Re: Help with Raised Grain over time.
Lyle Jamieson
You will get a lot of great ideas here on how to fix your torn out grain. Most of them will likely work.
I would rather not get the torn out grain in the first place. What caused it?? There is a very short list of possibilities. I can generalize and say dull tools and poor turning technique. The dull tool answer can mean sharpening techniques or poor choice of tools. The old carbide tools, not old tools, but old carbide with large particulate, is not as sharp as the newer nanograin carbide. Some cheap china made tools can say HSS right on them but they will not get sharp or hold an edge as well as good quality tool steel.
In the technique area, a slicing/sheering cut will leave a better surface on the wood than scraping. (I will get some disagreement on this point) Good tool control with bevel supported cuts is important. Grain orientation is key in tool control. The direction of the cut is always changing so grain direction is very difficult to figure out. I assume the pepper mills were done in spindle mode so the cuts need to always, ALWAYS, go from large diameter to small diameter on a spindle.
Your sanding sequence can contribute to your problem, since the grain roughness developed with age. I assume you used dull sandpaper and/or skipped grit too far between numbers. The result of poor sanding techniques is to burnish the wood, mushing over the fibers with dull sandpaper. It looks OK for a while but the torn out grain problem is only being masked, its still there to raise its ugly head in the future. Sharp sandpaper is the key to a good finish. But better yet don't get the torn out grain in the first place. Get some help trouble shooting your tool control. It makes turning a lot more fun and requires a lot less sanding.