Hi, I uploaded on mumnew gallery a few photos. I just wanted to try it and found a few problems that should be addressed.
There is a List of recent galleries: well mine is not there. Not that I care but to show that it is not updated regularly.
Also to go to the forum from the Gallery it is impossible. I need to reload the forum from my bookmrks. Not the easiest solution.
Finally there is no way to know if people have seen a personal gallery not to mention single photos. This renders the gallery not too interesting, besides the cronic lack of comments.
I agree with you Sergio. It seems the only use for it is a personal photo file, but I got my hand slapped for downloading the wrong kind of pictures, even though I thought they would be interesting to others. Go figure.
Sergio, the Recent Gallery list is set up for newly established galleries rather than as a update list to older ones. The software doesn't (presently) have a "views" function like you may be used to on web forum boards. Visitors are, of course, welcome but not required to make comments on the work being shown, but, because Ellis had an early problem with spammers, comments by unregistered visitors must be reviewed and approved. Not a good solution to the cheap viagara problem but the only working one for now. Keep in mind that site maintenance and alterations to software are not free. The gallery site is not self-sustaining, so changes and additions to the formatting and functions may happen only as Ellis has the disposable funds to do them.
The gallery is just getting started. Functions like navigation links may be added in the future. Remember that you can include a link to your own website (if you have one) or contact information like an email address so that viewers can contact you directly about your work.
Barry, seems you missed the front page explanation that the Galleries are for finished work. They're not an alternative to the WC Shot Shots section. Not a big deal but hardly a "hand slap" kind of thing. BTW, you can go to your gallery and designate a photo for your work to show on the index page along with your name so people interested will know what you do. Right now, all that shows is your name.
Thanks, I just would like the gallery to be more active. I'm also a big believer in the educational (passive and active) function of a good constructive critique.
to do crits from internet photographs, Sergio; they usually wind up being comments on the photography coupled with expressions of personal preferences that are little more than "ataboys". I have done several, one of which was posted on the old WOW site. They take a great deal of time to work up, and even with a comprehensive set of photographs and the individual's prior portfolio to draw on, the analysis was pretty limited.
If you're looking for a useful critique, take your stuff to a symposium and button-hole a turner you respect to look at and comment on your work "in the flesh." The ability to engage in a real conversation about the piece in real time makes a huge difference.
I would not expect much more in the Galleries than personal expressions and generalized comments on one or more design elements. A back and forth question & answer dialogue won't happen in the gallery context.
I posted some pics of a completed table I built a long time ago. I got asked a question about how I did one decorative aspect of the table, and responded with some construction photos and a lengthy explanation. I haven't seen any responses at all to those, but we decided that probably wasn't really an appropriate use of the Gallery, so we are converting the instructional information into an article. While that's probably the appropriate place for it, a potential problem is that, unlike a post on a forum or a project shown in the gallery, there isn't a way to discuss the information later. We will shortly be removing the construction information and photos from the Gallery, so if anyone wants to ask any questions, now would be the time to do it.
The other motivational problem is I have no idea whether anyone finds the information interesting, or even whether anyone has looked at it. I think if users of this website want more work posted on the gallery, they would be wise to comment on what is there.
A "viewed" function would be helpful if only to let a gallery-member know that people are looking, as would an indication that a gallery had been updated or changed to alert viewers to new items. We can't expect people who, having gone through the images, to go through them all again just to find a couple of new pieces posted.
I understand that Ellis is working on all of this.
I saw your table but missed your build pix because I did know they were there. Your article will expand on the pix and it would be well to then put a link to the article in your gallery image with Ellis' question.
This is a great use of the gallery for a chat session. The photos are in one place for viewing. Any discussion is then done during the chat. Once done if it warrants documentation the chat session and photos can be organized into an article.
Thanks, Sergio. Yes, I'm aware of various gallery improvements that would be welcome. I do what I can to implement them as time and budget permit.
Here are a few items on my wish list, including some things you're suggesting:
1. Increase the viewport size to 1400 px. This would have the effect of making the page wider and increasing the area for displaying thumbnails.
2. Organize the thumbnails into a more regular grid.
3. Add view counters to individual images.
4. Flag gallery and image thumbnails to give a visual clue as to which have been updated since your last visit. This is somewhat challenging because it is going to involve setting cookies on visitors' browsers that will remember which galleries and images you've already viewed, similar to the way our cherries work in the messageboards.
5. Ditto for comments. It would really foster dialog if you could see at a glance what comments were being exchanged on which images.
6. Change "Recent Galleries" (latest created) to "Recent Uploads" or some such, to indicate galleries that have undergone recent additions.
6. Set up some kind of autofill for name and e-mail address when commenting on an image.
Others?
I will transmit these requests to the guys who are doing the development for me and get a quote on feasibility, cost and timelines. Regarding getting back to the forum from the gallery, if you scroll down the gallery page, you'll see a large banner invitiing you to click here to visit the forums. Maybe that needs to be more obvious.
And, as far as guidelines for posting, as I was telling Barry Rockwell and William Duffield and Mark Mandell and others, we're feeling our way into this so it might take some time to settle out. Originally the gallery was intended for people to have a place to post photos of their work where it could be preserved for posterity, as opposed to inline on the forum where it scrolls off the page in a couple days. That is accomplished, and now we're dealing with navigation issues mostly. Process shots and images unrelated to individual gallery pieces aren't forbidden, but they do dilute the images of finished work and they're all on the same hierarchy level in the gallery.
I looked into allowing each registered gallery member to have a two-tiered gallery, one tier for finished work, and within each of those a sub gallery with process shots. That proved to be way too complicated and expensive, and potentially confusing for everyone. Besides, we do have an articles department where good process articles are welcome, and those articles can be easily linked to from the gallery image of the finished piece whenever the author wants to include further information. The downside here is that the articles department doesn't include the opportunity to comment, so where exactly to have discussions is unclear. If the discussions are moved to the forum, they scroll away; if they go back to the gallery, the process shots are not there anymore.
So you see, there are no clear "best" ways to move forward. Another dimension for me is the expense and the time and liason required for me to try to specify and oversee the software development. I could have bought a good used car for what I've already invested in the gallery with no revenues anticipated, so I have to be a little careful. If I could envision high functionality and traffic, then I might be able to open it up to advertisers at some point. Meanwhile, we'll have to proceed carefully, implement affordable changes as quickly as we can identify the needs and wish lists, and live with what we have already.
You may have noticed that I commissioned a category filter recently, that allows you to click to see galleries that are self-identified (or identified by me) as turning, furniture, architectural or miscellaneous. As the number of contributors grows, this will allow visitors to view galleries by categories, to cut down the sheer number of thumbnails viewed.
Anyhow, that's the state of play. I apologize for anything that isn't suitable and I look forward to incremental improvements. Time is on our side.
Ellis, I am a member of the segmented woodturners and our site Has a different format which has a current gallery and separate member galleries. I am not saying that it is better but different. You might look at it for some ideas that you may or may not try.
I had a look at your forum and gallery and there are things I like about it, including the photo of the week. At the background level of what's going on here, I've adopted a Wordpress platform for the gallery pages. Features that are standard in your vBulletin forum software can't easily be translated into the sorts of layouts and widgets that Wordpress uses, so incorporating those features here won't be trivial in terms of programming and cost. What I need to do is articulate things that we'd like to have and run them by our developer for feasibility and cost. Anything may be possible, but most enhancements at this point are going to be custom jobs.