Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Burnished Surface - Permanent?

Posts

Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#1

Burnished Surface - Permanent?

Doc Green

When you put a shine on a piece of wood by burnishing, is it permanent or does the shine gradually fade away over time?

Can you capture the shine by applying a film finish - sanding sealer, lacquer, or polyurethane?

For the record, three ways to burnish wood are (1) rub the spinning wood with a hand full of shavings; (2) rub the surface with the bevel of a gouge while making a cut; and (3) use dull sandpaper. There are many other ways, of course.

I would like to hear your thoughts, observations, and opinions on the benefits of burnishing. Can burnishing reduce the amount of sanding you have to do?

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#2

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

Don Orr

I guess I don't understand burnishing as a final surface. Isn't it just kind of smashing down the wood fibers? I suppose that covering it with some sort of sealer would then keep them smashed down. If you got the piece wet with water wouldn't the fibers just pop back up if not sealed? Even when wood is finely sanded, it is common to raise the grain by wetting with water and then resanding. I think that due to the hygroscopic nature of wood that a burnished surface would not stay shiny as desired without some sort of chemical assistance. Curious what others think.

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

Lyle Jamieson

I do not believe that burnishing is good. Burnishing will mask or hide the true nature of the wood. It may even leave it cloudy or milky looking. Cutting the fibers with sharp tools and sharp sandpaper allows the grain, figure, character, and color speak for the wood. It will look clean and crisp. I choose not to mask the wood with burnishing or plastic coating surface finishes.

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#4

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

Mark Wollschlager

Some consider sanding to a very high grit a burnished finish.

I have a few tops that I turned with just a very sharp spindle gouge.

The finish off of the tool looked ok to me.

They are still shiny after a few years.

The wood species may play a big part, these are Osage Orange, Jatoba, Ebony, hard woods.

I also have some Maple pieces with a sanded burnish. Still a fine finish.

It seems like finger print oils and dust will muss up the 'finish'.

These are all my pieces. Usually if I give them I use some wax or friction polish.

I think it would be hard to get a large burnished piece with a uniform 'finish'.

Others may have better luck...or not.

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#5

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

John Lucas

When I first started turning I learned to burnish. My level of finish was t what it is today. In today's terms I find it to be inconsistent or uneven and sandpaper of the proper grit is more consistent in surface quality Perhaps on small items it might be good. Can't say how it holds up because I've always applied a finish

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#6

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent? *LINK*

Jack Savona

Wish Russ were here to chime in

Application of the "no-finish"

The following is described as though the work was being done on the lathe.

Dry sand through 600-grit following the techniques described in article No. 2 of this series.

Moisten the wood surface with a "damp" paper towel that has been dipped in water and wrung dry.

Allow the wood to dry for several hours to ensure that all of the moisture has evaporated, not just that on the surface.

Lightly hand-sand with 600-grit. For a very high gloss surface, follow by hand sanding with 1000, 1500 and 2000 grits in both directions.

Repeat Steps 2, 3, and 4.

Burnish the surface in both directions with a piece of grocery-bag paper.

Apply a coating of beeswax and polish with a soft cloth or paper towel.

Just wish Russ were here.


Part of  Russ' Legacy to Us

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#7

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

John Lucas

A grocery bag isn't the same thing as burnishing with shavings. It is more like very fine sandpaper

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#8

If you burnish do you sand-

John Lucas

If so what grit do you stop at before burnishing. I got the impression we were talking about finishing the wood straight off the tool by burnishing with shavings.

Re: Burnished Surface - Permanent?

#9

Brad Vietje

...and...

Brad Vietje

...Russ told us to sand to 600 first.

In answer to Doc's original question -- in a word -- no.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT