Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT: Outlet Safety

Posts

OT: Outlet Safety

#1

OT:  Outlet Safety

jim breeden

While investigating a "hot" smell in the house, I discovered it coming from the powder room. My wife had plugged in one of them wax / light thingees in the outlet - the kind that get hot, melt the wax and send a vaporized scent through out the house. Ugh! I unplugged it, and a spark jumped out of the outlet. I made a mad dash and turned off the GFI circuit for the baths. After removing the outlet cover I found the hot lead had melted about two inches of the insulation, and welded itself to the contact screw. I had also installed one of those foam insulation pads behind the face plate, as recommended by whomever recommends those kind of things, it had also melted. The GFI did not trip. I tested the circuit, and the GFI operated as normal. At this point, I do not know which item caused this very near disaster - the smelly wax thingee, or the foam pad. I ripped out all the other pads from the remaining outlets, just in case. The only hot wax thingee in the house was in the powder room . SUGGESTION: If you have any of these things attached to an outlet, pull that sucker out and throw it as far as you can!

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#2

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Don Evans

Jim, I agree, those things are cheaply made and should not be trusted with life and property.

Throw them all away.

Now to discuss the problem a bit, I hate to give guesses to these, possibly serious, problems but calling it a thingey doesn't give much to go on does it?

A short some how in that perfumer caused it to over heat and melt the insulation and I'm unsure what screw it shorted too but I am concerned that the GFCI didn't trip the breaker, but they also go bad. Pressing the test button is good idea once a month but it isn't 100 percent that the unit will work correctly.

How they work is this, they have a "comparator" inside them the monitors the current going out on the black (hot) wire and looks for that same amount to return on the white wire. If their is a very very small difference in the 2 measurements the breaker should trip. If part of the current In this case when to ground instead of returning on the white wire then you also have a bad GFCI.

It sounds in your message like you have a GFI breaker the way you worded your message not a GFCI outlet but I would replace it which ever it is.

The foam I'm thinking is one of those that stops drafts at the outlet from getting into the house. I don't see how it could be at fault in this case.

Don

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#3

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

jim breeden

I called it a thingee so as not to use non-complimentary words here on Web Central. When I pulled the hot wax perfumer out of the outlet is when a spark followed it, and the plastic around the insert (?) hole was slightly melted. The GFCI circuit breaker for all the baths is located in the breaker box in the garage, and was not tripped. I did install a new outlet, reset the GFCI, and everything seems alright. Maybe I need a new GFCI circuit breaker?

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Brad Vietje

Hmmm... not good. Is this on a sub-panel? Sub panels should have grounds and neutrals separated, while main panels should be bonded, but many houses are wired by contractors who don't know that. I've found a lot of 1.25" green screws in the bottom of boxes because the GC didn't know what to do with it. Might not be relevant, but I'm wondering if the GFCI went bad due to poor grounding? I would get a new one, and good idea to test it now and then.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#5

Re: OT:  get a gfci tester

Rum

One something like this:

http://www.amazon.com/Amprobe-ST-102B-Socket-Tester-GFCI/dp/B008E07HM2

There are a number of different ones out there, this one is reasonably complete for most common miswiring situations. It won't catch everything and isn't infallible but it does a bit better job of testing the gfci than the button does since it actually causes a fault at the outlet.

Having said that it's possible to have arc fault problems and the gfci won't fire for those in many/most cases because the fault is not to ground but between the two conducting wires. You can get arc fault interrupt breakers (and combination arc fault/gfci breakers) and they are actually required for new installations for breakers in certain rooms (bedrooms at least, maybe more) because of the prevalence of faulty equipment in this rooms (bedside lamps, clock radios, etc) and the problem of proximity to where you sleep so you don't have as much time to escape if a fire does happen.

I suspect that you did in fact have an arc fault problem in the scent thingy so of are that fixing that fixed it.. However the $10 tester is an easy and cheap way to cross check that the wiring is at least nominally OK (again there are still a lot of conditions it can't detect, but those start requiring real equipment that costs $$$).

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Jesper, Denmark

A GFI only works if the short or leak is to ground. It will not react on overload - that is what the breaker or fuses are for. Sounds to me like a faulty breaker, not a ground fault.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#7

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Barry L Elder

Our local firefighters began spreading the word about fire hazards from certain "smell thingys" a while back and said that a growing percentage of house fires were being caused by them. Also said that if the wifey insisted on her "smell thingys" then each outlet should have one of the GCFI? outlets that have their own breaker, not a single breaker somewhere else. Licensed electricians have gained a lot of extra business in the interest of fire safety. Of course, it could have been local hysteria.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#8

Brad Vietje

Not Only THAT...

Brad Vietje

...but are you sure you want to actually BREATHE some sweet smelling concoction cooked up in China with exceeding lax food- and consumer-safety laws -- or none??? Do we have any idea what is in those things -- or if they have been tested adequately ?

I borrowed my son's truck a few months ago, and he had one of those smelly things mounted in one of the air vents, and it lasted about 15 seconds before I tossed it in the bed. No WAY do I intend to breathe that crap!

Want it to smell nice -- put a pan of water on the stove with a pinch of cinnamon in it and allow it to simmer (but don't forget it and burn your house down!!!).

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#9

Re: stock breakers might not trip on arc faults

Rum

which is why they introduced afci beakers.

http://www.afcisafety.org/qa.html

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#10

Re: stock breakers might not trip on arc faults

Bill Howatt

If there was no leakage to ground then a GFI won't do anything. The Arcfault breaker has a better chance but if is just a solid overheating, ie, not looking like something arcing, it won't trip. A standard breaker will pump 1800W into the little plastic thingy without thinking it is doing anything wrong and that'll melt it for sure.

Several years ago there was a particular model that was flagged as a fire hazard and it was sold by a large, well-known American firm (I think I know but since I don't know for sure I won't mention it.)

Given their small size and construction these things seem to be potential fire risk at the best of times.

Bill

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#11

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I assume you are saying that the hot wire welded itself to the terminal it was supposed to be connected to, NOT to a ground terminal. If true, I agree with Bill, the GFI should not have tripped. My guess is that the hot terminal screw was a bit loose and thus making a resistive contact with the wire and in turn heating everything. Pulling the gizmo out of the receptacle moved things enough to cause the arc.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#12

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

jim breeden

Thanks to everybody. There are three GFIC breakers in the main panel, of which one is dedicated to the baths, one for the garage, and one for the outside outlets. I do have a tester and it proved all connections correct. The three individual breakers are not "standard" to code, as this was what I requested when we had the house built, just for safety purposes. I know a GFI snaps off when the ground is interrupted, but I would think it would also shut off when something else happens - like when the hot lead melted and fused itself to the side of the outlet, and creating enough heat internally to overload internally? I'm not an electrical expert by any means, just thinking maybe ....................?

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#13

Re: stock breakers might not trip on arc faults

Rum

Yep I wouldn't be surprised to see the plastic thingys explode into flames occasionally.

Although in this case it sounds like it was the wire behind the outlet itself that was overheating.. Hmmmm...

I guess that brings up the question as to what gauge of wire is it, how long is the run and what is the breaker amperage? A poorly chosen combination (where poorly is occasionally subtle) can cause issues of this sort.

I can't say the insulation wouldn't have been a contributing factor as it would reduce the ability of the plenum around the wire to dissipate heat (which is why we have all the conduit fill rates, etc.. which are different but related problems) - but the observed behaviour does seem perhaps a bit extreme based on the reported data.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#14

You're right, I think!

Bill Howatt

I re-read the original post and while he did yank the thingy and throw it away, he didn't say that it was a melted blob burning away.

The arc he saw when pulling it out which could be caused by interrupting the current to the device. However, I imagine this current really would be very small which should not have made a big arc.

The fact that the wire had burned back insulation and was welded to the screw indicates the problem was most likely a poorly tightened screw which turned into a connection with some resistance and thus heated due to the current flow into the thingy.

The foam insulator for the plate really should not have caused any excess heating due to the minimal insulation they provide. These things are normally used on exterior walls to stop drafts. The amount of heat generated by the current, even a 15A flow, inside a box would be very, very small if all the connections were good. I think box fill is more of a physical damage issue than a heating issue.

Bill

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#15

Re: You're right, I think!

jim breeden

Reading through all your replies, the loose screw was probably the most likely culprit. The outlet and the wiring is as what was installed when the house was built. When I pulled out the hot wax smell generator it was hot, hotter than normal (?) - what ever is normal for these things. I'm still going to install a replacement circuit breaker in the main panel, just to be safe. Thanks all for the words and advice.

Jim

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#16

Re: You're right, I think!

Rum

Electrical issues are complicated :D

One other thing I thought of when considering the wire<->outlet connection is to double check is the wire type and make sure its not aluminium. If its aluminium you'd want to pig tail it back out with an approved connector:

http://www.cpsc.gov//PageFiles/118856/516.pdf

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#17

Re: You're right, I think!

jim breeden

Nope, not aluminum. House is only 9 years old.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#18

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety - Electrician

Rik, WI

Have you considered having a licensed electrician check things out?

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#19

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety - Electrician

Barry Irby

You have gotten good advice. As a Home Inspector I see things like this regularly.

The Device you wisely threw away is clearly a fire hazard. I see them with towels hanging on them from the towel rack above. Foolish.

The GFCI will not respond to a heavy current draw or to arcing. The Breaker part of it will only respond if the draw is greater than its rating.

An AFCI will respond to the arcing, but not to the heavy draw unless it exceeds its rating.

Arc Faults (AFCI) are common in bed rooms in newer houses (required by code). As far As I know, they are made as breakers only, not outlets, and they are available as a combination AFCI, GFCI breaker.

I strongly suspect you had a poor connections and the melted wax device pulled enough current to cause it to arc and weld itself and over heat the the jacket on the wire. Probably a loose screw or poorly made connection.

I use the circuit tester or one like it daily. They are good, but not the end all be all. It would not have detected the poor connection. There are conditions where it will not trip a properly wired GFCI. The manufactures suggest Pressing the button is an adequate test. I do both.

Hopefully replacing the outlet cured the problem.

I Don't think the foam gasket was part of the problem, but it might be good if they have low flame spread and don't contribute fuel to the potential fire. (something to research.)

The outlet you fixed was getting hot inside the wall and the device you threw away was disguising that by putting out heat of its own. You can find poorly wired receptacles with a very sensitive infrared thermometer or a thermographic camera. Or the back of your hand. If the outlet is loaded and it gets hot, there's a problem.

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#20

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Don Evans

Unfortunately as seems to be the cause there is some misleading and just plain wrong information in some of there post.

Jim understand that a GFCI has nothing to do with the green wire ground circuit. They are separate in independent of each other.

I'll say it again, the GFCI (ground fault circuit interuptor) the use of the word ground causes a lot of confusion but the safety ground circuit is separate and serves another purpose.

The spark when you unplugged (in this case) I would not worry about, its not unusual. When things went wrong inside this thingy it became shorted and was drawing too much current so it was able to jump the gap as you pulled the wire out of outlet.

Back to the GfCI -- current coming into the outlet on the black wire returns on the white wire and they should be the same amount if they are not the GFCI should trip the breaker. I've seen circuits wired incorrectly in homes and no one was the wiser till something like this points it out.

You should make sure that outlet IS INDEED on one of the GFCI breakers.

Put a tester in the outlet or a lamp and turn it on. Go turn off the breaker and make sure the lamp goes out, go back and turn breaker back on and check to make sure lamp came back on.

You could get surprise and find that outlet is on another breaker.

One last thing for understand purposes: on the gfci if the current on the black wire and the white wire do not match there is an assumption made that the missing current is going through a human and it shuts down the circuit.

You have a serious enough problem here and you have limited knowledge about how all this work CALL AN EXPERT AND HAVE IT CHECKED OUT!!!

Be safe not sorry!

Don

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#21

OH thanks for warning of these devices


Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#22

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

Bill Howatt

I agree with your post except that a better test, or at least an additional test, is not to turn off the breaker but to push the Test button on it. My old Square-D GFI breaker had a big yellow test button on it.

I don't use breakers now but rather find the first outlet in the circuit and put in a GFI receptacle and protect the others with the downstream terminals. Lot cheaper than the breaker and in the case of my old Square-D the receptacles are spec'd to trip with less fault current. However, if the first outlet is in an illogical location it may not be as convenient to find and reset as a breaker in a panel.

Bill

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#23

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety

jim breeden

Don, the GFCI circuit for the baths is presently turned off at the main panel. I called an electrician and he will be here Tuesday.

And, I would like to thank everyone for their advice, and knowledge of an event that should not have happened. I have never liked those hot wax smelly perfume things anyway. What a way to learn of a near disaster!

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#24

I agree; thanks for the warning

GaryG in MD

I have seen those things in my daughter's house.

I just warned her off them.

Good tip! ...GG

Re: OT: Outlet Safety

#25

Re: OT:  Outlet Safety - Electrician

jim breeden

Electrician was here today. Checked everything out from here to there - nothing out of the ordinary. He was kinda surprised at what happened, especially after looking at the outlet I saved as show and tell. His prognosis - the hot wax perfume heater was improperly assembled, which led to the problem. He inspected all three of the GFCI circuits, and they tested within specifications. He said that he does not trust those kind of things, and would recommend to anyone to "get rid of it". 'nugh said! :b