Apologies for the mediocre pictures... but mostly just interested in the general shapes here.
Was wondering if I could get some feedback on what's wrong with this form. It looks pretty ok (to my eye) when viewed straight on (ignoring the small flat under the transition - getting consistent curves is still a WIP).
But from an elevated angle it starts to look a bit weird for some reason. This has been bothering me every time I look at it since it seems "close" but is just a bit off somehow that I can't quite put my finger on.
This tells me I got something? wrong with it, but I can't quite figure out out where I went wrong with it so any thoughts are welcome.
Interestingly if you just change the curves just a wee bit it becomes a rather nice cauldron shape (again a little trouble on that transition..)
I am not a good critic. Sometimes I see that something is off a bit, but have no idea what to do about it. On your top bowl I think the foot is too big in diameter. I usually shoot for a foot that is about 1/3 the largest diameter. I like footed bowls but the foot needs to be very discreet.
My eye was stuck on the rim. I don't know if it is the size of the radius under the rim is too large, or that the rim is too large of diameter. My eye sure gets stuck on those two features. Maybe since it is a flatten shape that is inspired by native pottery, but is really a bowl instead of a hollow form. Very nice work!
My first reaction was that I would not have immediately thought there was a problem with the shape -- it's just "different" and "unusual" and "unexpected", all of which are good, in my book. But with your prompt, I came to agree with your assessment of something slightly unsettling.
After looking at it for a minute, I came to "my" conclusion -- which may not be anyone else's. If I were to make such a shape, I think I would not have the rim at the same diameter with the largest diameter of the vessel -- I think the entire shape would be more effective if the lip were either larger (as in your second pot) or smaller. But I'm not so sure about smaller either. I think larger is nice, and I like your second one.
I, too, would have gone with a smaller foot, but I don't think that's the main issue here. I believe that shape would benefit from, but not require, a smaller foot.
I think your eye is picking up the lines I added to your photo.
I think you will be happier if the angles are not at 90°, 80° or 110° anything close to 90 should be avoided.
In other words make the rim bigger or smaller than the bowl but not the same size. It is a trap that is all too easy to fall into by trying to make the largest bowl possible from bowl blank you have. To get the most pleasing form you will waste some of the wood.
These are very nice, and look like something anyone would want to hold in their hands, which is a good test of general appeal. My comments are in the spirit of helping you see these with different eyes and perfecting these forms for future work. I think these are very good the way they are, but if you make fine adjustments over a series of pieces, you'll really nail down what features you like best. And furthermore, I think the photos are GREAT ! Haven't seen anything green -- even moss -- in quite some time!
When we are turning, refining, sanding, and polishing these, we see them sideways, which almost no one else ever will, so it helps to look at them upright, and turn 'em upside-down to let the mind process the shapes. I like to hold them and turn them over and over -- sometimes with my eyes closed -- before they are completely finished, but certainly after they are done, to figure out what I like and what I wish I'd done a little different.
Looks to me like you have 2 bowls here -- 2 pix of one, and a single pic of the other? The two forms are different to my eye in 4 ways: 1) the first has a more sudden turn inward, under the rim, 2) the second has a fuller & taller profile w/out a sudden inward curve, 3) the second seems to have a rim that's wider than the body of the bowl, and 4) the second one appears to have either a round bottom or perhaps a small foot that's harder to see due to the photo angle.
Aside from any lumps in the curves, I think it's all in the rim size, as Walter points out, and the foot. I'm in a phase in which I prefer no foot and a full, rounded bottom for shapes like these. I like a foot on a more formal and fussy design. I can't say I'll still feel the same in 6 months, but that's where I'm at today.
I think a smaller rim might look and feel better, but I don't have the image processing skills to modify one of the photos to try it out -- probably someone here could do that. Raffan has some great forms that have just a little outward curve, and they look great -- I'll bet those are pretty tough to get just right, too! A wider rim could also work, but then the rim becomes the dominant element, and the full, organic shape of the pot or bowl becomes secondary.
As for any lumps in an otherwise fair curve, I rarely mind these if the entire form is warped from natural drying, but if turned with a zone that can be felt all the way around on an otherwise fair curve, it's hard not to notice when you pick the bowl up.
I think you have some great pieces there, and if you have more of this beautiful wood, a whole series of these will help you get closer to the elusive perfect form.
I'm no expert but I think that your bowl, let's call it like this, has a couple of profile problems that lead to what you righty cll squashed. To me the potential form was what the Greeks and Romans called Krater: a bowl divided in three parts, a foot, a bowl And a neck. It was used to mix wine, that at that time was too strong to be drunk undiluted.
An amphora had a neck smaller in diameter than the bowl so that it could be used to handle the vase itself while puoring and transporting.
Having said that, I feel that your neck has a cove too steep and short and the final curve of the bowl that precedes the neck becomes suddenly to sharp. These two fattors in my eye squash the vase that appers compressed. For the rest it is agood idea which need just a little improvement.
Of course I was commenting on the first picture. The last in some way has the mistakes corrected. Unfortunately I had lot of trouble posting the first post. Lot of try.
I see only two problem - other than any turning faults you mention, but are not easy to see on the pictures:
The foot does not belong, It is not necessary and spoils the cleanliness of the design.
The shape is too close to having e semicircular curve. The curve should change radius over the whole bowl to make it more interesting. not necessarily a lot, but more than you have done.
I do not know where you got your inspiration from, but the general idea is similar to some very ancient pottery found in caves in southern Spain - over 20,000 year old. The rim had a practical purpose - you could pick it up from the fire with two sticks. Most of thes cooking vessel did no have a foot and were a bit taller and pointier, so that they could stand directly in a fire and cook the content.
The bottom one with the cauldron shape is just fine. It directly mimics the very early cooking vessels made of cast iron and used one cast iron stoves or brick ovens.
In my view, the transition from the convex curve of the body of the bowl to the rim needs to be better integrated. Our eyes (mine at least) are accustomed to and most satisfied by pure geometric curves, e.g., parabolas and ellipses, even pure cyma curves. I think this piece would appeal to you more if a) the rim were a smaller diameter and b) the hollow were a more integrated transition instead of an arc of a circle, in other words, the curve sloped in more gradually and got tighter as it returned upward. That would have taken the emphasis off the shoulder a bit.
Shootin' from the hip here, so pardon me if my descriptions are hard to imagine.
"Our eyes (mine at least) are accustomed to and most satisfied by pure geometric curves, e.g., parabolas and ellipses"
Yes, but not circles or parts of circles, which tends to be heavy and boring. Any section of a cone is OK, whether it be parabola, ellipse, catenary - or superellipse.
Thanks all, definitely lots of good thoughts to ponder on the shape.
Brad: yes its two different vessels, sorry should have made that more clear - I included the second sort of as a might have been for the first. The upper two pics are the one I'm not happy with and the bottom is a different one. The problem one is 11" x 4.5" with 1/4" wall and the other is 13.5" x 6.5" with 1/4" thick wall increasing to 3/8" on the bottom. Both are sweet gum - used of that batch.
Sergio: thanks for the pictures - its sometimes hard to place where your thoughts come from that was similar to how I was originally thinking about this piece.
Interesting notes on the foot, it measures 5.5" so definitely more than 1/3 of the major diameter. I think perhaps even reducing the "weight" of it some would help - I may try cutting it back a smidge to see how that looks if it doesn't get grabbed up to quickly (in which case I'll figure one of the clamoring hordes liked it and chalk it up to experience )
Originally when the piece was rough turned the rim actually came up and out a bit more and the transition underneath it wasn't quite as steep - which looked pretty ok. The wood moved a fair bit bit when drying so I lost some of the shape when I finished turned it.. first time I've used gum so had really no idea what to expect (its not an easy wood to turn green to finish without excess fuzz compared to say maple or walnut or similar).
Although a catenary curve can be derived from a conic section (as a roulette of the focus of a parabola on a straight line), a catenary curve is itself, not a conic section. Also, as a personal opinion, I think the medieval stone masons did a pretty good job with arcs and straight lines in the stone tracery of gothic windows.