Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

Posts

Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#1

Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

robo hippy

Another clip from me. Side note, I do use spindle roughing gouges for finish cuts. They are never good or safe for roughing, but can produce very clean finish cuts.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1x2qQDNL9BQ

robo hippy

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#2

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

john Veerkamp

I agree, I use a 1" roughing gauge to do my rolling pins start to finish, except for the parting tool to clean off the nubbins from turning between centers.

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

Keith Tompkins

Reed, Curious, have you tried the same cut you are showing after honing the tool to compare the final cut? Thanks for sharing!

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#4

Steven Antonucci

What tool do I grab?

steven antonucci

More often than not, there are a number of ways to accomplish any turning task. For me, the question is which tool is going to be the best...and the answer largely depends on movement.

On a large surface, I think it is very difficult to pull cut through without creating ripples with a smaller tool, especially if the tool has a small sharp tip. Every adjustment of body, every breath can telegraph in a ripple. I prefer to push because I can swing my body through an arc without having the little two-step dance and trying to keep bevel contact.

So, if you take a good edge, and can move it through the cut, you are in a good spot. Having the handle really low can make it difficult to get the bevel to stay in contact and moving across a large surface because so much of the cutting forces are being directed down the tool shank and sliding you down the rest. It's doable on a convex surface, but pretty hard on a concave surface.

You show a lot of proficiency, but I tend to replace things once I find something better? I don't know that all of the things you show are practical, given some work better than others consistently?

Steve

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#5

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

robo hippy

Well, I don't hone, mostly because I have never found it to help, and this revolves around the discussion of 'more serrated cuts better/no honed cuts better', and kind of ties into what Steve mentions. I have never found any one tool that works every time. One would think that after all the years I have been turning, that one tool would make the same cuts every time, but that appears to be as true as using the same drying method for every piece of wood. I can take two pieces from the same tree, some times, even a core from a bowl, and finish cuts from one tool work beautifully, and while the others won't, but on the second piece it is different. Just 'because'.... Well, that isn't an answer!!!!! I don't really have a better one. The high shear angle makes the cleaner cut most of the time.

Steve, I think the ripples come from both pull and push cuts. What seems to make the difference to me is how close to your body your arms are. If you are doing the Stuart Batty type push cut, arms extended way out, that would be difficult to learn to control to me. Much longer arm levers to work with. Other than that, it is all Tai Chi 101, steady base, and move with your whole body. Till you mentioned it, I hadn't thought about the breathing, but do tend to make the finish cut one long exhale. Again like Tai Chi, though most of the time we exhale moving forward, and inhale moving backward, but that can change.

robo hippy

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

Keith Tompkins

The "hone" or "don't hone" debate will probably never end...I think the way a tool is honed makes all the difference. I see turners take a pocket hone and hone a tool while holding the tool back and forth. Personally, I use a bench stone when possible, honing only one direction, and that is honing away from the edge, not towards the edge. I hone the inside of gouges with round honing stones. Experienced wood carvers are a good example....when any cut leaves white lines instead of clear, untorn grain, the tool is not sharp. I can assure you, the tool that was honed with a back and forth motion is not truly sharp. Feed rate is important also...I hone difficult wood before the last cut, and slow down the feed rate, so each cut removes less material. I guide the tool with my hand against the tool rest to help eliminate ripples, rather than just freehand. I find a slower feed rate will help remove high spots and ripples.

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#7

George Balock

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

George Balock

Reed,

Good video. There is always some thing new to learn after all these years. The one cut that I didn't see, that Keith Tomkins mentioned years ago, is using a spindle gouge with a fingernail grind on its side. I use this on almost all of my finish cuts where possible--outside of vessels and bowls, spindle work. I do this with the flute facing me and a pull cut. I get very fine shavings off of this cut. It is very similar to the bowl gouge cut with the flute facing the work.

I also agree with Keith that slow and steady wins the race.

If anyone would like to see some pics, I'll give it a try.

George

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured myrtle

#8

Re: Finish cuts on some punky maple and figured my

robo hippy

I actually have a couple of spindle gouges with a nose profile like this ) so blunt, and very little sweep, identical to the one on the fluteless gouges. I use the spindle gouge if I want to take off 1/8 or so of depth, and the fluteless gouge if I am taking cuts 'finer then frog's fur'. But grandpa, I ain't never seen fur on a frog! That's cause it is so fine'..... Yea, my grandpa actually said that....

I still have that piece of maple out in the shop, I may have to take a hone to the fluteless gouge and try it out.

robo hippy