Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Raising Grain ?

Posts

Raising Grain ?

#1

Raising Grain ?

Don Orr

When I turn kitchen utensils I wet them completely and let them dry before a final fine sanding and oiling. Has anyone ever done this with utility bowls or think it's necessary?

Re: Raising Grain ?

#2

Re: Raising Grain ?

Dick Coers

I'll do it on some species to whisker the grain, especially soft maple, but often do it to help reveal if I have missed any sanding scratches.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#3

Re: Raising Grain ?

Bill Howatt

I only do wetting to raise the grain if I'm going to use a water-based finish and for turning my use of them is infrequent.

OTOH, I often wonder if there is a little grain-raising, perhaps microscopic, even with oil-based finishes.

With the different formulations of commercial finishes appearing on the market these days, your treatment may be a good idea for some.

Bill

Re: Raising Grain ?

#4

Re: Raising Grain ?

John Lucas

Hmmm. Never thought of that even though I routinely raise the grain when using min was wipe on poly. I've made several spoons salad forks and rolling pins and don't remember raising the grain on those. Interesting thought. Ill follow this thread.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#5

Spritz and let dry

jeff Willaford

I give my turnings (most woods but not all) a spritz with a spray bottle then let them dry. Raising the grain before final sanding seems like the thing to do. Utility or display...either way.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#6

Re: Raising Grain ?

john Veerkamp

We've had several purchased utensils. After some use they all had raised grain. light sanding and re-oiling really helped. I'd raise the grain as you thought. Better to be safe.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Raising Grain ?

Keith Tompkins

HI Don, I wet nearly everything I turn, and in my furniture days I wet most flat surfaces. Wetting will bring deep sanding marks near, sometimes even above the surface, making them easier to remove with finer grits. The improvement in appearance is obvious.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#8

Re: Raising Grain ?

Ralph Lindberg

I don't do it with bowls, but I do with rolling-pins

Re: Raising Grain ?

#9

Re: Raising Grain ?

Phillip Medghalchi

Don, last year I did few of my bowls that way with idea ofkepping the dust under control. I did this at lower grits on up to 180 grit. Surprisingly, this caused Avery smooth, slick finish after all done. Once I would get to 320 and above grits the process went very smooth. Of course, I never thought of this procees like what you described, however, I am glad that you brought it up this way. It sure makes me think.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#10

Re: Raising Grain ?

Rum

Interesting conversation...

I've wet sanded some bowls using walnut oil (usually at 400+) with somewhat mixed results. It does yield a smoother surface quicker most of the time, but it seems to lose a bit of the grain due to the filling action unless you sand again after the oil cures (and even then not convinced it's as good). Wetting, drying and then resending would undoubtedly be better at not loosing the grain.

For treen ware this is generally the way I finish, sand up through 320-400, wet to raise the grain, sand again, and repeat a couple of times depending on the wood/intended use (going up grits as you go). Most of that sort of stuff though I'm putting no finish at all on, not even oil and definitely not wax so it might be a bit different than what you'd want to do with most bowls.

I've been playing around a little with burnishing which looks rather promising. It's pretty easy to do on the lathe with some shavings. Simple spindle turning stuff like drop spindles, nostepinnes, etc I mostly put a quick couple of coats of wax on then burnish a fairly high speed (maybe burnish before the wax to to have a polished surface to start with). I've tried this with a few bowls with surprisingly good results, almost as good as using a buffing wheel and somewhat faster (unless you have a dedicated buffing setup I guess, which I don't, otherwise the changeover time adds up).

The polissoir concept (http://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/finishing/my-introduction-to-the-polissoir-roubos-wax-polisher) is similar and somewhat intriguing. Not sure how to apply it to turning yet, or if just using shavings is as good in that context.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#11

Re: Raising Grain ?

John Lucas

Burnishing with shavings is a very old technique. I tried it for a while but it's inconsistent if you want a really fine finish. I guess the problem is the shavings themselves are of inconsistent hardness. It gives what I call an OK finish that looks good for many things but to get a really fine finish sandpaper with known grits size is better. You don't get any extraneous lines or uneven areas when you step through the grits. In this case I think it's simply that good sandpaper has a very consistent grit size so each successive one eliminates the scratches from the next.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#12

Joe Fleming

Re: Raising Grain ?

Joe Fleming

I raise the grain on nearly everything I make from wood, before final sanding. I sand through the grits. Before the final grit, I typically wipe the piece with a damp paper towel and let it air dry before sanding with the finest grit.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#13

Re: Raising Grain ?

Rum

Yeah, most of what I do could be generously called "functional" or "utilitarian" so it often works well enough for that.

How well it works also does depend on the type/quality of wood and the texture of the shavings as well. In the best cases the surface has rivaled sanding to around 1500-2000 with no visible flaws, in the worst case not so much.

One of the big problems (or benefits depending on your perspective) with burnishing is that it compresses the softer grain some so especially on woods with distinctive growth rings you'll get noticeable ripples between the rings. Sort of like what can happen if you over sand at a single to fine grit. Not a huge issue on woods with fine and more consistent structure. For some utilitarian things the texture can actually be kind of a nice feature if that's what you're into.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#14

Re: Raising Grain ?

John Lucas

It really causes problems if you need to stain the wood. The end grain compresses differently than the side grain and you get a really noticeable difference in how they take the stain. If I have to stain work I often sand the end grain to higher grit if I can. This is easy on flat wood but not so easy on turned wood. Sanding to a higher grit makes the end grain absorb the finish less and it evens out the stain.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#15

Re: Raising Grain ?

John Jordan

Try wetting the wood between every grit. I start after carving/filing-it helps to pop out the scratches and damage, and in the finer grits, it lets you see where to sand. Its really hard to tell where to use your 400 grit-it looks pretty much like 320, wetting takes care of that. I also wet after the final grit, more than once if I feel any roughness or patchy spots, and after the final wetting I don't sand-it will be a perfect flat/velvety surface with no burnishing streaks etc. Perfect for any finish.

Wet means lightly wet the surface, not flooding or soaking.

John

Re: Raising Grain ?

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Raising Grain ?

Keith Tompkins

Good information John. I use files and rifflers to refine or straighten my carved lines, also sandpaper glued to strips of veneer. I sand surfaces with foam-back flexible paper such as Klingspor, avoiding using just my fingers. I feel the flexible paper helps distribute the pressure more evenly on the surface.

Re: Raising Grain ?

#17

Re: Raising Grain ?

John Jordan

I use 1/8 thick sticks, like paint sticks, and thin leather glued on. I use sticky back paper on these. This will cushion it just a little, and you can use dowels and other shapes when needed.

JJ

Re: Raising Grain ?

#18

Thanks everyone for the input!

Don Orr

Your feedback and experiences are very appreciated. I have some process evaluation to do now.