Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

Posts

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#1

Aage Rendalen

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

Aage Rendalen

It was only when I tried my hand at thread cutting that I came to realize that my spindle doesn't run true: it runs out about 1 millimeter (drive spur tip wabbles around a fixed spur tip in the tail stock). So, what to do?

I checked that all set screws on the drive shaft and the spindle were tight. I can't feel any play in the spindle. Yet it wobbles ever so much.

Are there any You-tube videos or instructions on replacing the spindle (I suppose that's the only way to remedy a situation like this?)? If so, is this something I should mess with myself?

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#2

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

John Jordan

Its probably a bad center, or the taper and center don't mate due to galling, wood chip etc.

BUT! Even if your spindle was inaccurately machined, whatever you have mounted can only be turned can only be turned true. True your workpiece to size before threading. Save your money. :)

John

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#3

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

John Lucas

It's difficult to tell if the spindle is wobbling using a center. Ideally you need to find someone with a dial indicator. The spindle can be running true and still throw the threading off if the spindle is angled in the headstock or the headstock not aligned. I have this problem with my powermatic and had many discussions with Vic from best wood tools. He finally helped me understand how a spindle that runs true but is angled with respect to the bed of the lathe will throw off the threads. When I put the box on the threaded and move the cutter up to just touch the wood I would have to advance the cutter .008" for it to cut all the way around. I thought it was his machine but he measured his threaded and it was virtually dead on so it had to be the lathe. Since then I have used other lathes and they all vary. It doesn't seem to hurt the threaded boxes. All my kids fit and not a single customer has noticed. If you cut a full depth threw it will be pointed on one side and flat on the other. I don't typically do this because it leaves a weak thread if its pointed

As John said dirt or any galling on the morse taper inside or out will throw the center off. Screw a couple of faceplates or chucks on. Move your tool rest up real close and watch the gap as you rotate the spindle by hand. Or even better measure the gap with a feeler gauge. You can also try the same thing by measuring the gap at the spindle shoulder.

Don't assume it's the spindle bent or warped until you have an accurate way to measure it.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#4

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

John Lucas

Sorry for the typos. Hope you can get through them. It's very hard to preview everything when typing on my phone

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#5

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle *LINK*

Bill Howatt

Get a dial indicator.

You don't need an expensive high-quality Starret. Here is one:

http://www.harborfreight.com/1-inch-travel-machinists-dial-indicator-623.html

You probably can get a magnetic base for it for about the same money.

They are great for all sorts of WW tool checking and setting not to mention eliminating a lot of anatomy scratching when something seems amiss.

Bill


Dial Indicator

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#6

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

robo hippy

When you say you are cutting threads, are you hand chasing them, or using one of the X Y type jigs (Klein, Baxter, or other)? I ran into the same thing with my Klein jig. The threaded shaft that the box was mounted on had a tiny bit of bend in it, which I found by rolling it across my table saw top. I got another shaft and it took care of most of the problem. If your lathe runs pretty true with a chuck on it, then the main spindle is not the problem.

robo hippy

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#7

Aage Rendalen

How do you mount it?

Aage Rendalen

Thanks for the tip. How do I mount it? On the tool rest?

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#8

Aage Rendalen

I'll get a dial indicator

Aage Rendalen

Thanks for your advice. I haven't actually tried cutting any threads yet because of the wobble I observed. Yesterday, I tried my MT2 tapered Jacobs chuck and a new screw version on Barbara Dill's PM lathe, and the wobble was hardly observable, so I assume the problem is my spindle. I'll clean out the spindle and try again today, as well as get a dial indicator.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#9

Re: I'll get a dial indicator

Ron Bauer

Aage, Try to always blow out the spindle (head or tail) before inserting a taper. As said any small chip will throw things off. If you ever had a taper spin there might be a small burr inside the spindle that needs to be removed. Not a problem. You can get a #2MT finishing reamer for not much money ( I got mine at Grizz). Since you are not creating a new taper they are easy to use, just follow the directions, such as NEVER turn it in reverse and use a drop of light oil. I've touched up mine several times. Just my TCW. Ron.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#10

Re: How do you mount it?

John Lucas

You can buy a magnetic mount very Inexpensive. You can the. Stick it to the lathe bed and adjust the indicator to get a reading. Then just rotate the spindle with it touching. I would actually measure the inside of the morse taper. After you clean it of course. The outside of the spindle collar may or may not tell you much. The face of the spindle collar should run true.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#11

Re: How do you mount it?

Bill Howatt

Any place that allows it to reach the place you want to measure and is stable. You can make a wood base to hold it and clamp the base down to the bed or banjo. Easiest way is to buy a magnetic stand for it. They have lots of adjustment and you just put it on the bed and turn a level which "activates" the magnet.

Main thing is that it is stable and doesn't move - not a problem because the force to move the needle is very tiny.

Billh

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

Keith Tompkins

Hi Aage, just a thought....I've seen several turners pound the spur center into the stock with a hammer, resulting in a mushroomed morse taper, and a galled spindle. Hope that's not the case...

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#13

Aage Rendalen

Tested dial indicators today

Aage Rendalen

Keith, I didn't heat my shop today and hence I only fiddled with my dial indicator I bought yesterday from HF. My first spindle reading indicates no run-out. It was too cold for me to rig up the indicator properly and I didn't stay long enough to clean out the spindle and deburr it (if needed), but that might be what is needed.

And no, never have pounded in a spur before. Seen it done, but early on I read books that said it warn't the thing to do.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#14

Re: Tested dial indicators today

John Lucas

I doubt this is your problem since early on you said your spindle rotated around the center of the tailcenter but since the 3520 is a sliding headstock it can be very easy to swing the tailstock out of alignment very slightly. Mine fits pretty good but whenever I lock the headstock down I bias it toward the front bed way so that it aligns the same way everytime. Same is true for the tailstock. My tailstock has more slop than the headstock and can really throw a long drill bit off center unless locked in the front way position.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#15

Aage Rendalen

Cleaning out the spindle helped

Aage Rendalen

Cleaning out the spindle took care of 95 percent of an already limited wobble. Glad to have heeded you all's advice.

Re: Re: Replacing PM3520 spindle

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tested dial indicators today

Keith Tompkins

That's great! A mushroomed drive center could ruin you day!