the cuts - are they supported cuts? What size bowl gouge are you using? Is it sharp?

We have a timber we call "ivory walnut" locally in Far North Queensland. It is spectacular with very hard black regions & spalted "softer" regions. Overall it is a very abrasive timber with a high silica content and takes the edge of a gouge in a matter of seconds at higher turning speeds. Its worth persisting with though, but it can be a nightmare to work. I have found larger bowl gouges minimize the issues I mentioned above however they can't hold an edge for any practical length of time which creates issues caused by the persist a little longer or sharpen cycle?

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#10

Re: clarifications and question for John

Dick Coers

I'm no fan of bolting to the concrete. I've been taught that you will have bearing trouble then.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#11

Re: clarifications and question for John

Dale Bonertz

That is another topic that is sometimes hotly debated. May I suggest you check your owners manual on that question. The manufacturer of my lathe recommends bolting it to the floor/concrete - written in the owners manual.

Re: Bad vibes on the JET 1642

#12

Re: clarifications and question for John

John Jordan

Level is not the problem, its two legs that are not touching the floor. I suspect that if you take the blank off and mount it between centers and balance it, you can solve the problem. This should be the method you use in any case.

Start over is my best advice.

John