Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Boiling wood

Posts

Boiling wood

#1

Boiling wood

Ralph Lindberg

Over the years I've boiled a fair amount of wood, and noticed the water level drop, drastically after I turned off the heat.

I didn't know what the cause is, but some people have claimed it was the wood absorbing water, other said it was water still coming off the pot due to the heat.

I did a little test this time, I rough turned some wet/green Madrone/Arbutus I left some of the rough turned wood in water, for days before I boiled. I also left some just sitting on a pallet, next to the un-turned wood.

Just before I tossed the wood in the boiler, I weighed both lots.

After boiling the wood, I let the pot cool down just like normal, then took the wood out and weighed both lots.

On average the wood that had been left in water before boiling did not change weight.

All of the wood left out in the air gained weight, on average the wood gained 5%.

Just to be clear how wet the wood (Madrone) was. Before turning the wood had been simply left outside (in the rain/fog/sun/etc). But I was constantly wiping sap and water off my mask or safety-glasses, there was a constant stream of water running down the tool, and the lathe ways were constantly wet.

Re: Boiling wood

#2

Re: Boiling wood

Ron Bauer

Ralph, I have a stupid (to me) question. What are the benefits of boiling wood? Are those benefits enjoyed, at least in some measure, for most North American hardwoods? Thanks for your thoughts. Ron.

Re: Boiling wood

#3

Re: Boiling wood

Ralph Lindberg

Any wood that has lots of stress in the wood can benefit from boiling. While some only boil tropicals, we in the Pacific-North-Wet have learned that Madrone really does benefit from boiling.

Of course some steam or pressure cook rather then boil, but honestly boiling is easier.

I know people that boil Big Leaf Maple and Red Alder (two other local woods). But honestly my personal experience is they are so stable, why bother.

The only wood I have found that boiling may not help is Lilac. It just always wants to split and crack on me.

Re: Boiling wood

#4

Re: Boiling wood

Ron Bauer

Thanks Ralph. I have some cut offs from a massive Red Oak burl that I want to use for Spice Mills. The grain is typical (burly) but the wood has lots of mini/micro cracks. I might try a good boiling to see if that stabilizes it. Thanks for the info. Ron.

Re: Boiling wood

#5

Re: Boiling wood

Bill Howatt

I haven't done much boiling but I knew a very prolific turner who made lots of large bowls and he always boiled to reduce the chance of cracking. Boiling seems to enjoy the reputation of being a method that does reduce the chance of cracking whereas a lot of the other schemes are seen as snake-oil remedies by many.

From what I understand, if you don't boil Madrone you very likely will have severe cracking. Some wood is just more crack-prone than others.

If you do boil, make sure the pot diameter is at least 1" larger than the bowl diameter so the bowl can't form a plug in the pot and let steam build up underneath it.

Bill

Re: Boiling wood

#6

Re: Boiling wood

Don in Central Illinois

Cracking results from uneven drying in the wood. My understanding is that boiling breaks down the cells sp tbst all celks are basically equal. So when you dry them there is less chance of uneven drying. I've used this and it worked for me.

Re: Boiling wood

#7

Re: Boiling wood

Ron Bauer

I did wonder about the mechanism of boiling and what it does to the timber. For no reason I had surmised that the lignin was set by the boiling water. I heard that happens at ~180 deg (F).

Re: Boiling wood

#8

Re: Boiling wood

Hugh Buttrum

Ron,

A question: When you say the "lignin was set"..........what do you mean by "set"?

I have boiled Madrone and found that some of the sap ends up in the water. If you stick the boiling water out to dehydrate, you end up with a thick sugary syrup. Wool dyer's love the stuff.

I have also found that boiling Valley Oak does not help with the cracking of the wood.

Hugh

Re: Boiling wood

#9

Re: Boiling wood

Ron Bauer

Hugh, As I understand it, when wood is kiln died it is kept below ~160 deg to prevent what was called "case hardening". This condition was caused by the lignin somehow changing chemistry which makes the wood hard. In my simple thoughts this might help prevent cracking. As I said this stuff is way out of my league!!! Ron.

Re: Boiling wood

#10

Re: Boiling wood

Ron Bauer

Oops, I meant dried, not died. Sorry.