Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Help with Raised Grain over time.

Posts

Help with Raised Grain over time.

#1

Alan Sweet

Help with Raised Grain over time.

Alan Sweet

I turned and finished some black walnut pepper mills and I was satisfied with the results. Finishing, I sanded 150 to 600, let them set for a day and ended using #0000 steel wool. Four coats of Minwax Satin Gloss poly. Complete. Smooth finish.

Fast Forward 3 months. On most of the pepper mills, the finish has that whiskery feel. The grain appears to come up. I plan to disassemble and address with steel wool and poly again.

But,

1) Is this best way to remedy?

2) Why did it happen?

3) How to avoid in future?

Alan

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Lyle Jamieson

You will get a lot of great ideas here on how to fix your torn out grain. Most of them will likely work.

I would rather not get the torn out grain in the first place. What caused it?? There is a very short list of possibilities. I can generalize and say dull tools and poor turning technique. The dull tool answer can mean sharpening techniques or poor choice of tools. The old carbide tools, not old tools, but old carbide with large particulate, is not as sharp as the newer nanograin carbide. Some cheap china made tools can say HSS right on them but they will not get sharp or hold an edge as well as good quality tool steel.

In the technique area, a slicing/sheering cut will leave a better surface on the wood than scraping. (I will get some disagreement on this point) Good tool control with bevel supported cuts is important. Grain orientation is key in tool control. The direction of the cut is always changing so grain direction is very difficult to figure out. I assume the pepper mills were done in spindle mode so the cuts need to always, ALWAYS, go from large diameter to small diameter on a spindle.

Your sanding sequence can contribute to your problem, since the grain roughness developed with age. I assume you used dull sandpaper and/or skipped grit too far between numbers. The result of poor sanding techniques is to burnish the wood, mushing over the fibers with dull sandpaper. It looks OK for a while but the torn out grain problem is only being masked, its still there to raise its ugly head in the future. Sharp sandpaper is the key to a good finish. But better yet don't get the torn out grain in the first place. Get some help trouble shooting your tool control. It makes turning a lot more fun and requires a lot less sanding.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#3

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

don stephan

My suggestion is first to share the information with customer service at Minwax. It is very hard for me to imagine that grain could raise through the finish after it is cured.

Just for completeness, did the roughness suddenly appear after 3 months or develop gradually?

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#4

Alan Sweet

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Alan Sweet

I assumed it happen over time. I finished these around thanksgiving, let them set for about 2 weeks and then packed them away to be available for a show. Just took the time to build up some inventory. When I got some plastics cases, I moved items to them. That was when I noticed that some of the mills felt whiskery.

I have checked them further and it does only occur in the end grain areas.

But, thank you for the suggestion of contacting Minwax. It is worth a try. I am sorry to say that most of my interfaces with product people has not been pleasant. I've pretty much given up on them for any help. But, there is always a chance.

Alan

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#5

In addition to Lyle's observations, .....

JamieDonaldson

....being able to reverse the lathe for sanding in both rotation directions is a big help in smoooooooothing the grain. Sanding sealer also helps with cutting the fuzzies as you sand down to final grits.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#6

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Dick Coers

How much time between the coats and how long before it went into a plastic bag? I'm thinking it was not cured, and out gassing in the bag, you have some kind of solvent pop issue.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#7

Alan Sweet

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Alan Sweet

About 8 hours between coats.

They were not put in plastic bags, I've had problems with plastic bags and heat in past and avoid them. I use crumbled up butcher paper as a filler and cushion.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#8

Alan Sweet

Re: In addition to Lyle's observations, .....

Alan Sweet

I agree about the reverse on a lathe. I wish I had it. But I don't so it takes me longer having to reverse a pepper mill for each sanding grit.

BTW, I had no tear out.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#9

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

robo hippy

I would think that the sanding would be the culprit. If your tools are really sharp, they cut very cleanly in spindle grain orientation. If you are sanding in only one direction, then the fibers will lay down, and the first time the humidity goes up, they pop up as well. A frequent habit for a lot of wood workers is to wet the wood to raise the grain, then sand it again. Reverse sanding helps, and it takes only minimal revolutions, just a touch.

If the finish seals it like with a marine type varnish, or that thick stuff they put on bar tops, you probably won't get enough moisture into the wood to make the grain pop up. Most wipe on poly type finishes don't seal that well.

robo hippy

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Keith Tompkins

Alan, A sharp spindle gouge or skew chisel will cut end grain so smoothly with good technique that no sanding is required at all. My "ten essential cuts" demos covers this topic...Number one essential cut: end grain with a spindle gouge, because I find so many turners have trouble with this. Don't use a parting tool for end grain cuts. One other thought...was your wood thoroughly dry?

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Mike Stafford

I, too, was wondering if the wood was thoroughly dry.

This end grain feathering you are describing; is it on the ends of your peppermills or just on the exposed end grain in the various coves and beads along the surface of the exterior of the peppermill?

I have seen this phenomenon occur on walnut myself on some of my walnut boxes. I think in my case the cause is bruising where I rode the bevel a little too vigorously while cutting a curve and compressed the fibers which then spring back as humidity causes the wood to react to the environment. It only happened occasionally and only on walnut.

I think sharper tools and relief on the bevel combined with less vigorous "riding" helped in my situation.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#12

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

Ron Bauer

Alan, In addition to all the above great advice I do one additional thing on my mills. I hand sand with the grain. It only takes a few minutes and I have never had a grain problem. I think it also improve the chatoyance (sp?) of the wood. Also thoroughly blow out all dust from the surface. A lot of loose dust can get stuck in the pores so a good blow out helps. Ron.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#13

Alan Sweet

Thanks Mike

Alan Sweet

Yes, the wood is dry.

Since you suggested, I looked at the effected mills closer. The end grain feathering occurs mainly in long cove areas, or long arc areas.

I would not have observed that if you had no mentioned it.

So, I may have been too aggressive in final cuts in those areas. Good thought. I'll definitely remember next time.

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#14

Alan Sweet

Thanks Ron


Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#15

Alan Sweet

I assume that to remedy..

Alan Sweet

I can disassemble, mount on lathe, using steel wool or 600-800 grit paper, get rid of dust and apply a few coats of poly.

This should address the issue?

Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: I assume that to remedy..

Keith Tompkins

Can you load pictures for us to view? That would help....again, cutting rather than scraping should solve your problems. Since I don't know your tools or techniques, at this point one can only guess. You ARE cutting downhill I can assume?