Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

Posts

Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#1

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

Dennis in Southern Oregon

A problem with grinder start-up after installing CBN wheels was reported on another forum. An internal fuse would blow during start-up of a variable-speed grinder “rated” as 0.5 HP. While other factors may have been involved, it occurred to me that the larger mass of a CBN compared to a “stone” wheel , and the fact that much of it is concentrated at the outer edge of the wheel, may have been the root cause. I decided to investigate further. I weighed an 8-inch by 1-inch AlO wheel and an 8-inch by 1.5-inch D-Way CBN wheel using a postal scale and got the following results: ALO = 3.7 lb, CBN = 6.2 lb, a rather striking difference. If one takes into account the distribution of the weight in the CBN wheel, the difference is even more striking.

Dragging out my ancient Engineering Mechanics 101 textbook, I calculated the mass moments of inertia of the two wheels and an estimate of that of the rotor and shaft of the 0.5 HP motor of my grinder. (Mass moment of inertia is the quantity that resists the acceleration of the motor during start-up.) The results were as follows. The total MMI for two ALO wheels plus the rotor/shaft is 72 units while the total for two CBN wheels plus the rotor/shaft is 148 units. Therefore, a grinder with CBN wheels will accelerate about half as fast during start-up as one with ALO wheels.

Aside from slightly delaying the tool grinding process, this does not appear to have been a problem with most grinders. I have successfully used CBN wheels on both a Delta 0.5 HP grinder and a Rikon 0.5 HP low-speed grinder. However, if the grinder motor has a marginal starting torque, the high starting current may cause time-delay fuses to burn out or breakers to trip or, conceivably, overheating of the motor.

This is not intended to be a slam on CBN wheels. I like my CBN wheels very much, and if I encountered the above problem, my solution would be to replace the grinder with one known to be compatible. It should be noted that max horsepower in itself is not the issue here. Max horsepower is developed under load at near maximum speed and is not affected by the choice of wheel. The light touch required when sharpening woodturning tools could be served with a motor much smaller than 0.5 HP. The issue is starting torque and starting current draw, which are only roughly related to max HP. Also, beware that some manufacturers take a rather loose interpretation of “max horsepower”.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#2

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheel

robo hippy

Dennis,

Nice to see the science behind what I already had kind of figured out. Add to that, not all hp ratings match the actual out put, and you can get all sorts of different out put of power. I consider 1/2 hp to be minimal, and 3/4 to be better. My old blue no name grinder that Woodcraft used to carry has much less actual power than my slow speed Baldor 3100.

robo hippy

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheel

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Reed, this is all a funny kind of dance. It involves both starting current draw and starting torque. You would like lots of torque with little current draw and you get that only with good design of the motor to fit the application. Just changing to any old larger motor would not necessarily improve the situation. Sadly, some vendors use the "one set of specs fits all" approach and go for the cheapest source.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#4

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheel

Rjstavran

I give my cbn wheels a spin with my hand before switching it on. Max speed is attained quickly and it sounds like the motor is less stressed.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Minor correction

Dennis in Southern Oregon

In my analysis, I weighed and measured my 80-grit CBN wheel and tacitly assumed that the 180-grit wheel was the same. However, on inspection, I find that the rim of the 180-grit wheel is slightly thinner than the 80-grit wheel. Therefore, the total MMI of an 80-grit and a 180-grit CBN wheel and the rotor/shaft turns out to be 134 units rather than 148 units previously stated. This small difference in no way changes my conclusions.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#6

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheel

Bill Howatt

Very good method and not unlike the loaded big-rig drivers who slow down for a red light well in advance - they want to keep the truck moving no matter how slowly. Accelerating from a snail's pace crawl is a lot easier than starting from a dead stop.

Bill

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#7

HP ratings

Ralph Lindberg

More and more firms are giving the HP rating for their "X" as power consumed vrs power generated at the shaft.

An immediate example is the new G0766 Lathe from Grizzly. Which they "rate" at 3HP. When you go to the Burt Co (the actual supplier) they rate the motor as 3HP power consumed but only 2HP produced at the shaft.

Of course then there are the firms that rate their motor by some kind of peak instantaneous power: i.e. how much power is available for a nano-second when you apply a load.

Or how you get 2HP from a 120V@15amp motor circuit.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#8

I do the same thing.

Donna Banfield

I have 2 grinders. One has 2 CBN wheels, an 80 grit and 180 grit. I give the wheels a spin by hand before turning on the switch.

Re: Grinder Start-up Considerations with CBN Wheels

#9

Re: HP ratings

Roger Chandler

Ralph......related to this hp thing, and the earlier conversation we had on hp related to the G0766.......it is evident by the wattage rating that 3hp is going in to the inverter, so it is a 3 hp motor. On other brands do inverters that take three phase power also reduce it down.......is this a common thing with input and output regardless of brand......say Jet & PM? Since the Burt Group does manufacture for PM and Jets as well as Grizzly, my guess is that they likely apply the same principles to all brands they manufacture?

Related to the grinders........this would not apply because they are basically single phase motors........so hp rating might be able to be played with a little more by motor manufacturers...........