Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Lathe Upgrade

Posts

Lathe Upgrade

#1

Lathe Upgrade

Doug Reynolds

Retirement is less than five months away and it is time to upgrade my Jet mini lathe to something full sized. I have compared all the specs and wanted to ask if there is any reason NOT to buy any of the following brands of lathe:

Vicmarc

Oneway

Powermatic

My interest/concern is parts and service in case something stopped working. I have heard Oneway was having trouble with the alignment of spindles but, assume this can happen on any lathe.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#2

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Rjstavran

Robust

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Dennis in Southern Oregon

That's the first I've heard of spindle alignment problems with Oneway. My 3624 has been in perfect alignment for over ten years now and is rock solid. I would expect alignment probems to be more common with movable headstock machines.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#4

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Doug Reynolds

The Robust is outside my price range and, again I am only seeking resons to NOT buy any of the above brands otherwise, they are all contenders. I only heard of the spindle alignment problem from one person so, it could have been a glitch.

Also, how much horsepower does a casual hobbiest turner really need? The usual answer is buy as much as you can afford. Some machines come standard with more horsepower than others so, is it worth it to upgrade say to three horses?

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#5

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Dick Coers

I use 2 hp. No reason not to buy one of those lathes.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#6

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

My Oneway has 2 hp...more than I've ever needed. I have a fiiend who has a Oneway with 1-1/2 hp...he cores big blanks on a regular basis. Service from Oneway is excellent

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#7

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Geoff Whaling

Doug if you are doing typical projects I think you would be happy with product from any of the three manufacturers. I believe 2hp is plenty for the average turner, 1 hp was plenty for decades. Rating measurements are not comparable or reliable guides to effective power depending upon country of origin. Hogging cuts are hard on old bodies. ;-)

The 3 you mention seem pretty reliable & consistent. I have no experience of Oneway. Powermatic I've only ever seen one as both are ridiculously expensive here plus Vicmarc are made here in QLD. I have used many Vicmarcs and some very early models too, 850's etc. All Vicmarc lathes are un-killable. You have to do something really stupid to cause harm to Vicmarc castings, bearings etc. They do have detractors too, but usually there is operator error & pride involved in the stories, or it was a bare lathe with a DIY stand / motor. I think the most significant weakness in all modern EVS lathes is their vulnerability to power issues, and the expense of repairing / replacing the EVS units.

Have you considered the M910 Rikon/Woodfast/Record? I have an older Woodfast M908 with the M910 retrofitted - very nice lathe.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#8

Re: Lathe Upgrade

robo hippy

Well, I consider the Oneway and Robust to be in the same price range, and both are excellent. The PM3520 is an excellent lathe. I had one for 8 years before I stepped up to a Robust. I have never turned on a Vicmark, so can't comment there. I do prefer a sliding headstock as it is very versatile. Alignment problems are more with the pivoting headstocks. You can get chips under the tailstocks and headstocks which can cause some alignment problems, but pretty easy to fix. I have heard several comment that the fixed headstock has less vibration issues than the sliding headstocks, but haven't tried one since before I got my PM 16 plus years ago, and it was a 12 inch lathe. Many have the Jet 16 lathe with 1 1/2 hp motors. I found it pretty wimpy for production turning, but for hobby turning it is great. 2 hp is probably more than you need, but I like the extra power. I have a 3 hp on my Robust and would like 5.....

robo hippy

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#9

Re: Lathe Upgrade

David Walser

There's no reason NOT to buy any of the brands you mentioned. Each brand sells a number of lathes. Which of those lathes to buy will depend on what you want to turn, your style of turning (how you prefer to stand at the lathe, where you want your controls, etc.), the amount of room you have in your shop, and your budget.

How much horsepower you'll want (as opposed to need) will depend on the kind of things you turn and, more importantly, on your style of turning. If you tend to take very aggressive cuts or turn large scale items, you'll want more horsepower. However, 1.5 hp will allow you to turn very large items -- if you take it slowly and take light cuts.

Good luck with your purchase and with retirement!

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#10

Re: Lathe Upgrade

David Walser

I only heard of the spindle alignment problem from one person so, it could have been a glitch.

I suspect the lathe with the alignment problem was not properly leveled. With the exception of poorly made lathes, all the alignment issues I've seen were caused by the lathe bed not being leveled front to back and sided to side. If that's the case, it's not a reflection on the quality of manufacturer.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#11

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Dale Bonertz

Good luck in your search. Geoff mentioned that vicmarcs are un-killable. I have to agree. A friend of mine has had a VL300 for 25 years and has never turned it off (I am referring to the VFD). He has never replaced anything (bearings, VFD drive, motor, belts or anything). That is after he has rough turned over 35,000 plus (that is correct) bowl blanks. That speaks volumes to me.

If you are a hobby turner the 3520B will work for most people but you always hear, on forums, of this going bad or that going bad and etc. I am not a fan of sliding head stocks. When you have the most important component of a lathe and it is movable you are introducing potential problems (vibration, twisting the bed, not holding down tight, spindle not lining up with the tail center and etc.). It is easy to understand that having the head stock fixed over a solid foundation (the legs) is a superior design. If this is the last lathe you intend to purchase I would sincerely consider, out of the three, the VL300 or the Oneway. If you have a lot of accessories then look closely because the Oneway has some different morse tapers and I think different threading on the spindle Been awhile since I viewed all the specs on that lathe. Al can jump in to note the differences from most lathes. It may cost you quite a bit to adapt your accessories to that lathe. Most lathes and standard accessories have a 1 1/4" x 8 thread on the spindle and #2 morse taper. Again, good luck with your search and try to turn on all of the lathes you are considering.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#12

Re: Vicmarc no doubt

Sergio

Vicmarc here, I have VL300 and when my addition to the shop will be done I hope to add VL240.

I believe that there are difference between the Powermatic, Robust Onway e Vicmarc. One is cast iron versus Steel.

vicmarc is cast iron like powermatic but the two are in different league. Powetmatic, which in Europe is sold only as Jet even the bigfer ones, is made in an anonimous factory abd marketed according to the markets needs. The motor is also anonimous with with a plastiv sticker on it! (Correct me if I'm wrong).

Vicmarc is machined in house and in Australia. One of the interesting features of the VL300, if this is your size lathe is the possibility of adding sections to reach any lenght besides the outboard section. Plus, and to me this is really a bonus, it has a marvelous stop bar that allow to stop the lathe with the knee from any position. i found these feature unique and very useful in emergencies. The Robust is an eccellent lathe if you want a movable head and Oneway if you want a massive amount if steel. Another difference is in the bearings: tapered roller in the Vicmarc and ball bearing in the other two. The spindle of the Vic very simple and easy to disassemble to change the belt and cleaning nd greasing the bearing (every many years) witout changing them like the other two.

Hope this will help. By the way, the Vic is about two thousand dollar less then the other two.

There a new Vl 300 with a 2hP about 1000dollar less then the VL300 3HP.

Regards.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#13

If you intend to be a turner of.......

JamieDonaldson

..."average" sized objects, 2 HP and 20" swing capacity are 2 criteria for your dream lathe. The Powermatic 3520B is the best value in a lathe that size, and sliding headstock problems mentioned are operator errors, not design shortcomings. Vicmarcs are excellent lathes, but the current Chinese made Woodfasts are not a shadow of the quality of the older machines.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#14

Do any of y'all have any real .........

JamieDonaldson

...experience with Baileigh lathes? I don't believe I've ever seen one, just know that they exist here in the US, with dealers in Wisconsin and California.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#15

Re: Lathe Upgrade

walta

It has been my observation that the best lathes do not depreciate and hold their resale value.

If you are in a position invest more money now you can enjoy a fine machine now and when the time comes to sell it should sell for more than you paid but less than the now higher retail price.

So you are likely to have a much lower differential cost so it is likely the more expensive machine costs less to own over time.

The Powermatic is not quite in that class but they have held there resale value better than the $2000.00 class lathes.

Walta

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#16

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Phillip Medghalchi

Have you looked at NOVA, if you are not going to be a production turner then the price is right and I haven't had any problem with it since 2012.

Also, if you buy one of the ones above, then you have to changed your wife's BMW, to a Mercedes, to make everything fair. :D

Other wise you wouldn't be behind the lathe turning. :b

Good luck, with your purchase, I am sure your final choice will be very much appreciated by the maker of the lathe. (big $). :b

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#17

Bill Blasic

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Bill Blasic

I can have any lathe I want. I bought a Powermatic 3520b about ten years ago and if I had to buy another today I would do it in a heartbeat even though the price now is $1400 more than mine cost new. I have used the Vicmarc and it is a good lathe but I am partial to the sliding headstock. All my lathes are cast iron as that is what I like. The Powermatic has been absolutely trouble free and I think it is still the best bang for the buck available.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#18

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Bill McWhirter

As opposed to other posters, I feel that the sliding headstock of the PM 3520 is a big plus. Reaching retirement to me means that you are "older" and with that come all sorts of musculo-skeletal maladies, i.e., back problems. Being able to slide the headstock to the tailstock end allows you to stand UPRIGHT at the end to do most anything that does not require the use of the tailstock. That was the deciding factor for me (with my aging back). If you are left-handed, it is even more important to be able to stand at the end.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#19

Re: Lathe Upgrade

Brent English

Respectfully Doug, if you are looking at Oneway lathes or the Powermatic 4224, then Robust lathes are very much in your price range. As others have pointed out, if your budget is in the $3500-4000 range, get the PM 3520. Bumping up into the $5k range, the Vicmarcs are hard to beat. Brent at Robust Tools.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#20

Re: Lathe Upgrade

don stephan

Haven't had an accident (yet?) but sure wish my lathe had the full length kill switch of the Vicmarc. If needed once, it would be worth the cost of five or ten lathes. IMHO

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#21

Re: Do any of y'all have any real .........

Dick Coers

My opinion is they are the same as Grizzly with a different color paint. Can't verify that, but they are not a manufacturer.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#22

Some additional thoughts

David Walser

My interest/concern is parts and service in case something stopped working.

All three firms you mentioned have good reputations for service after the sale. However, Powermatic is not independent. It is possible that Powermatic's current owner will sell the brand to a firm that isn't as supportive of service after the sale.

Re: Lathe Upgrade

#23

Brad Vietje

Horsepower

Brad Vietje

For most turners, horsepower is overrated. If you are turning bowls for a living, and cranking out X bowls per day pays the bills, then more HP ==> more work produced.

I have a friend who's been a professional turner for about 20 years, who sometimes turns and cores some really big bowls up to 48" diameter. He uses a home-made lathe with a 1.5 hp motor. Many of the big ones are turned with massive rims that are carved later, so they are pretty heavy, too. He's a fellow who could probably benefit from a 5 hp lathe, but he understands how to work smart and keep his tools sharp.

Most people will be fine with a 2 hp lathe. I've slowed mine down a few times, but 2 hp is fine for me.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT