Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Photography - lighting illusions

Posts

Photography - lighting illusions

#1

Photography - lighting illusions

Geoff Whaling

In the "a comment on photography" thread posted by Darrin Hill, Jamie Donaldson suggested lighting balance should be mismatched to enhance the 3D appearance of the object. While revisiting this image for the 5 day FB challenge I noticed how this image plays tricks on the viewer.

Is the bowl's convex or concave shape facing the camera? Focus on the LH or RH rim of the bowl - what do you see?

The bowl btw is Queensland Silky Oak (Cardwelia sublimis) approx 250mm dia and about 6mm thick. Not fully finished in the image, sanded to 800 and only has one light coat of NC sanding sealer buffed with 0000 steel wool.

Photo was taken with a setup modeled upon Jamie Donaldson's Phrugal Photo Studio setup using materials costing less than $100AUD including the lights.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#2

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

John Lucas

This is a perfect example of lighting that is too flat or too even. You lose the depth in the bowl. If I use a photo booth or a set up similar to what Darrin posted I usually use just one light up high and to the side. Then fill with reflectors and sometimes aim that light forward just like Darrin did to pick up what I call Raw light and bounce it back it.

By using the one light to light the photo tents you end up with one glare that is usually soft enough to not be obnoxious, and then you have a shadow. You control the shadow by how much fill you add. You can also control the glare spot by moving the light up or down or forward or back to make it look better and give more shape to your piece.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#3

Geoff, try using just 1 light to add.....

JamieDonaldson

...some shadows to enhance the 3D effect. I usually place the single light in the front R of the enclosure, then fill shadows for detail with bounce boards on the opposite L side. Play with it! ;)

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#4

Different types of lighting

Dave Long

Jamie or John: What about the different types of light to use in photography such as floods, halogen or LEDs. What is the difference and what kind of effects does it have on the item being photographed

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#5

Re: Different types of lighting

John Lucas

The type of light doesn't matter. It's the quality of the light. When considering light sources there are a couple of considerations. The most important is whether or not you can set your cameras white balance to a setting that will match the light source. For example Daylight bulbs need the daylight setting. quartz lights will probably need the Tungsten setting. LED's and FLD's can be a problem unless you buy photo quality bulbs because they don't put out full spectrum light and may not match any setting on the white balance. Photo grade FLD's usually match the daylight setting if you buy 5500K bulbs

Power and Heat are the next considerations. I used to use Quartz lights for all my teaching because they have lots of power (think brightness for shorter exposures) They match the tungsten white balance close enough to work quite well for the color. The problem with them is the heat. They will catch a cloth diffuser on fire and of course touching them without a glove to move them would be very painful. If you use an umbrella it needs to be designed for the Hot lights, they will burn up a standard photo umbrella.

Tungsten photo bulbs are good but are kind of expensive and have a very short life. They are also quite hot in the more powerful bulbs. They do however produce very accurate color and fit in many standard Photo type reflectors and soft boxes.

What I use now are Photo grade FLD bulbs. They aren't very powerful and need a darkened room to work well, but they are very cool so it's easy to make your own light modifiers, diffusers, grids etc. They match the daylight setting on your white balance (if you buy the 5500K bulbs) and last a very long time.

The quality of light is very important for shooting art work. Darrin hinted at this when he said larger lights produce softer shadows. A single light bulb in a 12" reflector produces a rather harsh light because the bare bulb appears quite small. It gives a small but very harsh glare type highlight and produces a rather hard edge shadow. Put a piece of diffusion material over that same light and the glare is not as harsh and shadow edge is softer because the light now appears to be 12" instead of the small bulb. This makes it easier to reduce the shadow intensity by adding reflectors.

To the other extreme is using a light tent. A light tent is supposed to sort of simulate a very cloudy day. No real harsh highlights and no real shadows. Works well in some circumstances but for really glossy pieces you see the whole tent reflected in the piece and it tends to make pieces look very flat because you don't have much of a highlight and the shadows are way too soft if they even exist. The way to make these tents work is to use one light and move it away from the tent so it produces more of a hot spot on the wall of the tent. (I mount the light high and to one side more like the sun in early afternoon) This light can be moved around to create a nice pleasing glare or reflection on the piece which gives it shape. It also helps produce more of a shadow. Then you add fill light by either using a bounce card to bounce light back in or in some cases a second light that is much weaker on the other side of the box. Doing it this way you've take it from a really cloudy day to a sort of cloud blocking the sun kind of day which is much more pleasing.

In between the light tent and the small reflector light is what we call Soft Boxes or Umbrellas. As Darrin said the size of the light source affects how soft the highlights and shadows are. Distance of the light from the subject also changes this. A 12" square soft box placed 1 foot from the subject will produce the same quality of light as a 6' square soft box placed 6 feet from the subject (that's just an illustration and probably not exactly accurate) I typically light my pieces with 24x30" soft box with an FLD bulb placed about 2 to 3 feet away from the piece. This simulates using a large window to light your piece. Then I add a reflector to the other side and you get a lot of the advantages of the light tent but I have a more pronounce highlight and little more shadow. This gives turnings more shape and will show off the texture of carvings better. Being able to move the soft box around also helps create more shape on the piece or changes where and how the highlight looks.

A good example of this that Darrin understands quite well I'm sure is if you photograph a beautiful lady and a rough old cowboy. By using a very large light box or umbrella very close to the lady you soften all the shadows on any lines or wrinkles in her face making her look very soft and smooth. To shoot the old cowboy you probably want the wrinkles and harsh skin to look that way so you use a smaller light source further away and it makes the shadows on all those wrinkles really pop out. So is your turning a soft lady or a hard ole man. You get to choose the quality of light by your choice of light source to make your piece be one or the other.

Hope that answers your question. I'm putting off going to the cold shop to pack some more. Talked to the movers yesterday and they will get a quote to me on Monday. Pray that it's low enough that I can quit packing. I don't look forward to moving the shop by myself even with the help of friends, when a mover can do it in a day with all the right equipment. I've got to lay out all the tools I need for my Florida Demo and later Jackson, TN demo to make sure I don't pack those. My finance bless her heart packed the bowls I laid out for some show and tell on my natural edge bowl demo this last week so I didn't have those. I was lucky and caught her before she packed the router demo pieces but I simply didn't even think about the bowls. OK back to work. I'm really tired of packing tape.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#6

I have not worked with LED lights

John Lucas

So consequently can't answer any questions about them. If you can buy them balanced to some sort of photo color, such as 5500 Kelvin or 3200 Kelvin then I suppose they would work. Also remember that anytime you add some sort of light modifier, a grid, a diffuser, an umbrella or soft box, you reduce the power of the light. Shooting in a very dark room this isn't a problem but when I shoot in my living room for example, the light coming through the window about 16 feet away can change the exposure or reflect in the piece since I have to use very long exposures to compensate for relatively weak FLD lamps.

You are often shooting work at an aperture of F16 or even more. This leads to fairly long exposures which in a darkened room isn't a problem. If you have some sort of ambient light leaking in and can lower the contrast or in some cases even change the color of the shadows on the piece.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Light Painting *LINK*

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I think there's a mug shot format that has long been the Turning standard that needs to be challenged.

. I like to experiment with light painting, using LED lights to fill spaces and create depth, it's fun, look it up on Youtube, so many great examples!

Take care,

Jim


Light painting example

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#8

Re: Light Painting

John Lucas

Depends on where your photos will be shown. For entering juried shows you need a nice clean shot without a fancy background. The piece should be sharp and clear and instantly show the juror what need to be seen about that piece. Really fancy or gawdy photography can get your piece ignored or scored lower than it should.

for here on the Forums or on your own website feel free to do what ever you wish. It's your piece.

Light painting to be done successfully is very time consuming. You can do some wonderful things but be prepared to take all afternoon. Personally I'd rather be turning.

I've painted very large rooms inside a cave with nothing but a hand held flash. Took about an hour and many many pops of the flash to do it right but it worked out well. I also painted a building on campus with a hand held flash and used close to 300 flashes to do it. That was done when I was teaching a class we took the students out and gave them all a flash with instructions on where to aim it and how many times to pop it from each location.

My Boss and I also had to paint a Christmas tree that was in the school presidents house. It simply wouldn't light right with normal lights so we got permission to go back later that night used light painting techniques to make it look really great. That was back in the polaroid days and it was expensive so we did a lot of calculating before we ever took the first shot.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#9

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Light Painting

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi John,

I understand that some places require photo specific details, not challenging that at all. I guess thinking outside the lines is where I was going with my mention of light painting. Turners more than most are also interested in how to reperesent their work and I think options are good :-)

I can imagine light painiting a building would take some time and energy, but at the scale that most of us work with turning I think it's dead simple.

 photo Cameraold.jpg

This pic took a few minutes to set up and 12 seconds to expose with a single small LED torch… not too long.. trial and error, took three frames.

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#10

Re: Light Painting

John Lucas

Pretty cool Jim. I donated 120 antique cameras to our local museum when I retired. Just didn't have any place to put them.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#11

Jim, light painting is a bit too ......

JamieDonaldson

...advanced a technique for many turners who are not interested in being photographer enough to experiment. I have done light painting in some very unusual settings in the military, and digital feed-back (instant replay!) would have been a huge blessing! Feel free to experiment as you choose, but John has well explained that circumstances most often require specific presentations in an image.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#12

I have this LED light coming my way to play with. *LINK*

Keith Newton

Makita LXLM03 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion 12 L.E.D. Flashlight. I wasn't thinking about using it for photographing my work, but planning to try some new things out in Nature shooting in macro, maybe in video. I already have 4 tools which use this battery, so I can just use one of those when I'm out at night.

At 240 lumens, in close range, I'm thinking it should be pretty bright. Makita makes another one which is a lot smaller, for about half the price, and in a format that might be easier for me to use, but instead of lumens, they show it as 500 lux, which I'm not familiar with, but for the $25 range, may just get it to find out.

I'll have to try painting with this light when I get it.


http://www.amazon.com/Makita-LXLM03-18-Volt-Lithium-Ion-Flashlight/dp/B007ZOMKJ8

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#13

Re: I have this LED light coming my way to play wi

John Lucas

Do you know what the color temperature is. As I said above I haven't used any LED lights. I do have a 300 lumen light I use for part of my home protection package. I may have to try it out in photography. I doesn't like to stay on for a long time. It gets hot and starts strobing instead of continuous light. It is extremely bright.

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

#14

Re: Photography - lighting illusions

Geoff Whaling

Jamie & John, thank you for your guidance on how to improve this photo. I only noticed the illusion the other day probably near two years since I took the photo. I still have the bowl so I may set up the phrugal photo studio again to see what I can do,

All this discussion on light painting is interesting. I have seen the results of light painting on architectural images of historic buildings but never really bothered to find out how it was done.