I guess I'm still not sold on the idea that turning a bowl on the end of the lathe is easier on the body than on the side of the machine. Has anyone seen or shot a video comparing? Even one just showing a bowl turned off the end of the lathe so I can watch the body dance? I've been searching YouTube, but no luck so far. Thanks.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Sergio
You are right, even people with moving headstocks seem to turn on the side of the lathe. If I had the ouboard ways like the new Vicmarc 300 has I'd probably use it.
I remember when I had a Jet 1642 I moved permanently the head foot plus from the left end not to have the foot on my way. That was all.
If I remember wel there is couple of you tube from a very nice irish guy, Robbiethewoodturner, who used a Vicmarc VL 175 with the head moved sideway. It seemed to work nicely.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Jeff Smith
Reed gray has a video on the ergonomics of turning that shows him turning off the end of his Robust AB - he also moves the head to the 'long' end to show the difference. Google Robo Hippie and ergonomics on YouTube and it should pop up.
I use my Robust much the same way for face grain work, but, being left handed (and somewhat ambidextrous) I tend to stand more directly inline with the ways for some operations.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
robo hippy
Thanks Jeff, I was going to suggest it. Like every thing else in life, some like it, some don't. The reason I got a sliding headstock was for the convenience of standing up straight and being able to keep the tool close to my body. The only advantage the fixed headstocks have, from what I have heard, is less vibration for turning and coring. I do a lot of both, and if there is a difference, I haven't noticed. I need to turn on a Vickmark some time though.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Dale Bonertz
I just watched Robo's video (nicely done). However I have to agree with Dick. The entire time Robo is cutting of the end of the lathe look at his body position. It is to the side of the lathe, he is allowing himself to twist his hip further right than when cutting on the long bed end of the lathe. Why not use the same cut and body motion on the longbed end. Your right hip will touch the lathe but you can use the exact same body motion and cut as he is using on the end of the lathe. In your mind extend the lathe when he is cutting off the end and you will see his right hip would be touching the lathe bed in the exact same way it would on the long bed end.
I don't get it with the sliding head stocks. Only advantage in my mind is if the turner does both hollow forms and spindle turning on the same lathe. And really the only advantage there is convenience in sliding the head stock rather than having a short bed lathe like vicmarc or oneway and using a bed extension for spindles. The short bed of the vicmarc is perfect in length for hollow turning by hand (I can't speak for the oneway since i have never turned a hollow form on one). So many use capture systems for hollowing that again sliding the head stock loses it's appeal since most of those systems you have to stand on the side of the bed to use them. This must be why so many who have the sliding head stock locate it in one position on the lathe bed and never move it again.
So why not buy a fixed head short bed lathe and eliminate any potential problems of having the most important component of the lathe (head stock) stay where it should be, fixed. Even in the operating manuals of the sliding head lathes (at least the one I read) says to move the head stock and then bring the tail stock up to align the points. This tells me there is play, which there needs to be or you wouldn't be able to slide the head stock, and thus introducing potential issues. Someone said these issues, that I bring up with the sliding head stock lathes, are operator errors. Maybe true but why introduce this potential in the first place with really little to no advantage of a sliding head stock.
In conclusion buy what your comfortable with and features that you think are important. There is a guy on another forum who uses the words herd mentality which I think applies to the sliding head stock debate. There is a perceived/real benefit for those who have the sliding head stock and for those that don't there are perceived/real issues with them. In the end which herd do you subscribe?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Jeff Smith
I didn't know there was a sliding head debate, or a cast vs weldment debate. Options exist for those who take advantage of them. Ford, Chevy or Toyota - they'll all haul your lumber; use what gets the job done best for you. If a sliding headstock allows advantages to the way you turn, you'll find it necessary - if the only material that will dampen vibration in your shop is cast iron (in spite of modern engineering and 20th century technology) you'll never be happy with a weldment.
I doubt that everyone approaches the lathe the same way. I'm left handed naturally and shift from hand to hand depending on what I'm trying to do. Probably looks awkward to someone watching at times, but it gets the job done. I use the sliding head quite often for face grain work and find that I reach across the ways (or where they would be) much less and stand straighter when turning. It is more comfortable for me. Depends on whether you're willing to adapt the way you turn to the tool you use or have the tool adapt to the way you turn most comfortably.
I doubt that a well designed and manufactured sliding head gets out of alighnment much more often than a fixed head one - it seems to me that the tailstock would be the culprit more often than not anyway. It just gets moved more and is more prone to wear.
All in all, as they say across the pond - it's horses for courses. I doubt that any minds are going to be changed by the discussion.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
I have just had this itch to buy a new lathe. Had it for a couple of years actually. I was just trying to gather information and try to understand what people were saying about the ergo advantages of the sliding head. Now that I bought that Hapfo, I might not have to make the decision for a while. LOL Doubt it, the itch still comes back fairly often. I'll always be a kid like that!
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
My biggest complaint with the sliding headstock is getting the tailstock out of the way. If I did enough turning to make it worth while (or my back was in slightly worse shape) one of the swing way tailstock setups would be on the short list... Hasn't been quite worth while yet but hoofing that sucker off and on the lathe gets tiresome pretty quickly (so I end up not turning off the end that much either unless its really compelling for that piece).
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
John Jordan
If you take someone who turns on a longer bed lathe, and put them at the end of a short/sliding headstock lathe, it won't be long before they are sanding at the end (more or less). I have a sliding bed, rather than headstock, but the intent is the same. If you just have a shortbed lathe, you can't do a tall piece between centers before hollowing. I have turned on hundreds of the various moving headstock variations, and they work well. I have never found a downside and alignment is a non issue. Its MUCH easier to hollow from the end if you use hand held tools, and easier to move around if you are bowl turning.
I have had a double ended Oneway, and it takes up an enormous amount of room, and it takes more effort to move the piece to the other end than it would to slide a headstock (or bed). But the double end works fine if you have the room.
John
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
robo hippy
Dale,
I had to ponder this a bit first. I think that mostly the body posture remains pretty much similar as in it is much easier all the way around if you are standing up straight. With my daily turning, I frequently find my body crossing the center line of the lathe bed. You do have to make some compensations for the camera. I think the biggest difference is in how you hold your tools and arms. The long bed lathe requires you to extend out more than when you are on a short bed lathe, all in the name of not having to bend or lean over while turning. The pull cut that Mike Mahoney uses keeps the tools in close to your body. The Stuart Batty push cut has your holding your arms out pretty far from your body. These both are used for turning the outside of the bowl. When turning the inside of the bowl, their styles are pretty similar. While roughing out the inside of the bowl, you can do a lot without having to extend your arms out. When you start the finish push cut on the rim, you have to extend out again. Both systems work, I just find it easier to stand at the end of the lathe. I am constantly adjusting the position of my headstock when turning and coring bowls for maximum comfort. When I first got my Robust, it had hex nuts for moving the headstock. I had Brent send me a set up for the lever bar. It takes seconds to move. Having a tailstock tilt away got me to use the tailstock a lot more often. I do at least wipe the ways clear of shavings before I move it much, so build up and misalignment isn't a problem. Learned that one early on.
I wish some one would hurry up and invent transporters. I would love to do a play date with you some time to compare styles and techniques. I am different. I will get out to the Rocky Mountain Symposium some year. I will get a chance to chat with Stuart and Mike at the Oregon Woodturning Symposium in 2 weeks.
By the turner who refers to following the leader and not the pack because there is less to step in, are you referring to 'he who had been kicked off all but one forum'?
robo hippy
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
About three years ago I decided to this turning thing was going to occupy me in retirement - about 5 years off then. While it wasn't a 'money is no object' situation, I could justify raiding a small, poorly performing retirement account to finance a new lathe. I spent nearly a year actually turning on almost every contender I could think of - Oneway, Powermatic, Robust, VB36, Vicmark - the only two I couldn't get time on were the Serious and the Magma (neither was at the top of my short list, though, for various reasons). By the way - it's a great way to see just how much customer service you can expect after the sale to ask the manufacturer/distributor for some help locating the closest owner that might be amenable to having someone 'demo' their lathe. Since i was planning to spend what for me is some serious cash, I had big expectations of the help I received.
After several months, the one characteristic that I came to appreciate the most was the ergonomics of the tool. Machines either force you to adapt to how they are made or they are capable of adapting to the way you work. The latter became more important to me.
For me, I had adapted to the benefits of a sliding headstock with the Jet 1642 I had been using for about 6 years; I discovered that I wanted the largest swing and the most HP I could afford. Getting the tailstock out of the way wasn't a priority until I turned on a Robust AB and I was hooked. Since turning sloppy-wet wood is vastly entertaining to me and something I do as often as possible the stainless steel ways were a nice touch. Easily located controls are nice, too (I keep them on the banjo when I turn off the end...)
When you find the right machine for your style of turning, it just disappears and the only thing left is the wood and the cutting edge. The dollar difference between all the machines with similar capabilities is just not that great.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Dale Bonertz
If you are referring to MM then no. This other guy uses that phrase in regards to bowl gouges and grinds.
John brings up a point that I meant to in the last post. Sanding would be easier with sliding the head stock. Still think it is a ford versus Chevy type conversation. I certainly don't see enough of an advantage if any at all to sell my lathe and get a slider. To each to their own. Maybe if I wear out my Vicmarc I'll reconsider.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
I really enjoy turning off the end on my PM 3520B, but I agree that handling the heavy tailstock is an issue. I always take it off when turning hollow forms, but sometimes just lean over the bed when making bowls. Of course, I'm also glad the tailstock is massive -- but that makes it less fun to remove.
I have plans to get back into turning in a much bigger way, and I'll have to either build or buy a device for getting the tailstock out of the way. My 55-year old back wants it both ways -- out of the way w/out having to lift and carry it.
I'm also very picky about balancing the figure on bowls, so I start every bowl between centers (unless exceeding 20" and using the extension), and usually finish them between centers, too, so I want it there at the beginning and the end (or maybe a vacuum chuck if I could afford one).
So, great idea that helps a LOT, but I still don't do it as often as I'd like.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
.... alternative "Down N' Out" tailstock tilt down device for the Powermatics. The swinging design doesn't get the tailstock out of the way when it rotates away from the bed, and I don't believe Robust any longer makes a swing down device for the Powermatic. All the Powermatics at the Folk School this trip were equipped with the Down N' Outs and they really save wear and tear on your back! Check out jtturningtools.com for more specific info and price.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
HeatherAinAK
Does anyone regularly turn off the other end of the headstock (outboard) if so equipped? I have a powermatic 4224 that came with the outboard bed extension and tool rest. I use it for storage as I figured it would only be useful if I wanted to turn something that exceeded the inboard capacity. I just took a class with Trent Bosch who advocates turning off the end for bowls and I got a chance to try it out on a lathe with a sliding headstock. I would have to reposition my lathe but wondered if there are any downsides to outboard turning. Enjoying this thread.
Heather
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
robo hippy
I am pretty sure that Trent turns on a Robust now. I do know of some that use the option. There used to be some 'adjustments' for the turner to make because you had to have a left threaded chuck and face plates because that end ran in reverse. I don't know if that has been changed or not. I didn't consider that option because that end of my lathe is in a corner.
robo hippy
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock
Dale Miner
The only time I've noticed alignment being an issue was spinning metal. The headstock can be off a bit one direction, the tailstock the other, and the spinning blank will be a bear to center and will in short order walk back out of concentric. Makes a creaking sound when things are very far off. Usually, loosening the headstock slightly and cranking the tailstock while things are spinning slowly will push the headstock lengthwise a bit, but will also cause the headstock to walk over into alignment with the tailstock. Clamp the besdstock down tight, lossen the tailstock a bit, repeat. After doing the headstock and tailstock this way, things work much better. The alignment doesn't need to be perfect, but does need to be close.
Re: Video showing bowl turned on sliding headstock?
Doesn't the extension get in the way for turning off the end - or do you add/remove it as needed as well? Its pretty heavy so it didn't seem like something I'd want to move a lot but maybe there's a trick