Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

how to tell..

Posts

how to tell..

#1

how to tell..

Phillip Medghalchi

......if a certain wood contains silica?

In a recent thread black locust was discussed as a choice for mallet.

I once got a piece of this wood & turned a bowl out of it. Although it turned out ok , I had hard time turning it not knowing it contained silica in it which resulted in my carbide blade getting dull.

On another thread I asked if my log was post oak? After some research I learned that some species of oak based on their habitat can also contain silica in them?



Main qsn. here is, if there is any visual or mechanical way to tell if a certain log would contain silica, so we would take proper cautions when attempting to turn?

Re: how to tell..

#2

Re: how to tell..

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I don't know a general method, but I've built furniture with mahogany that had lots of sicilca in it. In that case, you can often see it in the large pores, as a white powderery coating. Just chalk it up to "good sharpening practice." Another "good" place to run into silica, especially in trees that grew in hedge rows near fields, is in bark inclusions. That silica, of course, is wind blown, and not carried up through the roots.

Re: how to tell..

#3

Re: how to tell..

robo hippy

Some times it is visible, like with Ipe. When I bought a piece, the guy at the wood store said lay it down in the sun light and look at it. I did, and it sparkled. That wood has silica all through it, so that is more than wind blown, and down to microscopic particles, or maybe a chemical reaction in the tree. I didn't know that black locust had it, but that is one very hard wood. How much a piece can contain probably has as much to do with the local environment.

robo hippy

Re: how to tell..

#4

Re: how to tell..

Phillip Medghalchi

Reed that piece came from up the road in Vancouver. I was it aware of which problem I was facing with, hardness or silica.

Re: how to tell..

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: how to tell..

Brad Vietje

I've turned Black Locust for various projects and didn't have any issues like this, though it is really tough wood, and probably a great choice for mallets. Turns nice when green, and polishes up very nice when dry. If it were not for the odd greenish color it settles into after the bright yellow fades away, I think it would be a much more popular woodworking choice. Tree trunks also tend to be pretty gnarled, fluted, and odd-shaped, so saw mills would probably have a lot of waste compared to a smooth round straight log.

This tip won't apply in San Antonio, but for wood from more northern locations, be careful about roadside trees -- which might be easy to get for turning if you approach the highway department or road commissioners, Parks & Rec folks, etc... The side that faced the road could be entirely peppered with sand and gravel bits from many years of snow plows tossing snow, slush, gravel & road salt against them -- especially those that grew along dirt roads!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT