Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

hollowing problem

Posts

hollowing problem

#1

hollowing problem

eliot felman

I hollow a lot, but I'm having a weird problem. This form is about 9 in deep, and I started out drilling a 3/4 inch hole all the way to the bottom. Everything went well until I got to about 1 1/2 inches from the bottom. I'm using a straight boring bar in a restraining rig with a laser setup,and I am simply trying to cut away the last inch or so. The cutting edge of the tool is just slightly to the left of the center line (in fact 3/8 to the left where I can feel the edge of the 3/4 in hole.) What is happening, sometimes, when I try moving the tool to the left, is that the tool wants to rotate in the wrong direction-- clockwise! I thought, perhaps I had the height of the cutting edge too high or low. But I checked, and it's dead center. If I don't figure this out, I just know that the back of the bar, where the opening is, is going to slam against the thin opening of the form and ruin the piece. Please help if you can!

Re: hollowing problem

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: hollowing problem

Dennis in Southern Oregon

What kind of cutter are you using and how is it oriented?

Re: hollowing problem

#3

Re: hollowing problem

Don Evans

My GUESS is the cutter must be contacting the right side of the drilled hole.

With no more to go on, that is all that could do what you describe.

Remember the drill made the hole concave at the bottom not flat. Does that help or make sense to you?

Don

Re: hollowing problem

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: hollowing problem

Ric Taylor

Did you accidentally reverse the lathe?

Re: hollowing problem

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: hollowing problem

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Don, that is my guess too. I expect he is using a side cutting tool that is more than 3/4 inch wide overall. At shallower depths with the bar at an angle there is ample clearance, but at full depth with the bar nearly straight in, the right edge contacts the edge of the bore hole.

Re: hollowing problem

#6

This is a tough one!

Doc Green

Try as I may, I cannot envision anything that would cause the tool to rotate clockwise, or opposite to the direction of rotation of the piece. Even if you touch the tool to the right-hand side of the 3/4" opening, the rotation would still tend to be counter-clockwise.

Here is a possibility. If you are working near the bottom of a 9" hollow form, the tool will be extended "pretty far" over the tool rest. If the cutter is taking a bite more than about 3/16" wide, the downward force could be enough to cause some flexing of the bar, which would let the cutter move downward.

With the cutter set initially at dead center, it will tend to take a deeper cut as it moves downward. Soon thereafter, it will reach its limit and break out of the cut, springing back to dead center, or above, and the process will be repeated. The result will be a severe vibration and could possibly give the perception that the tool is trying to rotate clockwise.

My suggestions are, first, be sure that no part of the cutter holder is contacting the wood, which would only confuse the issue. Then raise the cutter about 1/8" or so above center so that if the bar flexes, the cutter will tend to move out of the wood rather than into it. Finally, and most importantly, be sure that the cut is no more than about 3/16" wide. (You didn't say what type cutter you are using. Can you re-grind it for a narrower cut?)

This may not totally eliminate the vibration (caused by flexing of the bar), but it will almost certainly reduce it, hopefully, enough so you can finish the piece.

Good luck, ~Doc

Re: hollowing problem

#7

Re: This is a tough one!

eliot feldman

I kind of figured it out, and you all have confirmed what's going on. I managed to cut the inside bottom of this form into something slightly heart-shaped, in that the bottom slopes down a bit from the center. The shape of the cutter is convex and flat on top like the bow of a ship. So, I'm pretty sure what happened is that the cutter, when started 3/8 from the center line at the edge of the 3/4 in hole, and moving to the left, started the cut on the left edge of the cutter. Then as it moved to the left, the cutting edge began to meet the wood more and more to the right side of the cutting edge, in effect as some have said, beginning to cut the edge of the hole on the right side of the cutter. This action really doesn't make the tool revolve clockwise, but it does make in suddenly rotate, twist, about its long center line in a clockwise direction (looking down from the tail stock), and that creates a sudden twisting and snapping kind of vibration that feels as if the tool is actually revolving backwards. And it does jerk the back of the bar around and threaten breaking the thin opening. What I believe I have to do is get a cutting edge down there that can't cut on its right side. I'll either grind something or maybe use my Berg tool. I do believe there may be a lesson here that goes beyond just my particular problem this time. I believe many hollow turners often have a problem with that little nub that usually forms at the bottom center. And this issue isn't that different.Thanks for your help.

Re: hollowing problem

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollowing problem

Lyle Jamieson

Eliot, please answer the questions above so we can be more specific, to help you. 3/4 diameter boring bar?? cutter size, mouth opening, cutter type, manufacturer of hollowing system. I would suggest the system is not set up correctly. The cutter must be parallel to the floor and cutting on or above the center line. When you have the cutter twisted downward to the left, the right side of the cutter is tilted up and would get a catch and pull to the right or clockwise. Go to my web site and look at my installation instructions as if you just purchased my system. Use my set up instructions to set your system up correctly. Some hollowing systems have built in obstacles that will not allow the correct positing of the cutter. If that's the case you are stuck. As suggested the deeper you get into the vessel the more exaggerated the difficulty will be. 9-10 inches is approaching the limit of any 3/4 inch boring bar.

Re: hollowing problem

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: This is a tough one!

Lyle Jamieson

You are hollowing in a 3/4 inch hole?? With what size boring bar?? Set up correctly you should be able to make any shape vessel and or bottom shape you might want. I don't follow what cutter you are using, can you take a photo??

Re: hollowing problem

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: This is a tough one!

Brad Vietje

Ahhh.... This is what I suspected when I read this very late last night, but I wanted to sleep on it, and allow a few others to comment.

Lyle is "Da Man" here, but my approach would be to clean up the profile with a much smaller straight-ahead, in-line cutter -- 3/16" or 1/4" (which would have a negligible moment of torque), before cleaning up the ridges with a broader and wider cutter -- if needed at all.

I've fooled myself into thinking I was cutting away from a drilled hole at center, when in reality, I had created a moat around a raised edge of the drilled hole -- if that makes any sense at all. In defense of Lyle and his hollowing system (and systems like his), this should only happen if you are blind hollowing without the laser in place, since the laser would let you see that you were not at center at all. I get lazy and stupid at times and try hollowing the bottom of a taller form without taking time to set up my hollowing rig, and this can sometimes happen. Turns out, it would have saved time and stress to have used the stabilized boring bar right from the start ! I think that's why these brilliant systems were devised in the first place 8)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: hollowing problem

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: This is a tough one!

Lyle Jamieson

Thanks Brad, I agree. The trick to keep from getting a "mote" is to keep the cutting action to the left. Start in the drill hole and push to the left. I rarely make the cut pushing toward the headstock. The second thing is to get the cutter EXACTLY on the center line when the drill hole is gone and you are cleaning up the bottom shape.

Re: hollowing problem

#12

Re: hollowing problem

eliot feldman

Sorry about replying to my own post. I tried to solve the problem with the Berger Tool. It worked perfectly for a while, confirming what was going on. The Berger tool only cuts on the left side. But I made the mistake of continuing to hollow with it. I believe I moved too far over to the left of the form so that the back of the tool started touching the small opening and slammed against it after a small catch. I should have simply corrected the problem area and then switched back to the usual hollowing tools to finish. The piece blew up -- actually fairly rare for me. The back of the Berger tool hit against the thin opening and cracked it up. I did learn how to sharpen the Berger Tool, which I don't use much, and which did work well for this problem until I got careless. Life in the hollowing lane!

Re: hollowing problem

#13

that was my thought too!  ;-)


Re: hollowing problem

#14

please bring the pieces to the next meeting

GaryG in MD

It will be instructive for us to see exactly what happened to the HMeister!

...GG