Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels
Dennis in Southern Oregon
A problem with grinder start-up after installing CBN wheels was reported on another forum. An internal fuse would blow during start-up of a variable-speed grinder “rated” as 0.5 HP. While other factors may have been involved, it occurred to me that the larger mass of a CBN compared to a “stone” wheel , and the fact that much of it is concentrated at the outer edge of the wheel, may have been the root cause. I decided to investigate further. I weighed an 8-inch by 1-inch AlO wheel and an 8-inch by 1.5-inch D-Way CBN wheel using a postal scale and got the following results: ALO = 3.7 lb, CBN = 6.2 lb, a rather striking difference. If one takes into account the distribution of the weight in the CBN wheel, the difference is even more striking.
Dragging out my ancient Engineering Mechanics 101 textbook, I calculated the mass moments of inertia of the two wheels and an estimate of that of the rotor and shaft of the 0.5 HP motor of my grinder. (Mass moment of inertia is the quantity that resists the acceleration of the motor during start-up.) The results were as follows. The total MMI for two ALO wheels plus the rotor/shaft is 72 units while the total for two CBN wheels plus the rotor/shaft is 148 units. Therefore, a grinder with CBN wheels will accelerate about half as fast during start-up as one with ALO wheels.
Aside from slightly delaying the tool grinding process, this does not appear to have been a problem with most grinders. I have successfully used CBN wheels on both a Delta 0.5 HP grinder and a Rikon 0.5 HP low-speed grinder. However, if the grinder motor has a marginal starting torque, the high starting current may cause time-delay fuses to burn out or breakers to trip or, conceivably, overheating of the motor.
This is not intended to be a slam on CBN wheels. I like my CBN wheels very much, and if I encountered the above problem, my solution would be to replace the grinder with one known to be compatible. It should be noted that max horsepower in itself is not the issue here. Max horsepower is developed under load at near maximum speed and is not affected by the choice of wheel. The light touch required when sharpening woodturning tools could be served with a motor much smaller than 0.5 HP. The issue is starting torque and starting current draw, which are only roughly related to max HP. Also, beware that some manufacturers take a rather loose interpretation of “max horsepower”.



