Scraper video
Posts
Re: Scraper video
#2Re: Scraper video
jim breeden
Excellent! Question - Are you holding the scraper 90 to the bowl? I was taught to raise the rest to above the center line, and to raise the tool handle with the nose at a downward angle slightly to create the scraping action. Is it because of the grind angle on your scrapers that will allow the angle you are using?
Re: Scraper video
#3Re: Scraper video
robo hippy
Most of the time, I am holding the scraper close to level, or slightly down hill. I don't exaggerate the angle. On the outside of the bowl, I am working below center, and on the inside, I am working above center. In both cases, if there is a catch, it allows the cutting edge to 'fall out of the wood'. I have a 70 degree bevel on them, which is pretty close to what was on them when I got them. Can't remember if the scrapers from Doug Thompson have a 60 or 70 degree bevel.
robo hippy
Re: Scraper video
#4Re: Scraper video
jim breeden
I have found if I am inside the bowl, and work above center line, I will get a catch. Maybe my scraper is not heavy enough to reach?
Re: Scraper video
#5Re: Scraper video
robo hippy
Well, I can't really say why you are getting catches when doing that. I was mentoring yesterday, and the turner was getting catches with my scrapers, and he does use them a lot at home. I could see that he was trying to take off too much, and had a little 'softness' in his grip. Not so much with his hands, but with his body and arms. You do need to develop a feel for how much you can cut, and the same goes with gouges. My lathe was a bit high for him as well. I do have some thing to ponder for a bit. One reason I prefer the 1 to 1 1/4 inch wide scrapers is because it is harder to stick too much steel into the wood at one time. I can stall my Beauty with no problem with the smaller scrapers.
robo hippy
Re: Scraper video
#6
Why don't the really fat ones work as well?
Aage Rendalen
Robo, why do you think it is that 3/8 thickness seems to work better than the really fat ones? I have a real fat Sorby scraper (3/4"?) and I can't get it to do much good. Will it help to grind the tip down to 3/8?
Re: Scraper video
#7Re: Why don't the really fat ones work as well?
robo hippy
Aage, I think there may be some confusion on terms here. For 3/8 inch thick, that is height. For width, which is the cutting surface, I prefer 1 to 1 1/4 maximum. I can't imagine a 3/4 inch thick scraper other than for a boring bar for deeper hollowing, and they will have tiny cutting tips on them. It does make for being able to hand out farther off the tool rest though. I have seen scrapers up to 2 inches wide, and I have heard some say it adds to stability. Most of that type are for smoothing the bottoms of platters, and have very little sweep to the nose, kind of shaped like this ). If you were to stick that much metal into a spinning piece of wood, you would most likely stall the machine. I find narrower widths easier to control, and there is less chance of getting over powered. Hope this makes more sense.
robo hippy
Re: Scraper video
#8
Re: Scraper video
Jesper, Denmark
The 1" Thompson scrapers seem to have just the right combination of thickness and heft as well as steel properties to retain a burr for a long time and not vibrate.



