Thought I would ask around. I'm packing my old one (thank god for stretch wrap) Anyway thanks to this latest round of cold it is very cold out there. I've been running the heater all morning and it's up to about 45 now but probably won't get any warmer. Just too much heavy metal to warm up and it's supposed to get even colder tonight.
Back to the topic. I will be either building a new shop or heavily modifying the existing garage shop. Insulation will be installed of course but my question is what style of heating to use. I have natural gas available and of course in Tenn electric is fairly cheap. Do you install a big heater and then a separate air conditioner for the really hot humid summers. Central heat and air would require some kind of additional filters on the return I would think but that's what is most popular for homes around here. Not sure about shops.
Looked at those units they have in hotel rooms that heat and cool in a single unit. Not sure they would handle something as large as a 3 car garage shop.
I currently use a large electric force air heater (6KW-220V)
The heat-pumps you mentioned are possible, but slightly better would be their "big brother", the Mini-split.
This type mounts to the wall of the shop, you then run pipes out to the air-handler.
The operating efficiency of these units is amazing SERs of 16 and 18.
The larger ones will work for your size install
Most good heating contractors would install them. However if you are handy, you can do most of the install yourself. Buying the unit mail-order, at a significant savings.
Most areas however require the system to be charged (freon) by a licensed HVAC type. You should be able to find someone to do that by asking around and/or running an AD on CraigsList.
I agree with Ralph. World wide, those units are very popular and dominating the market. Not so much in the us, but they are coming on strong.
I have two concerns. If you pan to keep your shop heated all winter they would be fine, but if you are going to turn it on and off, maybe not. Heat pumps don't do very well from a cold start. Might take it a while to catch up.
The second concern is the dust. Not sure how the unit would perform if it is constantly drawing dusty air through it. Might be possible to set up some sort of effective prefilter for it, but I would be careful.
The other classic choice would be a gas heater hanging from the ceiling and a window air conditioner. The air conditioner woudl have the same concerns about the dusty air. The gas furnace woudl have a fast start up.
Don't have one yet myself but I have been considering one of the ductless systems as mentioned here by others. A friend installed a couple of them on outbuildings and is very happy. Only real opinion I can offer is that of my godson, an HVAC guy who tells me Mitsubishi compressors have fewer problems than Toshibas. This seems to be a technology that just keeps on improving.
If you have natural gas available, I would make that a part of the equation. No way electricity can compete with its cost which is lower than 10 years ago,and pretty stable, even though they did raise it here in Ontario last year. I would bite the bullet and spray foam the walls for insulation. I have a three car garage with 6" insulated walls and good attic insulation, eleven foot ceiling and a U tube infra red heater. I keep the garage at 50F where the thermostat is which is on inside wall about center. For work sessions I turn it on 15 minutes before going out to it and raise the temp to just above 60 depending on season and work about 6-8 feet away from under the heater. AC I could only dream of, so can't help there.
I heat with kerosene . I put he heater as far away from the lath as I can. A double of years ago I put R19 in the walls and overhead.
I don't run the heater when I am not in the shop. This morning it was 42 in the shop and 17 out side. In less Than 1/2 hour it was up to 50 and by 1 I had to turn the heater off. It was pushing 80. I never I repeat never leave the shop when the heater is. Running.
Boy you must have a better heater and smaller shop. I had my propane heater on today all day. It's not quite as powerful as my Kerosene but close. It was 36 in shop this morning and warmed up to 57 after being on all day. My current shop just eats the heat. Ceilings are too tall and not enough insulation.
John, my shop is 24'x28', it's divided in half with a wall and door. the one side has my lathe, band saw, sharpening equip. 4x8 work bench. that side has a electric base board heater. it was there when I bought the place 12 years ago, so probability not as efficient as it could be. I live in north central Ohio so winters are pretty cold. when I'm working in the shop on a regular basis I leave the heater set a 50 over night with the door closed between the two sides. no worry on dust every once in awhile I take the shop vac to it to get the dust and shavings cleaned off. On the other side are my table saw, miter saw,planner, router table, and a wood burner. When I get down to the shop I crank the electric heater up to 70, a start the wood burner. within 2 hours both sides are at 70 and the electric shuts off for the day. I burn all my shavings and any other scrap yes I do have to get fire wood in, but there is plenty of free wood for that. my shop has good insulated doors and windows, and insulated wall and ceiling so it is efficient. the cost of a good base board heater and wood burner are fairly inexpensive the operating cost is very low, just involves a little work getting in the wood, but that good exercise. just another option for you
I know money is always an issue but a ceiling mounted LP or natural gas heater with a fan would be a great way to get instant directional heat as well as overall heat.
I don't have one of these but I have been in a shop that does and it is able to heat a 24"X32" shop from below freezing to well over 50 in less than 30 minutes. It has a thermostat so you can set it and forget it.
Depending on where you position it the fan forced heat can be directed to the area of the shop where you will be working first or the most.
Here is one similar to my friends that is available from Northern Tool. Most propane and natural gas suppliers also sell similar items.
I've been in shops that have those. Are there cold spots. Seems to me like it would leave one area a lot warmer than others. At least until it averages out if it does.
Baseboard seems like it would be a good choice unless it's just not afficient enough You wouldn't have to worry about dust in a return duct and changing filters. It could be around the shop so there wouldn't necessarily have cold spots. I might have 2 rooms in the new shop and and it could go in both rooms.
base board heaters are usually resistance electric. Fairly inefficient. NG is going to be your most economical source of energy. Lots of options, many mentioned above. The overhead radiant is among the most efficient with no venting required.
John, initially there are cold spots but since the unit has a blower it is moving the air about the shop and the entire shop gets warm.
That is why there is a thermostat on the unit to control the temperature evenly. I can tell you one thing, you don't want to be too close to it as the air coming out is very hot. That is why it is best mounted on the ceiling at some distance away from where you intend to spend most of your time.
If you remodel or build new, I would suggest a utility room. With a traditional NG furnace and air compressor in a separate room, you would reduce noise and reduce dust around the furnace. Get a pre cleaner in the air return and a 4" filter right before the furnace. Tough to beat for quick recovery. My new high efficiency furnace is only 18"x29"x 36" tall. 59" tall with the A coil. It's also totally sealed, all the combustion air is piped in, with exhaust going out the side wall in a PVC pipe.
John, I have what is probably a perfect combination: District heating based on hot water and an air handler in the shop. The shop is 1000 sq.ft. and serves both as workshop and garage. The heater is normally left on "freeze protection stand-by", so keeping the temperature above 40°F. When I go into the shop to work, it is a simple thing to turn the thermostat up to 60 or whatever. It does not take long before the air temperature is up to "comfortable"
Since you have natural gas, it would be possible to use a gas fired air handler with venting of the combustion gases to the outside. The air handler is nice in that it can put out a lot of heat quickly, and is easily controlled.
Just stating the obvious here for all of us trying to be productive in this cold weather. Be very careful with any heat source with and open flame. Wood dust can be explosive as can be fumes from many finishes. Also, if you are using combustion space heaters of any kind, be sure you have a carbon monoxide detector installed.
Steve I've been using open flame sources for almost 20 years. I'm sure there is a danger but I've never experienced it. I do shut them off when spraying lacquer. I did have a bag come off my dust collector once and filled the shop with dust. Scared me but it never did ignite. If I have a problem with carbon monoxide I don't know how to tell without a detector. I haven't had any physical problems I can point to. Unless it causes tool addictions. If so it's already out of control.
I do sweep up around the heaters if I leave the shop for any reason.
A mini-split (or possibly 2, depending on the size, shape and air flow) would be a very good option.
Mitsubishi makes the best ones on the market, and the only ones that can heat a home or a zone in a cold climate -- they are effective now to temp's below zero F. The LG models may be just as good in a warmer climate like Tennessee, so YMMV.
I would contact the dealer with questions about adding extra dust filtration, and make sure these units have enough oomph to handle the added air flow resistance. They will probably tell you that cleaning the filters every day is best.
While an air-source heat pump is probably by far the most economical option to install and run, the insulation is even more important. With enough insulation of the right type, your heat source matters less and less. If the insulation is not optimal you'll spend more money forever. I'll address that in a separate note.
In New England, baseboard heating is almost always hydronic -- a water/glycol mix is heated by a boiler burning oil, propane, or natural gas. Around here, electric baseboards are only rarely seen outside of a little supplemental heat in a mud room or bathroom. If you see a house on the market around here with electric heat, you run -- don't walk -- away. This is partly because we have very expensive electricity, and lots of cold, so it's a very expensive way to heat.
In your town or state, none of these things may be true -- pretty big country, so definitely not one-size-fits-all. No matter where you go, though, a heat pump uses electricity to transfer heat from A to B, and is a LOT more efficient that electric resistance heat.
C.O.P.: The comparison is usually made using the COP or coefficient of performance for a given heat source under given conditions. Electric resistance is defined as a COP of 1, meaning 100% efficient (or very nearly so). You can easily calculate kWh in and Btu out -- any "wasted" energy becomes heat, so unlike other electronic devices (like a light bulb or laptop) there really is no waste. However, there can be downstream inefficiency in heat transfer -- from dusty or grimy heat exchanger equipment or lack of airflow. A heat pump (or mini-split) works like a refrigerator running backwards to heat (frontwards to cool), and has a COP that is higher than 1, meaning more than 100% efficient. How could this be? Well, it's because we already defined a COP of 1=100% for electric resistance, so with a heat pump you will often see COP's of 2 - 7, meaning 2-7 times as efficient, depending on the temp and humidity of the ambient conditions.
For example: electric resist heater (COP =1): 1 kWh = ~3412 Btu. A heat pump at 45 F outside might have a COP of 5, meaning that it would use 1kWh to produce ~17,000 Btu, but if the outside temp is 20, the COP might be only 2.2 or 1.8 and so on. At some point, depending on the model, the COP approaches 1, and a simple resistance heater can be employed, or a different back-up or legacy system could turn on.
Carbon monoxide is a real hazard, particularly if you are using a combustion heater in a tight shop. The effects of high CO levels are cumulative and will build with time but the symptoms are subtle to the point where you may not realize what is going on. We have had two near misses at my house, both caught by a CO detector and it seems that I read about at least one local incident each year where folks are killed by CO.
In a garage shop with lots of air leakage it may not be an issue but it is still good practice to have a CO detector in any space with combustion heat. My shop is fairly tight and when I was using a propane fired radiant heater, my detector showed elevated levels of CO after extended periods of using the heater. I now use an electric heater.
In some areas, forced hot air is predominant, so that may be a the only consideration, but I'd encourage people to think outside that box, asFHA heating is terrible for turning green wood, since circulating warm (or downright hot) air will cause checks and speed up warping while you are still working. Some systems are great for holding a steady temperature, but others excel at rapid warm-up. Circulating air to move heat brings up (literally) dust issues. Hydronic systems like baseboard are less affected by dust, and radiant heat floors are completely unaffected by dust. Radiant floor systems can be great for fighting fatigue from standing on cold concrete, but do not respond quickly; they should only be used for constant temp systems.
Heat Source(s):
Existing systems -- could they be saved & used more efficiently?
Heat pump or Mini Split?
Wood Stove -- burn scraps of your turning
Petroleum fuels (oil, propane, NG, etc...)
"Geothermal" (ground source heat pumps) ?
Zone added to house or business?
Other Issues:
Combustion heat source (or not) ?
Fuel availability, environmental cost and financial cost?
Insulation and thermal mass (too much to cover here)
Shade from trees, buildings?
Air flow in summer? Can be very helpful to help keep you cool.
I figure if you are going to dig into the walls and ceiling (or roof), you are probably only going to do that once, so it's worth careful study and doing it "right" which means different things in different regions, or for different people. Caution: saving money in one area might cost you a lot more somewhere else!
Too much to discuss here in detail, but there are many factors to consider. In John's case, with and opportunity to retrofit an existing building, I'd say nothing is as important as insulation, so I'll start another thread on that.
John: Propane and oil cost more because you have to pay the delivery driver's salary. There are 3412 Btu per KWH of resistive electric heat. A therm of natural gas has 100,000 BTU of heat. A 1000 cu ft of natural has 1,020,000 BTU. Stack losses on any fired system have been 20% for decades. Newer systems are 5 to 10% stack loss. Heat pumps start losing efficiency at around 45deg, become almost totally resistive at 28deg. There is no ability for a fast recovery with heat pumps. Temperature differences between setpoint and room temperature larger than 2.5deg bring on auxiliary resistive heat on heat pumps. Do some simple math based on your local rates. The best thing to spend money on is INSULATION. It is a one-time expense. My wife's shop, 10' x 12', insulated in walls and ceiling with 3.5" fiberglass is heated with 1500 watt electric heater with oil from Lowes. It will run you out in the coldest weather on my mountaintop. Keep warm, have fun.