Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Post Oak log

Posts

Post Oak log

#1

Post Oak log

Phillip Medghalchi

Hi, every one. I tried to search this site to see if there are any posts about Post Oak wood or tree. Can not locate anything that's recent and the one I found can not pull the picture any more (2005, post).

I just went to a friend who lives in Central TX today to visit and he told me about this Post Oak tree that his neighbor cut and he saved it for me.

I got there and I found thsi huge log) I think it weighs about little more than 1000 Lbs.

I was ready to cut it in half and cut some blank out of it and haul it back to 100+ mls back home, but either my chain was dull or the dirt on it plus the hardness of this wood defeated me. So I left it behind with my trailer to go back in the near future to see if we can take it to a mill and have the guy cut it so, it would be manageable to handle.

Here is my qsn., has anyone of you perhaps in S. TX or Central TX, or anywhere else has ever turned Post oak and is it something to work with? Is it hard to use tools on, or crack easily crack? the wood grain pattern is very promising and it appears it has some spalting going on in it already.

My curiosity is if it's worth going through the trouble to mill this log and would it yield something to work with, or should I leave it alone and have my friend use it for BBQ.

I have worked with Live Oak burl before and that darn tree's wood is like working with concrete, although I managed it, however it took me a good while.

I am trying to save my back and going form my house to the friends land and back more than 200+ miles.

Any advise would be appreciated.


Sorry, for the picture, I am not sure why I didn't take the picture during the day light. It dawned on me as I was leaving after sun down and you know how it goes in the country, it gets pitch dark.

I may be able to ask him to take a photo tomorrow and send it to me for clarification, but I am not sure if he knows how. The log dia. is more than 36" sitting on its side, so when yo look at it. it's really large enough that we have to use come along to lead it on back of the trailer if I do not cut it down on the site.

Re: Post Oak log

#2

Re: Post Oak log

John Stegall

Phillip, call James Johnson. It makes pretty good firewood also.

Re: Post Oak log

#3

Steven Antonucci

look at www.liamflynn.com for oak turning


Re: Post Oak log

#4

Re: Post Oak log

darrin hill

I've never had success with oak or cedar.. it just cracks..

but then to me oak is oak... not sure if blackjack oak, live oak, water oak, post oak, pin oak, or random name inserted here but is still an oak oak, is different for turning or is oak just not a great wood ...

as someone once said.. turning crappy wood does not a good turning make...

i think it was yoda...

Re: Post Oak log

#5

Re: Post Oak log

Keith Newton

I'm not so sure your ID is right. I think the color is lighter gray, more scaly, and the wood is very rot resistant.

This looks to me to be something like Water or Willow Oak, both reds, and very prone to decay.

I don't think I would waste my time on that wood, if someone offered to bring it to me. But your mileage may differ.

Re: Post Oak log

#6

Re: Post Oak log

Phillip Medghalchi

Darrin, I believe, that just because you had hard time with one or it didn't turn out what you wanted it to be, and it cracked; should you write them off.

I only turned few live oak pieces and the one I showed you when you visited was a live oak burl which every one who's seen it liked it. Granted that live oak is as hard as rock to turn. My qsn. was merely to find out if it was worth my time to deal with such a large log. When I stood next to it to saw it darn thing was as high as hip and I think my main problem was the chain which was not sharp enough.

I do not have the proper experience with sharpening the chain on a chain saw and i tried to do it with the files I bought for that purpose and I think I got in a hurry and didn't do it right. some one once told me that I have to grind down the tooth in between the cutting gullets to prevent it from not cutting. Which of course needs some practice to get that under my belt. the other factor for failing ot ct it to manageable size was we were racing against time before it got too dark.

I got a call form my friend who said he managed to get it on to my trailer, and I have to try to get a sharp chain to see what's under neath.

I'll report later what I find out.

Re: Post Oak log

#7

Re: look at www.liamflynn.com for oak turning

Phillip Medghalchi

Steve, thanks for the link I watched it and man his pieces out of those oaks look very beautiful. I noticed that maybe the secret is to work on them while wet to get a better cut.

I hope some one will chime in if they have worked with it.

Of course, when I return to pick up my trailer from my friend (with a sharp chin for the saw) I'll find out what it has in store for me. worse it can happen that I will cut it up for him for fire pit.

i noticed that there were lots of pecan trees around which I told my friend to keep an ey out for them should someone cut hem down.

Re: Post Oak log

#8

Re: Post Oak log

John Lucas

Oak is a great wood. I don't turn much of it because it rusts the lathe and any other metal surface the green wood touches, almost instantly. Still I think it turns well and love the look of the piece when I'm done. Love to turn kiln dried oak and use it for lots of things.

There are more than 80 species of Oak. A tree expert once told us this and took us through the woods to show how to identify them. He was a logger. He said that by the time they get to the truck they are down to about 5 or 6 species and by the time it comes out of the mill it's either Red Oak or White Oak. Cracked me up but he's exactly right.

The only Oak I've had trouble turning was either the stump which has lots of silica or even stones, or barn wood that was extremely hard on tools until you got through the gray outer layer then it turns like normal kiln dried oak.

Re: Post Oak log

#9

Re: Post Oak log

Curt Stivison

John,

I had a logger tell me the same thing about 2 weeks ago when I ask him about an oak log that was on his mill. He told me it was red oak and it the lumber industry there is only 2 kinds of oak. Red or White.

Curt

Re: Post Oak log

#10

Re: Post Oak log

Barry Irby

You can take a piece of oak, say 3/4 by 3/4 and maybe four inches long or longer and stick one end in water and the other in your mouth and blow bubbles through it. If its red oak. If its white oak you can't blow through it. I have done this on several occasions to prove the flooring I was repairing was red oak. I have not tried it with sopping wet wood.

Re: Post Oak log

#11

Re: Post Oak log

John Jordan

Try it with a piece of white oak, Barry. Post a video of it. White oak cells (tylose?) are sealed and you can't blow through it. That's why whiskey barrels are made of white oak-so the whiskey won't leak out. :O :D

Green white oak is about as easy and fun to t :D urn as any wood there is.

John

Re: Post Oak log

#12

Re: Post Oak log

Phillip Medghalchi

Well friends, I finally got my friend to figure out how to send me the picture they took next day from this log. I hope you can help me to identify it.

BTW, I can not get it in my possesion until maybe next week.

On the left side of this picture what you see is not a crack it's the uneven cut form the saw. On the other side of the log ther is a nice crotch I am trying to cut through.

My friend said that it maybe blackjack Oak?

http://texastreeid.tamu.edu/content/TreeDetails/?id=99&t=O

Re: Post Oak log

#13

You can blow out a sinus....

Barry Irby

trying to do it with white oak.

I knew they made whiskey barrels out of white oak. They make whiskey or bourbon in new ones and then they sell them to the scotch makers and they use them again to make scotch. And now I hear they are aging beer in them.

The char on the inside of the barrels caramelizes the sugars in the wood and that imparts the color and some of the flavor to the contents. Makes you wonder who figured that out?

I will have to try some green white oak. Thanks for that info. I took some of the tree I cut up (for lumber) to the turning club. I had made blanks out of the cutoffs. Some of the old timers turned up their noses and said, Nobody turns oak! (Insert a bad French accent) I was donating the blanks to the silent auction fund raiser. Ended up I gave them to the one guy who wanted them.

Re: Post Oak log

#14

old timers

darrin hill

"Some of the old timers turned up their noses and said, Nobody turns oak! (Insert a bad French accent) "

and so do most of the old people here... i told phil that new turners come to our group showing off oak bowls and they bring chunks to give away at raffles.. and the old timers use the said item they won for firewood...

so why do old people not like oak? I just don't like the cracks...

d

Re: Post Oak log

#15

Re: old timers

Clifton C



I'm not an old-timer yet, so I still turn free wood. This is fumed white oak, 16x11.5. Free as in a full day out on the wood lot in August...Didn't seem so free the next day when I was feeling like an old timer...

cc

Re: Post Oak log

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: Post Oak log

Brad Vietje

Phillip,

I certainly know zippety-squat about trees in Texas, but do be careful about the vines climbing up the trunk. They could be absolutely harmless, but Poison Ivy often climbs trees like that and it's not just the leaves that can get you. I'd remove those vines with gloves until you are sure what it is.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Post Oak log

#17

Re: old timers

Barry Irby

I turned a winged bowl out of an red oak limb we pruned off a tree in the yard. Took it with me to a sale, not to sell it, but to have it to fill up the table. Had a very slow day. the best sale of the day was the winged bowl. A guy kept coming back offering me more and more until I let it go.

Re: Post Oak log

#18

Re: old timers

Phillip Medghalchi

Cliff, I'd take that oak any day. That's some beautiful piece you got there.

Re: Post Oak log

#19

Re: Post Oak log

Phillip Medghalchi

Brad, thanks for the advise as always. The first order of bus. Is to powr sand all the sands and dirt off it before I do anything else. I will definitely look into that. Thanks for reminder me about that as a city boy have no idea how that earn poison oak looks like. I sure don't want that on my skin.

Re: Post Oak log

#20

Re: You can blow out a sinus.... *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Personally, I love White Oak. Red is trash wood and rots quickly. White Oak is a workhorse. The tannins will rust your lathe bed, but you can have some real fun (safely) fuming Oak with HOUSEHOLD ammonia. The trick being to insure you are using an air-tight container and also giving the piece a MUCH longer exposure time. (I use a 40 gallon Igloo cooler. Works great.) Liam Flynn, Irish turner known for his dual rimmed bowls/vessels, uses oak on a regular basis.

One of my earliest turnings was a candlestick for those large 3" diameter candles that was made from White Oak with a 1/4" thick strip of Yellowheart laminated down the center. I fumed it to a nice chocolate brown using household ammonia. Nothing especially wonderful about the turning, but the coloring is great and fuming really lets the grain shine through.


Liam Flynn